Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Government Decrees / On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk and Inspection Checklists in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites

On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk and Inspection Checklists in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk and Inspection Checklists in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites

Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on July 25, 2016 under No. 13979.

Note. The title is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 6, 2020 No. 113 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 6, 2020 No. 37 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

In accordance with paragraphs 5 and 6 of Article 141 and paragraph 1 of Article 143 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, WE HEREBY ORDER:

Note. The preamble is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 4 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 2 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

1. To approve:

1) the criteria for assessing the degree of risk in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, in accordance with Appendix 1 to this Joint Order;

2) the inspection checklist in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with respect to licensees engaged in scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments, in accordance with Appendix 2 to this Joint Order;

3) the inspection checklist in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with respect to licensees engaged in archaeological works, in accordance with Appendix 3 to this Joint Order;

4) the inspection checklist in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with respect to local executive bodies of the capital, regions, cities of republican significance, districts (cities of regional significance), owners and/or users of historical and cultural monuments, individuals or legal entities, in accordance with Appendix 4 to this Joint Order.

5) the inspection checklist in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with respect to local executive bodies of the capital, regions, cities of republican significance, districts (cities of regional significance), individuals or legal entities, in accordance with Appendix 5 to this Joint Order.

Note. Paragraph 1 is worded as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

2. To declare invalid the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 25, 2015 No. 225 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 7, 2015 No. 503 “On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk of Inspected Entities in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites and the Form of the Inspection Checklist” (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 11851, published on August 26, 2015, in the Adilet Legal Information System).

3. The Department of Culture and Arts of the Ministry of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall, in accordance with the procedure established by law, ensure:

1) state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

2) within ten calendar days from the date of state registration of this Order, submission to the Republican State Enterprise on the Right of Economic Management “Republican Center for Legal Information of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan” of copies of this Order in paper and electronic form, certified by the electronic digital signature of the person authorized to sign this Order, for official publication and inclusion in the Reference Control Bank of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the State Register of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;

3) placement of this Order on the website of the Ministry of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan within ten calendar days after its official publication;

4) within ten working days after completion of the measures provided for in this paragraph, submission to the Department of Legal Services of the Ministry of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan of information on the implementation of the measures.

4. Control over the implementation of this Joint Order shall be entrusted to the Vice-Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan overseeing the relevant area.

5. This Joint Order shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication.

Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan __________ A. MukhamediulyMinister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan __________ K. Bishimbayev

Agreed

Chairman of the Committeefor Legal Statisticsand Special Recordsof the General Prosecutor's Officeof the Republic of Kazakhstan

____________ S. Aitpayeva

June 24, 2016

| | Appendix 1 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites

Note. Appendix 1 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 4 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 2 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Chapter 1. General Provisions

1. The Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with paragraphs 5 and 6 of Article 141 and paragraph 1 of Article 143 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, as well as in accordance with Order of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 31, 2018 No. 3 “On Approval of the Form of the Inspection Checklist” (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 17371) and Order of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 22, 2022 No. 48 “On Approval of the Rules for the Formation of the Risk Assessment and Management System by Regulatory State Bodies and on Amendments to Order of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 31, 2018 No. 3 ‘On Approval of the Rules for the Formation of the Risk Assessment System and the Form of Inspection Checklists by State Bodies’” (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 28577), and are intended for selecting entities (objects) subject to control in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites and assigning them to risk categories when the authorized body in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites (hereinafter referred to as the authorized body) and local executive bodies of regions, cities of republican significance and the capital (hereinafter referred to as local executive bodies) conduct preventive control with a visit to the entity (object) subject to control.

2. The following basic concepts are used in these Criteria:

1) control entities – individuals and legal entities, including local executive bodies, whose activities are subject to control in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites;

1-1) control objects – property owned by or otherwise lawfully held by a control entity and subject to control;

2) minor violations – violations of requirements established by regulatory legal acts in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, relating to the land-use regime within the protection zones, development regulation zones and protected natural landscape zones of historical and cultural monuments of local significance;

2-1) point – a quantitative measure of risk calculation;

3) significant violations – violations of requirements established by regulatory legal acts in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, relating to the installation of monumental art structures, the land-use regime within the protection zones, development regulation zones and protected natural landscape zones of historical and cultural monuments of international and republican significance, the conditions for maintaining historical and cultural monuments specified in protection obligations, as well as the adoption of measures having a harmful impact on the preservation of historical and cultural monuments;

4) gross violations – violations of requirements established by regulatory legal acts in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, relating to compliance with the conditions for conducting scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments, the conditions for carrying out archaeological works and licensing of such activities, the lawful relocation and alteration of historical and cultural monuments, as well as the adoption of measures having a harmful impact on the preservation of historical and cultural heritage sites and historical and cultural monuments, resulting in deterioration of their condition up to and including their complete destruction;

4-1) data normalization – a statistical procedure involving the conversion of values measured on different scales to a common conditional scale;

5) risk – the probability of causing harm as a result of the activities of a control entity to the legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities and the property interests of the state, taking into account the severity of its consequences;

6) criteria for assessing the degree of risk – a set of quantitative and qualitative indicators related to the direct activities of a control entity, the specific features of sectoral development and factors affecting such development, which make it possible to assign control entities (objects) to different degrees of risk;

7) objective criteria for assessing the degree of risk (hereinafter referred to as objective criteria) – criteria for assessing the degree of risk used to select control entities (objects) depending on the degree of risk in a particular field of activity and not directly dependent on an individual control entity (object);

8) subjective criteria for assessing the degree of risk (hereinafter referred to as subjective criteria) – criteria for assessing the degree of risk used to select control entities (objects) depending on the results of the activities of a particular control entity (object);

9) risk assessment and management system – a decision-making process aimed at reducing the probability of adverse factors occurring by distributing control entities according to degrees of risk for the subsequent implementation of preventive control with a visit to the control entity and/or inspections for compliance with qualification requirements, with the aim of imposing the minimum possible restrictions on entrepreneurial freedom while ensuring an acceptable level of risk in the relevant fields of activity, as well as aimed at changing the risk level for a specific control entity and/or exempting such entity from preventive control with a visit to the control entity and/or inspections for compliance with qualification requirements;

10) inspection checklist – a list of requirements imposed on the activities of control entities (objects), non-compliance with which entails consequences for the legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities and the state;

11) sample population (sample) – a list of assessed entities (objects) assigned to a homogeneous group of control entities (objects) in a specific area of state control, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 143 of the Code.

Note. Paragraph 2 as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

3. For fields of activity of control entities (objects) classified as high risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with qualification requirements shall be determined by the criteria for assessing the degree of risk, but no more than once a year.

For fields of activity of control entities (objects) classified as medium risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with qualification requirements shall be determined by the criteria for assessing the degree of risk, but no more than once every two years.

For fields of activity of control entities (objects) classified as low risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with qualification requirements shall be determined by the criteria for assessing the degree of risk, but no more than once every three years.

Note. Paragraph 3 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

4. The basis for scheduling preventive control with a visit to an entity (object) subject to control shall be a semi-annual list of preventive control with a visit to an entity (object) subject to control, approved by the first head of the state body.

5. Lists of preventive control with a visit to an entity (object) subject to control shall be drawn up taking into account the priority of control entities with the highest degree-of-risk indicator under the subjective criteria.

6. Criteria for preventive control with a visit to an entity (object) subject to control shall be formed using objective and subjective criteria.

Chapter 2. Procedure for Forming the Risk Assessment and Management System When Conducting Inspections for Compliance with Qualification Requirements and Preventive Control of Control Entities (Objects)

7. For the purposes of risk management when conducting inspections for compliance with qualification requirements and/or preventive control with a visit to an entity (object) subject to control, criteria for assessing the degree of risk for conducting inspections for compliance with qualification requirements and preventive control of control entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria, which shall be carried out in stages (Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis).

At the first stage, control entities (objects) shall be assigned to one of the following degrees of risk based on objective criteria:

1) high risk;

2) medium risk;

3) low risk.

With respect to a control entity (object) classified as high or medium risk, inspections for compliance with qualification requirements, preventive control with a visit to the entity (object) subject to control, and unscheduled inspections shall be conducted.

With respect to a control entity (object) classified as low risk, unscheduled inspections shall be conducted.

At the second stage, control entities (objects) shall be assigned to one of the following degrees of risk based on subjective criteria:

1) high risk;

2) medium risk;

3) low risk.

Note. Paragraph 7 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

8. Based on the priority of the information sources used and the significance of the indicators of subjective criteria, in accordance with the procedure for calculating the degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria specified in Chapter 3 of these Rules, the degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 points.

Based on the degree-of-risk indicators under subjective criteria, a control entity (object) shall be classified as:

1) high risk – where the degree-of-risk indicator ranges from 71 to 100 inclusive;

2) medium risk – where the degree-of-risk indicator ranges from 31 to 70 inclusive;

3) low risk – where the degree-of-risk indicator ranges from 0 to 30 inclusive.

Note. Paragraph 8 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

9. Depending on the possible risk and significance of the issue, the isolated or systematic nature of the violation, and the analysis of previously adopted decisions for each information source, subjective criteria shall be determined which, in accordance with the criteria for assessing the degree of risk established by the regulatory state body, correspond to the degree of violation – gross, significant and minor.

At the same time, the definitions of gross, significant and minor violations shall be established in the criteria for assessing the degree of risk of the authorized body for the protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, taking into account the specific nature of the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites.

When forming subjective criteria, the degree of violation (gross, significant, minor) shall be assigned in accordance with the established definitions of gross, significant and minor violations.

10. Criteria for assessing the degree of risk for conducting inspections for compliance with requirements and preventive control of control entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria.

Control entities that have fully eliminated the violations identified following the previous preventive control with a visit and/or inspection for compliance with requirements shall not be included when drawing up schedules and lists for the next period of state control.

11. The risk assessment and management system shall be maintained using digital systems that assign control entities (objects) to specific degrees of risk and generate schedules or lists for conducting control measures, and shall also be based on information tools.

In the absence of a digital risk assessment and management system, the minimum permissible threshold for the number of control entities (objects) in respect of which preventive control with a visit to the control entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with requirements are conducted shall not exceed five percent of the total number of such control entities.

Note. Paragraph 11 is worded as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Paragraph 1. Objective Criteria

12. In the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites, the following shall be classified as high risk for the purposes of control exercised by the authorized body:

1) local executive bodies;

2) licensees holding a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments and for activities involving archaeological works;

3) individuals and legal entities who are users and/or owners of historical and cultural monuments.

The following shall be classified as high risk for the purposes of control exercised by the local executive body:

1) structural subdivisions of local executive bodies carrying out activities involving the protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites;

2) individuals and legal entities who are users and/or owners of historical and cultural monuments.

Individuals and legal entities who are users and/or owners of historical and cultural monuments shall be classified as medium and low risk.

Note. Paragraph 12 as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Paragraph 2. Subjective Criteria

13. The determination of subjective criteria shall be carried out using the following stages:

1) formation of a database and collection of information on violations of requirements established by regulatory legal acts in the field of protection and use of historical and cultural heritage sites;

2) analysis of information and risk assessment.

14. The formation of a database and collection of information are necessary to identify control entities (objects).

For the purpose of assessing the degree of risk in order to conduct preventive control with a visit to the control entity, the following information sources shall be used:

1) results of previous unscheduled inspections and preventive control with a visit to control entities (objects).

For the purpose of assessing the degree of risk in order to conduct inspections for compliance with qualification requirements, the following information sources shall be used:

1) results of previous inspections;

Note. Paragraph 14 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

15. Assessment of the degree of risk of control entities and their classification into groups according to gross, significant and minor degrees of risk shall be carried out in accordance with Appendices 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 to these Criteria.

16. Analysis and assessment of subjective criteria make it possible to concentrate inspections for compliance with requirements and preventive control of the control entity on control entities (objects) with the highest potential risk.

At the same time, during the analysis and assessment, data on subjective criteria previously taken into account and used in respect of a specific control entity (object), or data for which the limitation period has expired in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, shall not be applied.

Chapter 3. Procedure for Calculating the Degree of Risk Based on Subjective Criteria

Note. The title of Chapter 3 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

17. The following procedure for calculating the degree-of-risk indicator shall be applied to classify a control entity according to its degree of risk in accordance with paragraph 8 of these Criteria.

The state body shall collect information and form a database based on subjective criteria from the sources specified in paragraph 14 of these Criteria.

The degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria (R) shall be calculated by summing the degree-of-risk indicator for violations based on the results of previous inspections and preventive control with a visit to control entities (objects) (SP) and the degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 8 of these Criteria (SC), followed by normalization of the data values to a range from 0 to 100 points.

\[ R_{\text{intermediate}} = SP + SC \]

where:

Rintermediate – intermediate degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria;

SP – degree-of-risk indicator for violations;

SC – degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 8 of these Criteria.

The calculation shall be carried out for each control entity (object) belonging to a homogeneous group of control entities (objects) and for each area of state control. At the same time, the list of assessed control entities (objects) belonging to a homogeneous group of control entities (objects) in one area of state control shall constitute a sample population (sample) for subsequent data normalization.

Note. Paragraph 17 is worded as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

18. Based on data obtained from the results of previous inspections and preventive control with a visit to control entities (objects), a degree-of-risk indicator for violations shall be formed and assessed on a scale from 0 to 100 points.

If one gross violation is identified based on any of the information sources specified in paragraph 14 of these Criteria, the control entity shall be assigned a degree-of-risk indicator of 100 points, and an inspection for compliance with qualification requirements or preventive control with a visit to the control entity (object) shall be conducted in respect thereof.

If no gross violations are identified, the degree-of-risk indicator for violations shall be calculated as the total indicator for significant and minor violations.

A coefficient of 0.7 shall be applied when determining the indicator for significant violations.

This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:

\[ SP_z = (SP_2 \times 100 / SP_1) \times 0.7 \]

where:

SPz – indicator of significant violations;

SP1 – required number of significant violations;

SP2 – number of identified significant violations.

A coefficient of 0.3 shall be applied when determining the indicator for minor violations.

This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:

\[ SP_m = (SP_2 \times 100 / SP_1) \times 0.3 \]

where:

SPm – indicator of minor violations;

SP1 – required number of minor violations;

SP2 – number of identified minor violations.

The degree-of-risk indicator for violations (SP) shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 points and determined by summing the indicators for significant and minor violations using the following formula:

\[ SP = SP_z + SP_m \]

where:

SP – degree-of-risk indicator for violations;

SPz – indicator of significant violations;

SPm – indicator of minor violations.

The resulting degree-of-risk indicator for violations shall be included in the calculation of the degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria.

Note. The Criteria were supplemented with paragraph 18 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

19. The degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria, determined in accordance with paragraph 8 of these Criteria, shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 points using the following formula:

Image

xi – indicator of the subjective criterion;

wi – specific weight of the subjective criterion indicator xi;

n – number of indicators.

The resulting degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria, determined in accordance with paragraph 8 of these Criteria, shall be included in the calculation of the degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria.

Note. The Criteria were supplemented with paragraph 19 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

20. The values of indicator R calculated for control entities (objects) shall be normalized to a range from 0 to 100 points. Data normalization shall be carried out for each sample population (sample) using the following formula:

Image

R – final degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria for an individual control entity (object);

Rmax – maximum possible value on the scale of the degree of risk under subjective criteria for control entities (objects) belonging to one sample population (sample) (upper limit of the scale);

Rmin – minimum possible value on the scale of the degree of risk under subjective criteria for control entities (objects) belonging to one sample population (sample) (lower limit of the scale);

Rintermediate – intermediate degree-of-risk indicator under subjective criteria calculated in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria.

Note. The Criteria were supplemented with paragraph 20 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

21. For the purposes of exemption from preventive control with a visit to the control entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with qualification requirements, regulatory state bodies, as well as state bodies, shall take mitigating indicators into account.

Note. The Criteria were supplemented with paragraph 21 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

| | Appendix 1 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Results of Previous Inspections and Preventive Control with a Visit to Control Entities (Objects)” for the Authorized Body

Note. Appendix 1 as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1Absence of a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments and activities involving archaeological worksgross
2Existence of facts of unlawful relocation and alteration of a historical and cultural monument of international and republican significancegross
3Existence of facts of violations of the land-use regime within the protection zones, development regulation zones and protected natural landscape zones of historical and cultural monuments of international and republican significancesignificant
4Existence of facts of violations of the rules for installing monumental art structuressignificant
5Existence of facts of violations of the conditions for maintaining a historical and cultural monument of international and republican significance specified in protection obligationssignificant
6Existence of facts of violations of the rules and conditions for conducting scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments of international and republican significance and the rules and conditions for carrying out archaeological worksgross

| | Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Results of Previous Inspections and Preventive Control with a Visit to Control Entities (Objects)” for Local Executive Bodies

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1Existence of facts of unlawful relocation and alteration of a historical and cultural monument of local significancegross
2Absence of archaeological works aimed at identifying historical and cultural heritage sites during the development of territories prior to the allocation of land plotssignificant
3Existence of facts of violations of the land-use regime within the protection zones, development regulation zones and protected natural landscape zones of historical and cultural monuments of local significanceminor
4Existence of facts of violations of the conditions for maintaining a historical and cultural monument of local significance specified in protection obligationssignificant
5Existence of facts of carrying out works that may pose a threat to the existence of historical and cultural heritage sitesgross
6Existence of facts of violations of the rules and conditions for conducting scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments of local significance and the rules and conditions for carrying out archaeological worksgross

| | Appendix 3 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Results of Previous Inspections for Compliance with Qualification Requirements”

Note. Appendix 3 is worded as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
For activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments:  
1Availability of at least one restoration specialist with secondary technical and vocational education (restoration) and at least five years of work experience, or a research worker in the relevant specialty (architecture) with at least five years of work experience and an academic degree in this field, or a master's degree, a professional doctorate degree, or a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree.gross
2A research worker or restoration specialist employed by an organization holding a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments may not be declared by another organization when submitting an application for obtaining a license for the specified type of activity.gross
3Availability of a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments.gross
For activities involving archaeological works:  
1Availability of at least one research worker with higher education in the relevant specialty (archaeology and ethnology, history), at least five years of work experience and an academic degree in this field, or a professional doctorate degree or Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree.gross
2A research worker employed by an organization holding a license for activities involving archaeological works may not be declared by another organization.gross
3Availability of a license for activities involving archaeological works.gross

| | Appendix 4 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Availability and Number of Confirmed Complaints and Appeals Regarding Violations of Requirements in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites”

Note. Appendix 4 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

| | Appendix 5 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Results of Preventive Control Without a Visit to the Control Entity (Object) (Final Documents Issued Following Preventive Control Without a Visit to the Control Entity (Object))”

Note. Appendix 5 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

| | Appendix 6 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Analysis of Official Websites of State Bodies and Mass Media”

Note. Appendix 6 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

| | Appendix 7 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Subjective Criteria Based on the Information Source “Results of Analysis of Information Provided by State Bodies and Organizations”

Note. Appendix 7 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 132 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 31, 2023 No. 93 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

| | Appendix 2 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Inspection Checklist in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan with Respect to Licensees Engaged in Scientific Restoration Works on Historical and Cultural Monuments

Note. Appendix 2 is worded as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Name of the homogeneous group of control entities (objects) ______________________

State body that ordered the inspection __________________________________________

Inspection appointment act ___________________________________________________

No., date

Name of the control entity (object) _____________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the control entity (object) __________________________________________________________________

Location address _____________________________________________________________

No.List of requirementsComplies with requirementsDoes not comply with requirements
1234
1Availability of at least one restoration specialist with secondary technical and vocational education (restoration) and at least five years of work experience, or a research worker in the relevant specialty (architecture) with at least five years of work experience and an academic degree in this field, or a master's degree, a professional doctorate degree, or a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree  
2A research worker or restoration specialist employed by an organization holding a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments may not be declared by another organization when submitting an application for obtaining a license for the specified type of activity  
3Availability of a license for activities involving scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments  

Official(s) _________________________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the control entity ____________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

| | Appendix 3 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Inspection Checklist in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan with Respect to Licensees Engaged in Archaeological Works

Note. Appendix 3 was added to the Order in accordance with the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 6, 2020 No. 113 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 6, 2020 No. 37 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication); as worded by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Name of the homogeneous group of control entities (objects) ______________________

State body that ordered the inspection __________________________________________

Inspection appointment act ___________________________________________________

No., date

Name of the control entity (object) _____________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the control entity (object) __________________________________________________________________

Location address _____________________________________________________________

No.List of requirementsComplies with requirementsDoes not comply with requirements
1234
1Availability of at least one research worker with higher education in the relevant specialty (archaeology and ethnology, history), at least five years of work experience and an academic degree in this field, or a professional doctorate degree or Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree  
2A research worker employed by an organization holding a license for activities involving archaeological works may not be declared by another organization.  
3Availability of a license for activities involving archaeological works  

Official(s) _________________________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the control entity ____________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

| | Appendix 4 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Inspection Checklist in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan with Respect to Local Executive Bodies of the Capital, Regions, Cities of Republican Significance, Districts (Cities of Regional Significance), Owners and/or Users of Historical and Cultural Monuments, Individuals or Legal Entities

Note. Appendix 4 was added to the Order in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 4 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 13, 2023 No. 2 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication); as worded by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Name of the homogeneous group of control entities (objects)

State body that ordered the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the control entity (object) _______________________________________________________

Inspection/preventive control with a visit to the control entity (object) appointment act ______________________________________________________________

No., date

Name of the control entity (object) _____________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the control entity (object) __________________________________________________________________

Location address _____________________________________________________________

No.List of requirementsComplies with requirementsDoes not comply with requirements
1234
1Compliance with the conditions for maintaining a historical and cultural monument specified in protection obligations: 1) takes measures to ensure the preservation of the historical and cultural monument; 2) ensures access to the historical and cultural monument for scientific, educational, tourist, informational and educational purposes; 3) coordinates projects for scientific restoration works on the historical and cultural monument; 4) coordinates the relocation and alteration of the historical and cultural monument; 5) independent destruction of the historical and cultural monument is prohibited.  
2Relocation and alteration of a historical and cultural monument are prohibited.  
3Carrying out works that may pose a threat to the existence of historical and cultural heritage sites is prohibited.  
4Compliance with the land-use regime within the protection zones, development regulation zones and protected natural landscape zones of historical and cultural monuments: 1) for the protection zone of a historical and cultural monument, a special land-use regime shall be established in order to ensure its preservation and historical integrity, restricting economic activity and prohibiting construction, except for the application of special measures aimed at preserving the historical and cultural monument. No new construction works shall be carried out in the protection zone. The protection zone of a historical and cultural monument shall be marked with protection signs, a ploughed strip, fences or shrub plantings along its boundaries; 2) in the development regulation zone of a historical and cultural monument, a regime restricting construction or economic activity shall be established. Road and transport construction shall be restricted in the development regulation zone of a historical and cultural monument, and the placement of industrial and warehouse enterprises shall be prohibited; 3) activities that do not cause changes in the nature of the landscape, water supply system or vegetation shall be permitted within the protected natural landscape territory of a historical and cultural monument; 4) projects involving economic and other activities on the territories of historical and cultural monuments and their protection zones shall be subject to approval.  
5Compliance with the conditions for conducting scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments and the conditions for carrying out archaeological works: 1) scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments and archaeological works outside the plan shall not be permitted; 2) projects for scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments shall be subject to approval; 3) ensuring the historically established appearance of the historical and cultural monument, preserving and revealing the historical, architectural and artistic appearance of the historical and cultural monument, and restoring historical elements of the historical and cultural monument where there is substantiated scientific data; 4) external scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments shall not be carried out at temperatures below +5 degrees Celsius; 5) scientific restoration works on historical and cultural monuments in enclosed premises during the winter period shall be carried out with the installation of a heating device to ensure a temperature regime above +5 degrees Celsius; 6) no later than ten working days before the commencement of archaeological works, the local executive bodies of the capital, regions and cities of republican significance shall be notified of their commencement, except for works on historical and cultural monuments of international and republican significance, of which the authorized body shall be notified; 7) archaeological works shall be carried out during the time of year favorable for fieldwork. When conducting archaeological works in winter, a tent structure shall be installed above the archaeological monument or historical and cultural heritage site to ensure an optimal temperature regime (not lower than +10 degrees Celsius), as well as lighting; 8) excavation trenches laid out at an archaeological monument or historical and cultural heritage site shall have dimensions of at least 2 × 2 square meters; 9) archaeological works shall be carried out manually, and the use of transport machinery shall not be предусмотрено. 10) the use of a metal detector shall be permitted in the areas under study during archaeological works; 11) where objects containing historical architectural and urban-planning elements are discovered, their preservation shall be ensured; 12) upon completion of archaeological works, spoil shall be removed from the territory of the archaeological monument or historical and cultural heritage site, restoration of their soil cover and conservation works shall be ensured, and these processes shall be photographed. The photographs shall be attached to the scientific report.  

Official(s) _________________________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the control entity ____________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

| | Appendix 5 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 14, 2016 No. 162 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 23, 2016 No. 277 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Inspection Checklist in the Field of Protection and Use of Historical and Cultural Heritage Sites in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan with Respect to Local Executive Bodies of the Capital, Regions, Cities of Republican Significance, Districts (Cities of Regional Significance), Individuals or Legal Entities

Note. Appendix 5 was added to the Order in accordance with Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Culture and Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 412-НҚ and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 27, 2026 No. 138 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Name of the homogeneous group of control entities (objects) ______________________

State body that ordered the inspection __________________________________________

Inspection appointment act ___________________________________________________

No., date

Name of the control entity (object) _____________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the control entity (object) __________________________________________________________________

Location address _____________________________________________________________

No.List of requirementsComplies with requirementsDoes not comply with requirements
1234
1Compliance with the requirements for the installation of monumental art structures: 1) dedication to anniversaries and commemorative dates of outstanding individuals and significant historical events; 2) installation no earlier than five years from the date of death of the outstanding individual and/or occurrence of the significant historical event; 3) installation in public places owned by the state; 4) inclusion in the plan formed by the authorized body; 5) holding of a republican creative competition; 6) positive decision of the Commission for the Installation of Monumental Art Structures.  
2Compliance with the requirement to conduct archaeological works to identify historical and cultural heritage sites during the development of territories prior to the allocation of land plots.  

Official(s) _________________________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the control entity ____________________________________________________

Position Signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Resolution Decision Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Charter Convention Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Minutes Draft Program Rules Messages