Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Government Decrees / On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and Inspection Checklists for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary, Additional Education, and the Provision of Educational and Health-Improving Services to Minors

On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and Inspection Checklists for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary, Additional Education, and the Provision of Educational and Health-Improving Services to Minors

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and Inspection Checklists for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary, Additional Education, and the Provision of Educational and Health-Improving Services to Minors

Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on December 31, 2015 No. 12777.

Note. The title is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

In accordance with paragraphs 5 and 6 of Article 141 and paragraph 1 of Article 143 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, WE HEREBY ORDER:

Note. The preamble is amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

  1. To approve:
    1. risk assessment and management criteria for the education system in the areas of preschool education and training, primary, basic secondary, general secondary, technical and vocational, post-secondary, additional education, and the provision of educational and health-improving services to minors, in accordance with Appendix 1 to this Joint Order;
    2. an inspection checklist for the education system in the area of preschool education and training with respect to educational organizations implementing educational curricula for preschool education and training, in accordance with Appendix 2 to this Joint Order;
    3. an inspection checklist for the education system in the areas of primary, basic secondary and general secondary education with respect to educational organizations implementing educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education, in accordance with Appendix 3 to this Joint Order;
    4. an inspection checklist for the education system in the areas of primary, basic secondary and general secondary education with respect to educational organizations implementing educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education, in accordance with Appendix 4 to this Joint Order;
    5. an inspection checklist for the education system in the areas of technical and vocational, post-secondary education with respect to educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education, in accordance with Appendix 5 to this Joint Order;
    6. an inspection checklist for the education system in the areas of technical and vocational, post-secondary education with respect to educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education, in accordance with Appendix 6 to this Joint Order;
    7. an inspection checklist for the education system in the area of additional education with respect to children's additional education organizations, in accordance with Appendix 7 to this Joint Order.
    8. an inspection checklist for the education system in the area of providing educational and health-improving services to minors, in accordance with Appendix 8 to this Joint Order.

Note. Paragraph 1 is amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication); as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

  1. To declare invalid the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 24, 2015 No. 479 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 31, 2015 No. 583 "On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and Forms of Inspection Checklists for Inspections of the Education System" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 11994, published in the Adilet Legal Information System on September 29, 2015).
  2. The Committee for Control in the Sphere of Education and Science of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan (S. Nyusupov) shall, in accordance with the procedure established by law, ensure:
    1. state registration of this Joint Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
    2. submission for official publication within ten calendar days after state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
    3. placement of this Joint Order on the Internet resource of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
  3. Control over the execution of this Joint Order shall be assigned to Vice-Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan T. Balykbayev.
  4. This Joint Order shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication.
Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of KazakhstanActing Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan
__________ Balykbayev T.__________ Kusainov M.

"AGREED"

Chairperson of the Committee on Legal Statistics and Special Records of the Prosecutor General's Office of the Republic of Kazakhstan

__________ Aitpaeva S.

December 30, 2015

 Appendix 1 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary, Additional Education, and the Provision of Educational and Health-Improving Services to Minors

Note. The title of Appendix 1 is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

Note. Appendix 1 is set out in a new version by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

Chapter 1. General Provisions

  1. These Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the education system in the areas of preschool education and training, primary, basic secondary, general secondary, technical and vocational, post-secondary and additional education (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 132, paragraphs 5 and 6 of Article 141 and paragraph 1 of Article 143 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter referred to as the Code), the Order of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Approval of the Inspection Checklist Form" dated July 31, 2018 No. 3 (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 17371), and the Order of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Approval of the Rules for the Formation of the Risk Assessment and Management System by Regulatory State Bodies" dated June 22, 2022 No. 48 (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 28577), and are intended for selecting controlled entities (objects) for the purpose of conducting inspections for compliance with qualification or permitting requirements under issued permits, requirements under submitted notifications in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Permits and Notifications” (hereinafter referred to as an inspection for compliance with requirements), and preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object).
  2. The following basic concepts are used in these Criteria:
    1. point – a quantitative measure of risk calculation;
    2. data normalization – a statistical procedure providing for the conversion of values measured on different scales into a conventionally common scale;
    3. risk – the probability of harm being caused as a result of the activities of a controlled entity to human life or health, the legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, and the property interests of the state, taking into account the severity of its consequences;
    4. risk assessment and management system – a process of making management decisions aimed at reducing the probability of adverse factors occurring by distributing controlled entities (objects) according to risk levels for the subsequent implementation of preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with requirements, with the aim of minimizing restrictions on entrepreneurial freedom while ensuring an acceptable level of risk in the relevant areas of activity, as well as aimed at changing the risk level for a specific controlled entity (object) and/or exempting such controlled entity (object) from preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with requirements;
    5. objective risk assessment criteria (hereinafter referred to as objective criteria) – risk assessment criteria used to select controlled entities (objects) depending on the risk level in a particular area of activity and not directly dependent on an individual controlled entity (object);
    6. risk assessment criteria – a set of quantitative and qualitative indicators related to the direct activities of a controlled entity, the characteristics of sectoral development and the factors affecting such development, which make it possible to assign controlled entities (objects) to different risk levels;
    7. subjective risk assessment criteria (hereinafter referred to as subjective criteria) – risk assessment criteria used to select controlled entities (objects) depending on the results of the activities of a specific controlled entity (object);
    8. inspection checklist – a list of requirements imposed on the activities of controlled entities (objects), non-compliance with which poses a threat to human life and health, the legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, and the state;
    9. sample population (sample) – a list of assessed entities (objects) assigned to a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) in a specific area of state control, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 143 of the Code.
  3. Risk assessment criteria and inspection checklists applied for conducting preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with requirements shall be approved by a joint act of the regulatory state bodies and the authorized body for entrepreneurship and shall be published on the Internet resources of the regulatory state bodies in accordance with paragraph 5 of Article 141 of the Code.

Chapter 2. Procedure for Forming the Risk Assessment and Management System When Conducting Inspections for Compliance with Requirements and Preventive Control of Controlled Entities (Objects)

  1. For the purposes of risk management when conducting preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) and/or inspections for compliance with requirements, risk assessment criteria for conducting inspections for compliance with requirements and preventive control of controlled entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria, which are carried out in stages (Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis).

At the first stage, controlled entities (objects) shall be assigned, according to objective criteria, to one of the following risk levels:

  1. high risk;
  2. medium risk;
  3. low risk.

With respect to controlled entities (objects) assigned to the high and medium risk levels according to objective criteria, inspections for compliance with requirements, preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object), preventive control without a visit to the controlled entity (object), and unscheduled inspections shall be conducted.

With respect to controlled entities (objects) assigned to the low risk level according to objective criteria, unscheduled inspections shall be conducted.

At the second stage, controlled entities (objects) shall be assigned, according to subjective criteria, to one of the following risk levels:

  1. high risk;
  2. medium risk;
  3. low risk.

Based on the risk level indicators under subjective criteria, a controlled entity (object) shall be classified as:

  1. high risk – with a risk level indicator ranging from 71 to 100 inclusive;
  2. medium risk – with a risk level indicator ranging from 31 to 70 inclusive;
  3. low risk – with a risk level indicator ranging from 0 to 30 inclusive.
  4. Depending on the potential risk and significance of the issue, whether the violation is isolated or systematic, and the analysis of previously adopted decisions for each source of information, the requirements imposed on the activities of controlled entities (objects) shall correspond to the degree of violation – gross, significant, or minor.

The degree of violation (gross, significant, minor) shall be assigned in accordance with the established definitions of gross, significant, and minor violations under the subjective criteria.

  1. Risk assessment criteria for conducting inspections for compliance with requirements and preventive control of controlled entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria.

Paragraph 1. Objective Criteria

  1. Objective criteria shall be determined by identifying risks.
  2. According to objective criteria, controlled entities (objects):
    1. high risk shall include educational organizations implementing educational curricula for preschool education and training, primary, basic secondary, general secondary education, educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary, additional education, and providing educational and health-improving services to minors, whose activities are carried out in violation of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education;
    2. medium risk shall include educational organizations implementing educational programs of children's music schools, children's art schools and children's schools of arts, whose activities are carried out in violation of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education;
    3. low risk shall include educational organizations implementing additional education programs, whose activities are carried out in violation of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education.

Note. Paragraph 8 is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

Paragraph 2. Subjective Criteria

  1. Subjective criteria shall be determined using the following stages:
    1. formation of a database and collection of information;
    2. analysis of information and risk assessment.
  2. The formation of a database and collection of information are necessary to identify controlled entities (objects) that violate the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the areas of preschool education and training, primary, basic secondary, general secondary, technical and vocational, post-secondary and additional education.
  3. The following sources of information shall be used to assess the risk level according to subjective criteria for conducting preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object):
  4. results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the information system "National Educational Database" (hereinafter referred to as the IS NEDB);
  5. results of previous inspections and preventive control with a visit to controlled entities (objects);
  6. the presence and number of substantiated complaints and appeals against controlled entities (objects) received from individuals or legal entities and state bodies during one calendar year;
  7. results of preventive control without a visit to the controlled entity (object) (final documents issued following preventive control without a visit to the controlled entity (object)).
  8. The following sources of information shall be used to assess the risk level according to subjective criteria for conducting inspections for compliance with requirements:
  9. results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the information system "National Educational Database" (hereinafter referred to as the IS NEDB);
  10. results of previous inspections;
  11. the presence and number of substantiated complaints and appeals against controlled entities (objects) received from individuals or legal entities and state bodies during one calendar year;
  12. results of preventive control without a visit to the controlled entity (object) (final documents issued following preventive control without a visit to the controlled entity (object)).

Note. Paragraph 12 is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

  1. Based on the available sources of information, the authorized body in the field of education shall compile data according to subjective criteria, subject to analysis and assessment in the following areas:
  2. preschool education and training in accordance with Appendix 1 to these Criteria;
  3. primary, basic secondary and general secondary education in accordance with Appendices 2 and 3 to these Criteria;
  4. technical and vocational, post-secondary education in accordance with Appendices 4 and 5 to these Criteria;
  5. additional education in accordance with Appendix 6 to these Criteria.
  6. provision of educational and health-improving services to minors in accordance with Appendix 6-1 to these Criteria.

Note. Paragraph 13 is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

  1. Analysis and assessment of subjective criteria make it possible to concentrate inspections for compliance with requirements and preventive control of controlled entities (objects) on those controlled entities (objects) that have the highest potential risk.

During analysis and assessment, data from subjective criteria that have previously been taken into account and used in relation to a specific controlled entity (object), or data for which the limitation period has expired in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, shall not be applied.

Controlled entities that have fully remedied the violations identified following previous preventive control with a visit and/or inspections for compliance with requirements shall not be included in the formation of schedules and lists for the next period of state control.

  1. Based on the priority of the information sources applied and the significance of the indicators of subjective criteria, in accordance with the procedure for calculating the overall risk level indicator under subjective criteria specified in Chapter 3 of these Criteria, the risk level indicator under subjective criteria shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100.
  2. The priority of the information sources applied and the significance of the indicators of subjective criteria shall be established in accordance with the list of subjective criteria for determining the risk level under subjective criteria with respect to educational organizations implementing:
  3. educational curricula for preschool education and training in accordance with Appendix 7 to these Criteria;
  4. educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education in accordance with Appendix 8 to these Criteria;
  5. educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education in accordance with Appendix 9 to these Criteria.
  6. educational programs of educational organizations providing educational and health-improving services to minors, in accordance with Appendix 10 to these Criteria.

Note. Paragraph 16 is amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 26, 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on January 1, 2025).

Paragraph 3. Specific Features of Forming the Risk Assessment and Management System

  1. The risk assessment and management system shall be maintained using the IS NEDB and other information systems that assign controlled entities (objects) to specific risk levels and generate schedules or lists for conducting control measures, and shall also be based on state statistics, the results of departmental statistical monitoring, as well as information tools.
  2. The calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria, as well as the risk level indicators in accordance with which a controlled entity is classified as high, medium or low risk, shall be established in the risk assessment criteria according to the list of subjective criteria for determining the risk level under subjective criteria in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria.

Chapter 3. Procedure for Calculating the Risk Level According to Subjective Criteria

  1. The following procedure for calculating the risk level indicator shall be applied to assign a controlled entity to a risk level in accordance with paragraph 4 of these Criteria.

The authorized body in the field of education shall collect information and compile a database according to subjective criteria from the sources specified in paragraph 11 or paragraph 12 of these Criteria, depending on whether preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) and/or an inspection for compliance with requirements is being conducted.

The calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria (R) shall be performed automatically by summing the risk level indicator for violations based on the results of previous inspections and preventive control with a visit to controlled entities (objects) (SP) and the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria (SC), followed by normalization of the data values within the range from 0 to 100 points.

Rпром = SP + SC, where

Rпром – intermediate risk level indicator according to subjective criteria,

SP – risk level indicator for violations,

SC – risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria.

The calculation shall be performed for each controlled entity (object) within a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) in each area of state control. In this case, the list of assessed controlled entities (objects) assigned to a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) within one area of state control constitutes a sample population (sample) for subsequent data normalization.

 20. Based on the data obtained as a result of previous inspections and preventive control visits to the subjects (objects) of control, a risk degree indicator for violations is formed, assessed on a scale from 0 to 100 points.

Upon identification of one gross violation under any of the sources of information specified in paragraph 13 of these Criteria, the subject of control shall be assigned a risk degree indicator of 100 points, and an inspection for compliance with the requirements or preventive control with a visit to the subject (object) of control shall be carried out in respect thereof.

If no gross violations are identified, the risk degree indicator for violations shall be calculated as the total indicator of significant and insignificant violations.

When determining the indicator of significant violations, a coefficient of 0.7 shall be applied.

This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:

SРз = (SР2 х 100/SР1) х 0.7, where:

SРз – indicator of significant violations;

SР1 – required number of significant violations;

SР2 – number of identified significant violations;

When determining the indicator of insignificant violations, a coefficient of 0.3 shall be applied.

This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:

SРн = (SР2 х 100/SР1) х 0.3, where:

SРн – indicator of insignificant violations;

SР1 – required number of insignificant violations;

SР2 – number of identified insignificant violations;

The risk degree indicator for violations (SР) shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 points and determined by summing the indicators of significant and insignificant violations using the following formula:

SР = SРз + SРн, where:

SР – risk degree indicator for violations;

SРз – indicator of significant violations;

SРн – indicator of insignificant violations.

The resulting value of the risk degree indicator for violations shall be included in the calculation of the risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria.

21. The calculation of the risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria shall be performed on a scale from 0 to 100 points and carried out using the following formula:

image

xi – indicator of the subjective criterion,

wi – weighting factor of the subjective criterion indicator xi,

n – number of indicators.

The resulting value of the risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 16 of these Criteria shall be included in the calculation of the risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria.

22. The values of indicator R calculated for the subjects (objects) shall be normalized to a range from 0 to 100 points. Data normalization shall be performed for each sample population (sample) using the following formula:

image

R – final risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria for an individual subject (object) of control,

Rmax – maximum possible value on the scale of the risk degree based on subjective criteria for subjects (objects) included in one sample population (sample) (upper limit of the scale),

Rmin – minimum possible value on the scale of the risk degree based on subjective criteria for subjects (objects) included in one sample population (sample) (lower limit of the scale),

Rпром – intermediate risk degree indicator based on subjective criteria, calculated in accordance with paragraph 19 of these Criteria.

Chapter 4. Inspection Checklists

23. Inspection checklists shall be drawn up for homogeneous groups of subjects (objects) of control and shall include requirements in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 132 of the Code and in compliance with the conditions specified in paragraph 2 of Article 143 of the Code.

24. Inspection checklists shall be prepared in the form prescribed by Appendices 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 to this joint order.

Note. Paragraph 24 – as amended by Joint Order No. 158 of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26.06.2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26.06.2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on 01.01.2025).

25. For educational organizations classified as high-risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with the requirements shall be determined by the risk assessment criteria, but not more than once a year.

For educational organizations classified as medium-risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with the requirements shall be determined by the risk assessment criteria, but not more than once every two years.

For educational organizations classified as low-risk, the frequency of inspections for compliance with the requirements shall be determined by the risk assessment criteria, but not more than once every three years.

| | Appendix 1 to the Criteria for Risk Assessment and Management for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education || - | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Degrees of Violations of Requirements by Subjects (Objects) of Control of Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Curricula for Preschool Education and Training

Note. Appendix 1 as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27.05.2024 No. 121 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy dated 28.05.2024 No. 26 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

Download

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Absence of premises intended for holding sports and music events.significant
2.Identification of cases of admission to work in an educational organization of persons who do not have specialized pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field.gross
3.Absence of medical services for children attending the organization.significant
4.Compliance by the teacher with official duties and standards of pedagogical ethics.significant
5.Compliance with the principle of state policy concerning the prohibition on the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations.gross
6.Availability of certificates confirming advanced training of management personnel and teachers of preschool organizations at least once every three years.gross
7.Compliance by teachers with the requirements for upgrading (confirming) their qualification category level at least once every five years.gross
8.Consistency of statistical data in the National Educational Database with the actual data of the educational organization.gross
9.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula for preschool education and training. Also, availability of an individual curriculum and an individual program taking into account the child's individual characteristics when educating children with special educational needs in an inclusive education environment.gross
10.Compliance with and implementation of the approved long-term plans of specialist teachers and educators by the educational organization, in accordance with the state compulsory standard, standard curriculum and standard preschool education and training program, in the educational process, according to the daily schedule and timetable of the preschool organization, which includes activities (reception, morning exercises, meals, walks, daytime sleep, health-improving procedures, children's departure home), providing for types of organized activities (play, cognitive, communicative, creative, experimental, labor, object-based, motor, visual arts).gross
11.Compliance with the requirements for conducting consultations on matters of social and pedagogical support for families whose children are not covered by preschool education and training.insignificant
12.Availability of materials for monitoring the level of development of skills and abilities in accordance with the child's age (individual child development record for the academic year).significant
13.Availability of constituent and title documents of the educational organization, notification of the commencement or termination of activities in the field of preschool education and training, a notification acceptance slip confirming the submission of a notification of commencement of activities through the state information system of permits and notifications, including in cases of changes to the legal address of an individual, the location of a legal entity, the address where activities are carried out or actions specified in the notification, as well as registration data, information about which is mandatory for inclusion in the notification.gross
14.Availability of materials (documents confirming the design capacity of the building; akimat resolution approving the state educational order; list of children attending the organization) confirming the fulfillment of the state educational order and the volume of services financed by the state for the upbringing, education, correction of developmental disorders and social adaptation, development and medical supervision, as well as supervision, care and health improvement of children, including for the implementation of inclusive education for children from the age of one year until admission to Grade 1.significant
15.Availability of work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council) confirming their activities.insignificant
16.Availability of copies of diplomas with supplements and staffing and salary schedules of teachers approved by the educational organization, confirming the provision of teachers who have pedagogical or other professional education in the relevant field or who have completed pedagogical retraining in the relevant field.gross
17.Prevention of admission to professional activities as a teacher in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to carry out professional teaching activities in accordance with a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapacitated or partially incapacitated, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field, or having completed pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation in the field of education in the relevant field; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offenses involving murder, intentional infliction of harm to health, offenses against public health and morality, sexual inviolability, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.gross
18.Performance by the head or another official of a preschool organization of official duties relating to the protection of the life and health of children attending the organization, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process.gross
19.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of implemented educational programs; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and upbringing, and the schedule of classes for children attending the organization); 4) grounds and procedure for expulsion of children attending the organization; 5) list and procedure for providing paid services; 6) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and children attending the organization and/or their parents and other legal representatives.gross
20.Compliance of the number and positions of teachers in preschool education and training organizations with the standard staffing levels for employees of preschool education and training organizations and the list of teaching positions (for state educational organizations).significant
21.Availability of agreements governing relations between the preschool organization and parents or legal representatives, and compliance with their terms.insignificant
22.Availability of internal regulations and job descriptions for employees approved by the educational organization.insignificant
23.Compliance with the requirements for retaining a child's place in a preschool organization during a period of illness, treatment, health improvement, correction and rehabilitation of the child in healthcare and other organizations (upon submission of a medical certificate, where indicated, or a conclusion), upon submission of a written application by one of the child's parents or legal representatives for leave or health improvement of the child for a period of up to two months per year, during a state of emergency (social, natural or man-made emergencies) or quarantine in a locality (verified where complaints have been received), and expulsion of children from preschool organizations in the event of violations of the requirements of the agreement between the preschool organization and the parent or other legal representative of the child, the child's absence for more than one month without valid reasons and without notifying the administration, or the existence of medical contraindications preventing the child's attendance, on the basis of a certificate from the Medical Advisory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the MAC).gross
24.Compliance with the requirements prohibiting: 1) assigning a teacher to types of work unrelated to professional duties (verified where complaints have been received); 2) requesting reports or information from a teacher that are unrelated to the teacher's official duties (verified where complaints have been received); 3) imposing on a teacher the obligation to purchase goods and services; 4) involving teachers of state secondary education organizations, in the course of their professional activities, in conducting events organized by non-governmental organizations.gross
25.Availability of a video surveillance system for state educational organizations in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of educational organizations.gross
26.Compliance with the requirements governing the work of the pedagogical ethics council.significant
27.Provision of equipment and furniture in preschool education organizations in accordance with established standards.gross
28.Compliance with the procedure for holding competitions for appointment to and dismissal from teaching positions in state educational organizations.significant
29.Compliance with the procedure for conducting national qualification testing.gross
30.Failure to conduct organized educational activities provided for by the standard curriculum for preschool education and training due to the absence of specialists.gross
31.Failure to post materials relating to the self-assessment of educational activities on the official website of the educational organization.gross
32.Failure to submit information, or submission of inaccurate information, within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
33.Availability of one (1) or more substantiated complaints and appeals from individuals and/or legal entities whose rights have been violated.significant
34.Compliance with age-based classification when forming age groups.gross

| | Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Risk Assessment and Management for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education || - | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Degrees of Violations of Requirements by Subjects (Objects) of Control of Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Curricula for Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education

Download

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Availability of constituent and title documents of the educational organization.gross
2.Compliance by the teacher with official duties and standards of pedagogical ethics.significant
3.Availability of certificates confirming advanced training of management personnel and teachers of educational organizations in accordance with their positions and/or the subject taught, in accordance with the specialty specified in the education document, at least once every three years.gross
4.Availability of certificates, orders, registration and certificate issuance logs confirming that teachers have completed, in accordance with the profile of the subject taught and the specialty specified in the education document, advanced training (confirmation) of their qualification category level at least once every five years, and for heads of state educational organizations once every three years.gross
5.Compliance with the principle of state policy concerning the prohibition on the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations.gross
6.Availability of orders issued by the educational organization concerning the student population and an alphabetical student registration book confirming the number of students in the educational organization by class.insignificant
7.Availability of working curricula, class registers (electronic/paper), and lesson timetables confirming implementation of the invariant and variable components of the standard curriculum, as well as compliance of the weekly academic workload of students in working curricula, lesson timetables, elective courses, clubs, group and individual classes with the maximum workload.gross
8.Availability in class registers (electronic/paper) of current grades or ongoing assessment in points, quarterly and annual grades for students in Grades 2–11, as well as availability of materials confirming the conduct of summative assessment and analysis of its results, which is carried out upon completion of a certain academic period (quarter, academic year) or the study of sections/cross-cutting topics in accordance with the curriculum.insignificant
9.Availability of orders on the organization of individual free education at home or in medical institutions for students who, due to their health condition, are unable to attend an educational organization for an extended period, as well as education in the form of external studies and distance learning on the basis of permits.insignificant
10.Availability and compliance of individual curricula with standard curricula and programs in terms of educational areas, academic subjects and number of hours for students who have MAC certificates and conclusions of psychological, medical and pedagogical consultations confirming the creation of conditions for obtaining education, correcting developmental disorders and social adaptation of children with special educational needs, students who will be unable to attend an educational institution for an extended period due to their health condition and therefore study at home or in special health-improving organizations free of charge, as well as an individual educational program and consultation schedule in accordance with the working curriculum for students studying in the form of external studies and distance learning.gross
11.Compliance with the requirements for the content of education focused on learning outcomes.significant
12.Compliance with the procedure for admission to educational organizations implementing general education curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education.insignificant
13.Compliance with the procedure for competitive admission to specialized educational organizations and to the first grades of gymnasiums and lyceums.insignificant
14.Availability of and compliance with the terms of the agreement on the provision of educational services concluded by the head of the educational organization with the parents or legal representatives of the student, the standard form of which is approved by the authorized body in the field of education.gross
15.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of implemented educational programs; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and the schedule of classes for students); 4) system of ongoing knowledge monitoring, interim and final assessment of students, and the forms and procedure for conducting such assessment; 5) grounds and procedure for expulsion of students; 6) list and procedure for providing paid services; 7) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and students and/or their parents and other legal representatives.gross
16.Performance by the head or another official of the educational organization of duties relating to the protection of the health of children attending the organization, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process.gross
17.Availability of and compliance with work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council) confirming their activities.insignificant
18.Prevention of admission to professional activities as a teacher in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to carry out professional teaching activities in accordance with a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapacitated or partially incapacitated, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offenses involving murder, intentional infliction of harm to health, offenses against public health and morality, sexual inviolability, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.gross
19.Availability of minutes of pedagogical council meetings, entries in registers for recording and issuing certificates of basic secondary and general secondary education, confirming the objectivity of issuing state-standard education documents to citizens who have passed the final assessment.significant
20.Compliance with the procedure for conducting ongoing monitoring of academic performance of students in educational organizations implementing educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education.significant
21.Compliance of the procedure for conducting final assessment of students in educational organizations implementing educational curricula for basic secondary and general secondary education.significant
22.Availability of materials confirming the organization of extracurricular activities for students and various extracurricular events in Kazakh, Russian and foreign languages.insignificant
23.In the course of a teacher's professional activities, the following shall not be permitted: 1) involving a teacher in types of work unrelated to professional duties; 2) requesting reports or information from a teacher that are unrelated to the teacher's official duties; 3) imposing on a teacher the obligation to purchase goods and services; 4) involving teachers of state secondary education organizations, in the course of their professional activities, in conducting events organized by non-governmental organizations.gross
24.Availability of an order issued by the head of the organization and documents confirming activities related to the organization of mentoring.insignificant
25.Availability of internal regulations of the educational organization and compliance with the working hours and rest periods of teachers and students.significant
26.Compliance with teachers' rights to material support, incentives and provision of social guarantees.significant
27.Compliance with the procedure for holding competitions for appointment to and dismissal from teaching positions in state educational organizations.significant
28.Compliance with the requirements of the Regulations on Class Supervision in Secondary Education Organizations.insignificant
29.Availability of and compliance with plans for educational and upbringing activities, school development and internal school monitoring, ensuring the quality of educational services provided and the implementation of curricula and programs in full.significant
30.Assessment of learning outcomes among students in Grades 4 and 9 in the event of unsatisfactory completion of comprehensive testing based on the results of preventive control without a visit.gross
31.Compliance with the procedure for organizing the educational process using distance learning technologies (hereinafter referred to as DLT) for students under restrictive measures, including quarantine, social, natural and man-made emergencies, on the basis of a recommendation from the authorized body in the field of education.gross
32.Identification of cases of admission to work in an educational organization of persons who do not have specialized pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field or have not completed pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education.gross
33.Availability of academic subjects in the working curriculum of the educational organization that are not taught due to the absence of specialists.gross
34.Availability of an educational portal and/or information system with pages containing educational and methodological, organizational and administrative information for students in educational organizations when organizing the educational process using DLT.gross
35.Availability of substantiated information on violations of legislation in the field of education on the official Internet resources of state bodies and in the mass media.significant
36.Failure to post materials relating to the self-assessment of educational activities on the official website of the educational organization.gross
37.Failure to submit information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.significant
38.Submission of inaccurate information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
39.Availability of one (1) or more substantiated complaints and appeals from individuals and/or legal entities whose rights have been violated.significant

| | Appendix 3 to the Criteria for Risk Assessment and Management for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education || - | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Degrees of Violations of Qualification Requirements by Subjects (Objects) of Control of Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Curricula for Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education

Note. Appendix 3 as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27.05.2024 No. 121 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy dated 28.05.2024 No. 26 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

Download

The English translation is provided below, preserving the original structure, numbering, tables, notes, hyperlinks, and wording without abridgement or substantive changes.

Degrees of violations of requirements of controlled entities (facilities) of educational organizations

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Absence of a sports hall in educational organizations.significant
2.Absence of a library.significant
3.Compliance of actual data with the National Educational Database, as well as the availability of an educational management information system with up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring.gross
4.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula and the State Compulsory Standard of Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education.gross
5.Availability of teachers in accordance with the subjects specified in the working curriculum, having pedagogical education in the relevant field or vocational education supplemented by pedagogical retraining. The proportion of teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, shall be at least 90%, with the exception of small-scale schools. The proportion of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers and teacher-masters for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, shall be at the following levels: 1) primary education: at least 20% for small-scale and special schools, and at least 25% for general education schools; 2) basic secondary and general secondary education: at least 25% for small-scale and special schools; at least 35% for general education schools, gymnasium schools and lyceum schools; at least 40% for lyceums, of which the proportion of teachers in natural sciences and mathematics shall be at least 30%; at least 40% for gymnasiums, of which the proportion of teachers in social sciences and humanities shall be at least 30%; at least 45% for specialized educational organizations for gifted persons, including (where available) teachers who have trained winners of district and/or regional stages of competitions and contests and/or participants and winners of republican competitions and contests over the last 5 years approved by the authorized body in the field of education. Compliance of the education and work experience of the head and teachers of the educational organization with the requirements of the qualification characteristics of teaching positions.gross
6.Provision of buildings (educational buildings) with equipped medical facilities. Availability of a license for medical activities or an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children, in accordance with the standard for providing medical care in secondary education organizations. In the event of an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children, availability of an annex to the license indicating the educational organization as a production facility.significant
7.Availability of a library collection of educational and fiction literature in accordance with the standards for the formation, use and preservation of library collections and the list of textbooks and teaching-methodological complexes determined by the authorized body in the field of education. Availability of a set of textbooks for each student in accordance with the working curriculum for the projected student population.minor
8.Availability of a food service facility for students in buildings (educational buildings) on the basis of a sanitary and epidemiological opinion issued by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population, in accordance with sanitary rules determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare. Availability of an agreement on the provision of meals to students.significant
9.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, or leased material assets with a lease term of at least 10 years, ensuring the quality of educational services, with educational premises complying with sanitary rules determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare, state standards in the field of architecture, urban planning and construction, and fire safety requirements established by the authorized body in the field of emergency situations. Leasing of a sports hall and/or sports facility is permitted, except where the sports hall and/or sports facility is located at a distance of more than 1,000 meters from the building of the educational organization, as well as where the route involves crossing motor roads or railway tracks, provided that a copy of the sanitary and epidemiological opinion for the facility is available.significant
10.Equipment with computer classrooms, computers connected to the Internet, subject classrooms, laboratories (for small-scale schools, special schools and schools at educational and health-improvement centers, the availability of recommended educational and laboratory equipment for physics, chemistry and biology subjects shall be sufficient), sports halls; availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone; availability of equipment and furniture; availability of equipped individual-use lockers; organization of a drinking water regime in accordance with the requirements of sanitary rules determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; availability in the building of sanitary facilities (toilets and washbasins) complying with sanitary rules determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; minimum Internet speed of at least 20 Mbps for up to 400 students, plus 1 Mbps for every 20 students, taking into account the number of students attending one shift. For educational organizations, availability of video surveillance in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of the educational organization.significant
11.Creation of conditions (ramps, painting doors and staircases in contrasting colors) for persons with special educational needs in buildings (educational buildings) in accordance with the standards approved by the authorized body in the field of education.significant
12.Availability on official Internet resources of state bodies and in the mass media of confirmed information concerning violations of legislation in the field of education.significant
13.Failure to post materials on the self-assessment of educational activities on the official Internet resource of the educational organization.gross
14.Failure to submit information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
15.Submission of inaccurate information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.significant
16.Permitting education to be conducted in three shifts.gross
17.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every 3 years, for a duration of at least 36 hours. Heads of educational organizations shall undergo professional development in the relevant field and in management in the field of education at least once every 3 years.gross

Appendix 4

To the Criteria for Risk Assessment and Management for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Upbringing and Education, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

Degrees of violations of requirements by controlled entities (facilities) of educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Availability of constituent and title documents of the educational organization.significant
2.Compliance by teachers with their official duties and the standards of pedagogical ethics.significant
3.Availability of certificates, orders, registration and issuance registers for certificates on the assignment/confirmation of qualification categories, confirming that teachers have undergone an increase (confirmation) of their qualification category level at least once every five years.gross
4.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field and management personnel of educational organizations at least once every three years, for a duration of at least 36 hours.gross
5.Compliance with the principle of state policy regarding the prohibition of the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations.gross
6.Compliance with the prohibition, in the educational process, of political campaigning, coercing students and pupils into adopting political, religious or other beliefs or renouncing them, inciting social, racial, national or religious discord, campaigning that promotes the exclusivity, superiority or inferiority of citizens on the basis of social, racial, national, religious or linguistic affiliation or their attitude towards religion, including through the communication to students of inaccurate information about the historical, national, religious and cultural traditions of the nations and peoples of the Republic of Kazakhstan, as well as encouraging students to engage in actions contrary to the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan.gross
7.Compliance with the guarantee of compensation for the expenses incurred for the maintenance of citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan in need of social assistance during the period of their education.significant
8.Prevention of admission to teaching activities in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to engage in teaching activities in accordance with a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapacitated or partially incapacitated, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offenses involving murder, intentional infliction of harm to health, offenses against public health and morality, sexual inviolability, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.gross
9.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of implemented educational programs; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and the schedule of classes for students); 4) system of ongoing assessment of knowledge, interim and final assessment of students, and the forms and procedures for conducting them; 5) grounds and procedure for expulsion of students; 6) list and procedure for provision of paid services; 7) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and students and/or their parents and other legal representatives.gross
10.Availability of educational programs developed by organizations of technical and vocational, post-secondary education (hereinafter referred to as TVPE) with the participation of employers, based on the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standard (SCES), professional standards (where available), and WorldSkills professional standards (where available); compliance of the list and scope of compulsory general education disciplines, as well as advanced and standard-level disciplines, taking into account the specialization profile in the following areas: social sciences and humanities, natural sciences and mathematics (for technical and vocational education organizations); availability in educational programs of general humanities and socio-economic disciplines or basic modules, as well as professional modules or general professional and specialized disciplines (except for military specialties).gross
11.Compliance of the data in production training records for organizations of technical and vocational, post-secondary education with working curricula and working educational programs, approved and agreed calendars for professional practice and educational programs with organizations designated by the educational organization as practice bases.minor
12.Compliance in working curricula for evening and correspondence forms of education with the requirement that the volume of academic time allocated to compulsory classes shall constitute 70% and 30% respectively of the corresponding volume of academic time provided for full-time education.gross
13.Performance by the head or another official of the educational organization of duties relating to the preservation of the health of pupils, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process.gross
14.Availability of work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council) confirming their activities.minor
15.Availability of registers of theoretical and production training and timesheets recording the completion of educational programs in academic hours.minor
16.Availability in the class schedule of compliance with the duration of an academic hour of 45 minutes for all types of classroom instruction; double-period classes are permitted.minor
17.Availability of at least two holiday periods for students during the academic year.minor
18.Availability of minutes and orders confirming the conduct of special or creative examinations under programs approved by the educational organization for persons applying for admission to educational organizations in specialties of art and culture.minor
19.Compliance with the deadlines for conducting the competition among applicants based on basic secondary education: under the state educational order, from August 19 to August 22 of the calendar year; on a fee-paying basis, from August 26 to August 28 of the calendar year; applicants based on general secondary education, technical and vocational, and post-secondary education: from August 22 to August 25 of the calendar year under the state educational order, and from August 26 to August 28 of the calendar year on a fee-paying basis; applicants to specialties in art and culture: from July 29 to August 2 of the calendar year. Compliance with the deadlines for special and/or creative examinations, as well as psychometric testing for applicants to pedagogical and medical specialties, conducted by August 18 of the calendar year for applicants based on basic secondary education, by August 21 of the calendar year for applicants based on general secondary education, and from July 21 to July 28 for specialties requiring creative training.minor
20.Compliance of the list of specialized subjects by specialty in technical and vocational, post-secondary education with Appendix 5 to the Standard Admission Rules for Admission to Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Programs of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education. Compliance with the determination of the average competition score as the average value of the sum of grades for subjects/disciplines and grades for special and/or creative examinations in accordance with Appendices 4 and 5 to the Standard Admission Rules for Admission to Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Programs of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education, divided by their total number.minor
21.Availability of minutes of meetings of the appeal commission confirming compliance with the procedure for admission and consideration of appeals.minor
22.Compliance with the deadlines for enrollment as students under educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education providing for the training of mid-level specialists and applied bachelor's degree holders, which shall be carried out by order of the head of the TVPE organization on the basis of the minutes of the admissions committee meeting: 1) for full-time education – by August 31 of the calendar year; 2) for evening and correspondence forms of education – by September 30 of the calendar year; 3) in TVPE organizations under the jurisdiction of the authorized body in the field of culture and sports – by August 10 of the calendar year; 4) based on applications from enterprises (organizations, institutions) – by August 18 of the calendar year. Enrollment as students under technical and vocational education programs providing for the training of qualified workers shall be carried out: 1) for full-time education – by August 31 of the calendar year based on the results of an interview; 2) for evening education – by September 30 of the calendar year on the basis of selection taking into account grades in specialized subjects specified in documents on basic secondary or general secondary education and the results of the interview.gross
23.Compliance with the procedure for transferring a student studying on a fee-paying basis with full reimbursement of costs to study under the state educational order in available vacant places: 1) an application or request submitted by the student (or other legal representatives) for transfer to further education under the state educational order, or an application submitted through the e-government web portal; 2) consideration by the collegial body of the student's application for transfer to further education under the state educational order; 3) an order on the transfer of the student to further education under the state educational order based on the decision of the collegial body.minor
24.Transfer of a student shall be carried out: From one educational organization to another, provided that the following documents are available: 1) an application for transfer of the student (legal representative); 2) a copy of the student's record book (or academic performance record), certified by the signature of the head and the seal of the educational organization from which the student is transferring. From an organization implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education to organizations implementing educational programs of secondary education, provided that the following documents are available: 1) an application for transfer (or an application from other legal representatives); 2) an arrival slip issued by the other educational organization. Availability of orders issued by the head of the educational organization (when resolving the issue of student transfer): 1) on admission to classes; 2) on completion of the difference in the curriculum; 3) on enrollment as a student of the educational organization.minor
25.Compliance with the conditions for reinstatement: Persons who previously studied in educational organizations shall be reinstated in their former educational organization subject to the mandatory conditions of: availability of an application from the student; completion by the student of one semester (students shall be reinstated in the first year upon completion of the first semester). Reinstatement of persons who previously studied in other educational organizations shall be permitted provided that the following conditions are met: availability of relevant study groups for the respective courses and specialties, subject to completion of the existing academic difference in academic disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes (in the absence of a corresponding group for the respective courses and specialties, reinstatement in other specialties shall be permitted subject to completion of the existing academic difference in academic disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes); an order issued by the head of the educational organization approving the procedure and deadlines for eliminating the difference in disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes under the curricula; the student's personal file; an order on the reinstatement of the student in the educational organization specifying the specialty, year of study and group. Reinstatement of students studying on a fee-paying basis (expelled during a semester for non-payment of tuition fees at the educational organization) shall be permitted provided that the following documents are available: an application from the student; an order on the reinstatement of the student in the educational organization. Reinstatement from a foreign educational organization to an educational organization of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall be permitted provided that the following documents are available: a document confirming completion of educational programs (academic certificate or transcript); a document confirming completion of the previous level of education, which undergoes the recognition procedure in the Republic of Kazakhstan; results of entrance examinations taken for admission to foreign educational organizations; an order on the reinstatement of the student in the educational organization.minor
26.Compliance with the conditions for determining the academic difference in the number of disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes when transferring students from one educational organization to another, from one form of education to another, from one language department to another, from one specialty to another, or from fee-paying education to education under the state educational order.gross
27.Compliance with the conditions for granting academic leave to students, which shall be provided on the following grounds and subject to the availability of: 1) a conclusion of the Medical Advisory Commission (MAC) at an outpatient clinic for a period of 6 to 12 months due to illness; 2) a decision of the Centralized Medical Advisory Commission of an anti-tuberculosis organization in the event of tuberculosis, for a period of no more than 36 months; 3) a military service conscription notice; 4) childbirth, adoption of a boy or adoption of a girl until the child reaches the age of three years.minor
28.Compliance with the requirements of the Standard Rules for Ongoing Assessment of Academic Performance, Interim and Final Assessment of Students shall be ensured by the availability of: examination sheets for interim assessment; orders admitting students to interim assessment, subject to compliance with the following requirements: students who have fully completed all practical, laboratory, calculation and graphic works, coursework (projects) and assessments in accordance with standard educational programs for each discipline; students who have no unsatisfactory grades based on the results of ongoing assessment of knowledge; students having unsatisfactory grades in 1–2 disciplines may be admitted with the permission of the head of the educational organization; students having more than two unsatisfactory grades may be admitted by decision of the pedagogical council; an order issued by the head of the educational organization admitting to interim assessment students who have not completed interim assessment due to illness or other valid reasons, specifying individual deadlines for completion; a decision of the pedagogical council and an order issued by the head of the educational organization on the expulsion of students who have more than three unsatisfactory grades based on the results of interim assessment; a register of issuance of certificates of the established form to students; an order issued by the head of the educational organization on the transfer to the next year of study of students who have fully fulfilled the requirements of the curriculum for the relevant year of study and successfully passed all assessments and examinations of interim assessment.gross
29.Compliance with the requirements of the Standard Rules for Ongoing Assessment of Academic Performance, Interim and Final Assessment of Students shall be ensured by the availability of: minutes of meetings of commissions conducting the final assessment of students, minutes of meetings of the commission conducting the final assessment of students concerning the taking of final assessment examinations (individual); minutes of meetings of the commission conducting the final assessment of students concerning the awarding of qualifications (summary); minutes of meetings of the commission conducting the final assessment concerning the review of a student's graduation paper (diploma project (paper)); a decision of the attestation commission admitting to a repeated retake of the final assessment persons who received an "unsatisfactory" grade when defending a diploma project or taking a final examination, specifying the deadlines for the repeated final examination in the discipline and/or module for which the unsatisfactory grade was received; a certificate of the established form confirming completion of the full course of study in a specialty (profession) for a student who received an "unsatisfactory" grade upon repeated defense of a diploma project (paper) or taking final examinations; an order issued by the head of the educational organization admitting to final assessment students who failed to appear for the defense of a diploma project (paper) or to take a final examination for a valid reason confirmed by relevant documents, specifying the deadlines for completing the final assessment; diploma issuance registers for organizations of technical and vocational, post-secondary education upon completion of the full course of study, as well as availability of documents confirming the objectivity of issuing a diploma with honors to students who have received "excellent" grades in at least 75% of all disciplines in the curriculum, and "good" grades in the remaining disciplines, and have defended their diploma project (paper) with "excellent" grades.gross
30.In the course of a teacher's professional activities, the following shall not be permitted: 1) involving a teacher in types of work unrelated to their professional duties; 2) requesting reports or information from a teacher that are unrelated to the teacher's official duties; 3) imposing on a teacher the obligation to purchase goods and services; 4) involving teachers of state secondary education organizations, in the course of their professional activities, in conducting events organized by non-governmental organizations.gross
31.Availability of subjects and disciplines in the working curriculum of the educational organization that are not taught due to the absence of specialists.gross
32.Availability on official Internet resources of state bodies and in the mass media of confirmed information concerning violations of legislation in the field of education.significant
33.Failure to post materials on the self-assessment of educational activities on the official Internet resource of the educational organization.gross
34.Availability of applications or requests submitted through the e-government web portal by persons seeking admission to educational organizations under: 1) educational programs of technical and vocational education providing for the training of qualified workers, special educational programs, as well as for admission to spiritual (religious) educational organizations and educational organizations in correctional institutions of the penal enforcement system – from June 25 to August 25 of the calendar year; for evening education – from June 25 to September 20 of the calendar year; 2) educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education providing for the training of mid-level specialists and applied bachelor's degree holders: for full-time education under the state educational order – from June 25 to August 18 of the calendar year for applicants based on basic secondary education, and from June 25 to August 20 of the calendar year for applicants based on general secondary, technical and vocational, and post-secondary education; on a fee-paying basis – from June 25 to August 25 of the calendar year; for evening and correspondence forms of education – from June 25 to September 20 of the calendar year; for specialties requiring creative training – from June 25 to July 20 of the calendar year; for pedagogical and medical specialties – from June 25 to August 15 of the calendar year.minor
35.Failure to submit information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
36.Submission of inaccurate information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.significant
37.Availability of one (1) or more confirmed complaints and appeals from individuals and/or legal entities whose rights have been violated.significant

Appendix 5

To the Criteria for Risk Assessment and Management for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Upbringing and Education, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

Degrees of violations of qualification requirements by controlled entities (facilities) of educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education

Note. Appendix 5 as amended by Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27 May 2024 No. 121 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 28 May 2024 No. 26 (shall enter into force upon expiry of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

Degrees of violation of requirements of entities (facilities) subject to control of educational organizations

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.The existence of a fact of admitting to work in an educational organization persons who do not have special pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field or who have not undergone pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation in the field of education.gross
2.Absence of computer classrooms used in the educational process and connected to the Internet.significant
3.Absence of a sports hall.significant
4.Absence of interactive equipment.significant
5.Absence of a library.significant
6.Absence of classrooms for general education disciplines and specialized disciplines, taking into account the specialty being prepared for.significant
7.Absence of the necessary laboratories, workshops, training grounds and training farms, taking into account the specialty being prepared for.significant
8.Availability of an educational programme included in the register of educational programmes of the authorized body in the field of education and compliant with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education and the professional standard (if any). For medical and pharmaceutical specialties, compliance with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational Education in the field of healthcare, standard curricula (if any), and the professional standard (if any) (in the Kazakh and Russian languages). For the training of specialists in the field of education, availability of an educational programme included in the register of educational programmes of the authorized body in the field of education, in accordance with the professional standard "Teacher", standard curricula and programmes (if any), in the Kazakh and Russian languages, taking into account the State Compulsory Standards of Preschool Education and Training and/or Primary, Basic Secondary Education. For educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, compliance of the educational programme, including general education and religious disciplines, with those agreed upon with the authorized body in the field of religious activities.gross
9.Availability of teachers in accordance with the disciplines and/or modules of the working curriculum for the specialty being prepared for, including compliance of teachers' education with the profile of the disciplines and/or modules taught, or completion of pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation in the field of education, as well as availability of industrial training instructors who have completed internships in organizations and/or at production facilities, amounting to at least 36 hours over the last 3 years in the relevant profile. The share of teachers and industrial training instructors for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, shall be at least 70%, including, for educational organizations implementing medical educational programmes, the share of teachers among nurses with a level of applied bachelor's degree or master's degree, out of the total number of teachers in the specialty, shall be at least 10%. The share of teachers in educational organizations implementing educational programmes in the field of art and culture, for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, shall be at least 50%. The share of teachers in educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, shall be at least 50%.gross
10.The share of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers, teacher-masters and/or persons holding a master's degree, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Doctor by Profile, academic degree of Doctor of Science, Candidate of Science, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), out of the number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, shall be at least 30%; at least 40% in post-secondary education organizations. The share of teachers of specialized disciplines and industrial training instructors who have completed internships in organizations and/or at production facilities amounting to at least 36 hours over the last 3 years, out of the number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, shall be at least 10%. The share of teachers in educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, teaching general education disciplines and having higher education, and teaching specialized disciplines and having higher education in the relevant profile and/or having graduated from a theological seminary or madrasa with a total work experience in the religious sphere of at least five years, out of the number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, shall be at least 50%. For post-secondary education organizations, the share of teachers and industrial training instructors holding a master's degree, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Doctor by Profile, academic degree of Doctor of Science, Candidate of Science, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), out of the total number of teachers in the specialty being prepared for, shall be at least 10%.gross
11.Availability of a library collection of educational and scientific literature in accordance with the working curriculum, relative to the number of students, including by languages of instruction, for the entire period of study in the specialty being prepared for, in accordance with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education, in printed and electronic formats. For educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, availability of a collection of educational literature that has undergone religious studies expert examination, in accordance with the educational programme.significant
12.Equipment of the specialty being prepared for with educational and laboratory equipment and technical teaching aids, as well as computer classrooms and computers connected to the Internet, in accordance with the standards for equipping technical and vocational education organizations with equipment and furniture. For educational organizations in the field of healthcare, availability of a simulation classroom (centre) within the structure of the educational organization. Where necessary, for military educational institutions of the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Kazakhstan, availability of a departmental order on the use of the educational and material facilities of military units and other military educational institutions, and memoranda with organizations of higher and postgraduate education on cooperation in the joint use of the educational and material facilities of military departments.significant
13.Availability of agreements with organizations designated as practical training bases for the specialty being prepared for, covering the entire period of study.minor
14.Availability of medical services for students on the basis of a license for medical activities.significant
15.Availability of a catering facility for students.significant
16.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, ensuring the quality of educational services (classrooms, workshops, laboratories, checkpoints, sanitary facilities, availability of video surveillance inside the premises and/or in the adjacent territories of the educational organization), including educational premises with an area complying with sanitary standards and fire safety requirements.significant
17.Availability of an education management information system with up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with the requirements approved by the authorized body in the field of education, and compliance of the actual data with the National Educational Database. Availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone.gross
18.Creation of accommodation conditions (provision of dormitories and/or hostels and/or hotels complying with the Sanitary Rules established by the authorized body in the field of healthcare) for students in need, in accordance with the rules established by the authorized body in the field of education.gross
19.For the training of specialists in the field of education specified in the Classifier of Specialties and Qualifications of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education, availability of a license and/or an annex to the license for at least 5 specialties in the field of education, with the exception of educational organizations in the field of culture and sports, educational organizations subordinate to the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Kazakhstan, and educational organizations ensuring employment of at least 90% of graduates in the relevant specialty within the year of graduation. For the training of specialists in the field of healthcare specified in the Classifier of Specialties and Qualifications of Technical and Vocational Education, availability of a license and/or an annex to the license for at least 4 specialties in the field of healthcare, with the exception of educational organizations ensuring employment of at least 90% of graduates in the relevant specialty in the field of healthcare within the year of graduation.gross
20.Information on the employment and occupation of graduates of the educational organization by specialty, with the share of employed and occupied graduates out of the total number of graduates in the specialty within the year of graduation being at least 75%.significant
21.Admission by colleges of students in the specialty being prepared for at least once every 3 years, with the exception of newly established educational organizations.minor
22.Availability of confirmed information on violations of legislation in the field of education on official Internet resources of government bodies and in the mass media.significant
23.Failure to submit information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
24.Submission of inaccurate information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.significant
25.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every 3 years, for a duration of at least 36 hours. Heads of educational organizations shall undergo professional development in the relevant field and education management at least once every 3 years.gross

Appendix 6 to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

Degrees of violations of the requirements applicable to entities (facilities) subject to control of educational organizations implementing additional education programmes

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Failure to ensure automated information exchange and absence of data updates in the information system of the authorized body in the field of education.minor
2.Availability of constituent and title documents of the additional education organization.gross
3.Compliance of the activities of the additional education organization with the type of educational organization.significant
4.Compliance with the principle of state policy concerning the prohibition on the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations.gross
5.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of implemented educational programmes; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process; 4) grounds and procedure for expelling children; 5) list and procedure for providing paid services; 6) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and children and/or their parents and other legal representatives.gross
6.Availability of work plans approved by the additional education organization and minutes of meetings of the pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council, as well as materials confirming their activities.minor
7.Availability of copies of diplomas with supplements and tariff lists of teachers approved by the educational organization, confirming the provision of teachers with pedagogical or other professional education in the relevant field.gross
8.Prohibition on admitting to the professional activities of a teacher in an educational organization persons who: 1) have been deprived of the right to carry out professional teaching activities in accordance with a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) have been declared legally incapacitated or partially incapacitated, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue employment relations; 3) have medical contraindications and are registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) do not have documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) have or have had a criminal record, or are or have been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offences involving murder, intentional infliction of bodily harm, offences against public health and morality, sexual integrity, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.gross
9.Availability of additional education programmes taking into account the requests of children, the needs of families, educational organizations, public organizations (including children's and youth organizations), the socio-economic development characteristics of the region, and national and cultural traditions.gross
10.Availability of registers confirming the assignment of grades and the issuance of certificates of qualification for specialized training of children (art, music and schools of arts).significant
11.Availability of approval from the authorized body in the field of education when establishing relations with foreign and international educational organizations and foundations, participating in international programmes, joining international non-governmental organizations (associations) in the fields of education, culture, sports and tourism, and concluding cooperation agreements in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan.minor
12.In the course of a teacher's professional activities, the following shall not be permitted: 1) involving a teacher in types of work unrelated to professional duties; 2) requesting reports or information from a teacher that are unrelated to the teacher's job responsibilities; 3) imposing on a teacher the obligation to purchase goods and services; 4) involving teachers of state secondary education organizations, in the course of their professional activities, in conducting events organized by non-governmental organizations.gross
13.Compliance of statistical data in the National Educational Database with the actual data of the educational organization.gross
14.Compliance with the procedure for enrolling children in additional education organizations for the purpose of providing them with additional education.significant
15.Familiarization of parents (legal representatives) of children with the procedure for conducting and the content of the educational and upbringing process, and with the Charter, upon admission of children to an additional education organization for children.minor
16.Availability of a methodological, social-pedagogical and psychological service.minor
17.Organization of the educational and upbringing process in children's music schools, children's art schools and schools of arts in accordance with standard curricula and educational programmes.significant
18.Completion of additional education programmes in children's music schools, children's art schools and schools of arts, and conducting the final state certification.minor
19.Compliance with the procedure for holding a competition for appointment to and dismissal from teaching positions in state educational organizations (verified where applications have been received) of a state educational organization.significant
20.Compliance of the number and positions of teachers in additional education organizations with the standard staffing levels for employees of additional education organizations and the list of teaching positions.minor
21.The existence of a fact of admitting to work in an educational organization persons who do not have special pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field or who have not undergone pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education.gross
22.Availability of subjects in the working curriculum of the additional education organization that are not taught due to the absence of specialists.significant
23.Performance by the head or another official of the additional education organization of duties related to safeguarding the health of pupils, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process.gross
24.Failure to submit information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.gross
25.Submission of inaccurate information within the framework of educational monitoring using administrative data forms.significant
26.Compliance by an additional education teacher with job responsibilities and standards of pedagogical ethics.significant

Appendix 6-1 to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

Degrees of violations of the requirements applicable to entities (facilities) subject to control of educational organizations providing educational and health-improving services to minors

Note. The Criteria were supplemented by Appendix 6-1 in accordance with Joint Order No. 158 of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26 June 2024 No. 158 and Order No. 42 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26 June 2024 (shall enter into force on 1 January 2025).

No.CriteriaDegree of violation
1.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula and the State Compulsory Standard of Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education.gross
2.Availability of teachers in accordance with the subjects of the working curriculum who have pedagogical education in the relevant profiles or professional education with completion of pedagogical retraining. The share of teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, shall be at least 50%. The share of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers and teacher-masters for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, shall be at least 25%. Compliance of the education and work experience of the head and teachers of the educational organization with the requirements of the standard qualification characteristics of teaching positions.gross
3.Availability of a library collection of educational and fiction literature in accordance with the standards and the list of textbooks approved by the authorized body in the field of education. Availability of a set of textbooks per student in accordance with the working curriculum for the projected student population.minor
4.Provision of buildings (educational buildings) with equipped medical stations. Availability of a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of healthcare. Availability of full-time medical personnel in accordance with the rules approved by the authorized body in the field of healthcare.significant
5.Availability of a catering facility for students in buildings (educational buildings) on the basis of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion in accordance with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population.significant
6.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, or leased material assets with a lease term of at least 10 years, ensuring the quality of educational services, with educational premises complying with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population and fire safety requirements approved by the authorized body in the field of emergency situations. Availability of indoor swimming pools/baths/beaches, children's playgrounds and sports grounds in accordance with the sanitary and epidemiological requirements for children's health-improving and sanatorium facilities, as well as availability on the staff of a sports instructor in therapeutic physical training (LFC) for swimming in accordance with the standard staffing levels for employees of state educational organizations.significant
7.Provision with computer classrooms, computers connected to the Internet, subject classrooms, laboratories (for educational and health-improving educational organizations, the availability of recommended educational and laboratory equipment for the subjects of physics, chemistry and biology is sufficient), sports halls; availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone; availability of equipment and furniture; organization of drinking water supply in accordance with sanitary rules; availability in the building of sanitary facilities (toilets and washbasins) complying with sanitary rules; minimum Internet speed of at least 20 Mbps for up to 400 students, plus 1 Mbps for every 20 students, taking into account the number of students in one shift. Availability of security service providers, an alarm button, access control and video surveillance inside the premises and/or in the adjacent territories of the organization.significant
8.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every 3 years, for a duration of at least 36 hours. Heads of educational organizations shall undergo professional development in the relevant field and education management at least once every 3 years.gross
9.Availability of the National Educational Database information system with up-to-date databases in accordance with the administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring, and an education management information system with up-to-date databases corresponding to the administrative data of the National Educational Database.gross
10.Availability of accommodation conditions for children in accordance with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population.gross
11.Availability of motor vehicles for transporting children and a driver carrying out the transportation of children, complying with the requirements of the rules approved by the authorized body in the field of road transport.significant

Appendix 7 to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk based on subjective criteria for the education system in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in relation to educational organizations implementing educational programmes for preschool education and training

No.Indicator of the subjective criterionSource of information on the indicator of the subjective criterionWeight according to significance, points (the total shall not exceed 100 points), wiConditions / values, xi 
Condition 1/valueCondition 2/value    
123456
For preventive control with a visit     
1.Absence of registration in the State Electronic Register of Permits and Notifications, including in cases of a change in the legal address of an individual, the location of a legal entity, the address of the place of business or activities specified in notifications, as well as registration details, information on which is mandatory for completion in notifications.Results of monitoring of reports and information submitted by the entity subject to control, including through the National Educational Database information system.100%01
0%100%    
2.Exceeding the occupancy limits for children in groups.Results of monitoring of reports and information submitted by the entity subject to control, including through the National Educational Database information system.100%01
0%100%    
3.Non-compliance of the age of children and the conditions of their accommodation with the type of preschool organization.Results of previous inspections and preventive control visits to entities (facilities) subject to control.100%01
0%100%    
4.Failure to comply with age-based grouping when forming age groups (except for mixed-age groups).Results of previous inspections and preventive control visits to entities (facilities) subject to control.100%01
0%100%    
5.Failure to remedy violations or failure to submit, within the prescribed period, a report on the results of the analysis of preventive control without visiting the entity (facility) subject to control.Results of preventive control without visiting the entity (facility) subject to control (final documents issued following the preventive control without visiting the entity (facility) subject to control).100%01
0%100%    

Appendix 8 to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk based on subjective criteria for the education system in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in relation to educational organizations implementing educational programmes for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education

  Below is the English translation, preserving the original structure, headings, numbering, tables, footnotes, legal references and hyperlinks.

List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk based on subjective criteria in the education system

No.Indicator of the subjective criterionSource of information on the indicator of the subjective criterionWeight according to significance, points (the total must not exceed 100 points), wiConditions / values, xi
Condition 1 / valueCondition 2 / value   
12345
For preventive control with a visit    
1.Non-compliance with the procedure for forming classes, including violation of the class occupancy standards.Results of previous inspections and preventive control visits to controlled entities (facilities).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
2.The presence of first or graduating grades combined with other grades.Results of previous inspections and preventive control visits to controlled entities (facilities).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
3.Failure to remedy violations or failure to submit, within the prescribed period, a report on the results of the analysis of preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility).Results of preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility) (final documents issued following the preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility)).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
4.The presence of students in graduating grades (4 and 9) who scored less than 50% of correct answers out of the total number of questions in the subjects covered by the monitoring of students' educational achievements.Results of preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility) (final documents issued following the preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility)).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
For compliance inspections    
1.Absence of a licence for educational activities and/or an annex to the licence covering the level of education being provided.Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
2.Absence of subject-specific classrooms (physics, chemistry, biology, computer science), interactive whiteboards and educational workshops (for basic secondary and general secondary education).Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
3.The fact of re-registration of the licensee or a change in its name or legal address.Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
4.The fact of reorganization of the legal entity holding the licence in accordance with the procedure established by Article 34 of the Law "On Permits and Notifications".Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%

 

Appendix 9

to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk based on subjective criteria in the education system in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in respect of educational organizations implementing educational programmes of technical and vocational and post-secondary education

Note. The List has been amended by Joint Order No. 158 of 26 June 2024 of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (link) and Order No. 42 of 26 June 2024 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan (the amendments shall enter into force upon the expiry of sixty calendar days after the date of their first official publication).

No.Indicator of the subjective criterionSource of information on the indicator of the subjective criterionWeight according to significance, points (the total must not exceed 100 points), wiConditions / values, xi
Condition 1 / valueCondition 2 / value   
12345
For preventive control with a visit    
1.Failure to remedy violations or failure to submit, within the prescribed period, a report on the results of the analysis of preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility).Results of preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility) (final documents issued following the preventive control conducted without visiting the controlled entity (facility)).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
For compliance inspections    
1.Absence of a licence for educational activities and/or an annex to the licence covering the level of education being provided.Results of previous inspections.100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
2.Creation of conditions (a ramp, painting doors and staircases in contrasting colours) for persons with special educational needs in buildings (educational buildings).Results of previous inspections.100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
3.The fact of re-registration of the licensee or a change in its name or legal address.Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
4.The fact of reorganization of the legal entity holding the licence in accordance with the procedure established by Article 34 of the Law "On Permits and Notifications".Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%

 

Appendix 10

to the Risk Assessment and Management Criteria for the Education System in the Areas of Preschool Education and Training, Primary, Basic Secondary, General Secondary, Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary and Additional Education

List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk based on subjective criteria in the education system in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in respect of educational organizations providing educational and recreational services to minors

Note. The Criteria have been supplemented by Appendix 10 pursuant to Joint Order No. 158 of 26 June 2024 of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (link) and Order No. 42 of 26 June 2024 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan (shall enter into force on 1 January 2025).

No.Indicator of the subjective criterionSource of information on the indicator of the subjective criterionWeight according to significance, points (the total must not exceed 100 points), wiConditions / values, xi
Condition 1 / valueCondition 2 / value   
12345
For compliance inspections    
1.Absence of a licence for educational activities and/or an annex to the licence covering the level of education being provided.Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
2.Absence of subject-specific classrooms (physics, chemistry, biology, computer science), interactive whiteboards and educational workshops (for basic secondary and general secondary education).Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
3.The fact of re-registration of the licensee or a change in its name or legal address.Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%
4.The fact of reorganization of the legal entity holding the licence in accordance with the procedure established by Article 34 of the Law "On Permits and Notifications".Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the National Educational Database Information System (IS NOBD).100%0 / 1
    0% / 100%

 

Appendix 2

to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 843

Inspection Checklist for the Education System in the Area of Preschool Education and Training in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in respect of educational organizations implementing educational programmes of preschool education and training

Note. Appendix 2 is set out in the wording of Joint Order No. 76 of 30 March 2023 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Order No. 41 of 30 March 2023 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

State body that ordered the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility): ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Act on the appointment of the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility): __________________________ No. __________, date __________

Name of the controlled entity (facility): ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Individual Identification Number (IIN), Business Identification Number (BIN) of the controlled entity (facility): __________________________________________________________________

Location address: __________________________________________________________________

No.List of requirementsComplies with requirementsDoes not comply with requirements
1234
1.Compliance by the teacher with official duties and the standards of pedagogical ethics (checked where complaints have been received).  
2.Compliance with the principle of state policy prohibiting the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations (checked where complaints have been received).  
3.Availability of certificates confirming that management personnel and teachers of preschool organizations have undergone professional development at least once every three years.  
4.Availability of certificates, orders, registration logs and records of issuance of certificates confirming the assignment/confirmation of teachers' qualification categories in accordance with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education.  
5.Consistency of statistical data in the National Educational Database with the actual data of the educational organization.  
6.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula for preschool education and training. Also, availability of an individual curriculum and an individual programme taking into account the child's characteristics when educating children with special educational needs in an inclusive education environment.  
7.Compliance with and implementation of the prospective plans approved by the educational organization for specialist teachers and educators, in accordance with the State Compulsory Standard, the standard curriculum and the standard preschool education and training programme, in the educational process, in accordance with the daily schedule and the activity schedule of the preschool organization, which includes activities (reception, morning exercises, meals, walks, daytime sleep, health-strengthening procedures, and children going home), and provides for types of organized activities (play, cognitive, communicative, creative, experimental, labour, object-based, physical activity and visual arts).  
8.Availability of materials confirming the provision of consultations on social and pedagogical support for families whose children are not covered by preschool education and training.  
9.Availability of materials tracking the level of development of skills and abilities in accordance with the child's age (an individual child development record for the academic year).  
10.Availability of the constituent and title documents of the educational organization, notification of the commencement or termination of activities in the field of preschool education and training, and a receipt confirming acceptance of the notification of commencement of activities through the State Information System of Permits and Notifications, including in cases of changes to the legal address of an individual, the location of a legal entity, the address at which activities are carried out or the actions specified in the notification, as well as registration details, information about which is mandatory for completion in the notification.  
11.Availability of materials (documents confirming the design capacity of the building; the akimat resolution approving the state educational order; the list of enrolled children) confirming the fulfilment of the state educational order and the volume of services financed by the state for the upbringing, education, correction of developmental disabilities and social adaptation, development and medical monitoring, as well as supervision, care and health improvement of children, including the implementation of inclusive education for children aged from one year until admission to Grade 1.  
12.Availability of work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council) confirming their activities.  
13.Availability of copies of diplomas with supplements and staffing and remuneration schedules for teachers approved by the educational organization, confirming that the organization is staffed with teachers who have pedagogical or other professional education in the relevant field or have undergone pedagogical retraining in the relevant field.  
14.Prevention of admission to professional activities in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to engage in professional pedagogical activities pursuant to a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapable or partially legally capable, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications or being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate pedagogical or professional education in the relevant field, or having undergone pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation in the field of education in the relevant field; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offences involving murder, intentional infliction of bodily harm, offences against public health and morality, sexual inviolability, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.  
15.Performance by the head or another official of the preschool organization of official duties concerning the protection of the life and health of children, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational process (checked where a complaint has been received).  
16.Performance of the functions specified in the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of educational programmes implemented; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and upbringing and the schedule of activities for children); 4) grounds and procedure for expulsion of children; 5) list and procedure for providing paid services; 6) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and children and/or their parents and other legal representatives.  
17.Compliance of the number and positions of teachers in preschool education and training organizations with the standard staffing levels for employees of preschool education and training organizations and the list of teaching positions (for state educational organizations).  
18.Availability of agreements governing relations between the preschool organization and parents or legal representatives, and compliance with the terms thereof.  
19.Availability of internal regulations and job descriptions for employees approved by the educational organization.  
20.Compliance with the requirements for retaining a child's place in a preschool organization during the child's illness, treatment, health improvement, correction and rehabilitation in healthcare organizations and other organizations (upon submission of a medical certificate, where indicated, or a medical advisory commission's conclusion), upon submission of a written application by one of the parents or the child's legal representative for leave or health improvement for a period of up to two months per year, during a declared state of emergency (social, natural or man-made emergencies), or quarantine in a locality (checked where complaints have been received); and expulsion of children from preschool organizations in the event of violation of the requirements of the agreement between the preschool organization and the parent or other legal representative of the child, the child's absence for more than one month without valid reasons and without notifying the administration, or the presence of medical contraindications preventing the child's attendance, on the basis of a certificate issued by a medical advisory commission (checked where complaints have been received).  
21.Compliance with the requirements prohibiting: 1) assigning teachers to types of work unrelated to their professional duties; 2) requesting from teachers reports or information unrelated to their official duties; 3) imposing on teachers the obligation to purchase goods and services (checked where complaints have been received).  
22.Availability of a video surveillance system in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of state educational organizations.  
23.Compliance with the standard rules for organizing the work of the pedagogical ethics council.  
24.Provision of equipment and furniture in preschool education organizations in accordance with the established standards.  
25.Compliance with the procedure for conducting competitions for appointment to and dismissal from teaching positions in state educational organizations (checked where complaints have been received).  
26.Publication of the staffing schedule and teachers' remuneration schedules on the official websites of state preschool organizations.  
27.Compliance with the procedure for conducting national qualification testing (checked where a complaint has been received).  
28.Compliance with age-based classification when forming age groups.  
29.Provision of ongoing medical monitoring, immunization and organization of preventive medical examinations for children.  

Official(s): ______________________________ ______________________________

Position / signature ________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity: ______________________________ ______________________________

Position / signature ________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

 

Appendix 3

to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 843

Inspection Checklist for the Education System in the Areas of Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in respect of educational organizations implementing educational programmes of primary, basic secondary and general secondary education

Note. Appendix 3 is set out in the wording of Joint Order No. 76 of 30 March 2023 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Order No. 41 of 30 March 2023 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

State body that ordered the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility): ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Act on the appointment of the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility): __________________________ No. __________, date __________

Name of the controlled entity (facility): ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Individual Identification Number (IIN), Business Identification Number (BIN) of the controlled entity (facility): __________________________________________________________________

Location address: __________________________________________________________________

Note: The source text ends immediately after the introductory information for Appendix 3. The actual checklist table for Appendix 3 was not included in the text provided, so it has not been supplemented or reconstructed.

Ниже приведён полный перевод на английский язык с сохранением структуры таблиц, нумерации, формулировок, примечаний, реквизитов и гиперссылок. Текст не сокращён.

CHECKLIST OF REQUIREMENTS

No.List of requirementsComplies with the requirementsDoes not comply with the requirements
1234
1.Availability of the constituent and title documents of the educational organization.  
2.Consistency of the actual data with the National Educational Database, as well as the availability of an education management information system containing up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with the administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring.  
3.Compliance by the teacher with official duties and the standards of pedagogical ethics (verified if complaints have been received).  
4.Availability of certificates confirming professional development of management personnel and teachers of educational organizations in their respective positions and/or in the subject taught, in accordance with the specialty indicated in the educational qualification document, at least once every three years.  
5.Compliance with the principle of state policy regarding the prohibition of the establishment and activities of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations (verified if complaints have been received).  
6.Availability of orders issued by the educational organization concerning the student population, an alphabetical register of students, confirming the number of students enrolled in the educational organization by class.  
7.Availability of working curricula, class registers (electronic/paper), and lesson timetables confirming the implementation of the invariant and variable components of the standard curriculum, as well as compliance with the maximum weekly academic workload of students in working curricula, lesson timetables, elective courses, clubs, group and individual classes.  
8.Availability in class registers (electronic/paper) of current marks or current assessment in points, quarterly and annual grades for students in Grades 2–11, as well as materials confirming the conduct of summative assessment and analysis of the results of summative assessment, which is conducted upon completion of a certain academic period (quarter, academic year) and the study of sections/cross-cutting topics in accordance with the curriculum.  
9.Availability of orders concerning the organization of free individual home-based education or education in medical institutions for students who, due to their health condition, are unable to attend the educational organization for an extended period, as well as education in the form of external studies and distance learning on the basis of permits.  
10.Availability of individual curricula and their compliance with standard curricula and programs in terms of the availability of educational fields, academic subjects and the number of hours for students who have certificates issued by medical advisory commissions and conclusions issued by psychological, medical and pedagogical consultations, confirming the provision of conditions for obtaining education, correcting developmental disorders and social adaptation of children with special educational needs, and students who will be unable to attend an educational institution for an extended period due to their health condition and must study at home or in special health-improving organizations free of charge, as well as the availability of an individual educational program and consultation schedule in accordance with the working curriculum for students receiving education in the form of external studies and distance learning.  
11.Compliance with the requirements for the content of education oriented towards learning outcomes.  
12.Compliance with the admission procedure for educational organizations implementing general education curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education.  
13.Compliance with the competitive admission procedure for specialized educational organizations and the first grades of gymnasiums and lyceums.  
14.Availability and compliance with the terms of the agreement on the provision of educational services concluded by the head of the educational organization with the parents or legal representatives of the student, the standard form of which is approved by the authorized body in the field of education (verified if complaints have been received).  
15.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of educational programs implemented; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and the study schedule of students); 4) system of ongoing assessment of students' knowledge, interim and final assessment, and the forms and procedure for conducting them; 5) grounds and procedure for expelling students; 6) list and procedure for providing paid services; 7) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and students and/or their parents and other legal representatives.  
16.Performance by the head or another official of the educational organization of duties relating to the protection of the health of children in care, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process (verified if complaints have been received).  
17.Availability of certificates, orders, registers of registration and issuance of certificates confirming that teachers, in accordance with the profile of the subject taught and the specialty specified in the educational qualification document, have undergone the procedure for awarding/confirming a qualification category at least once every five years; for heads of state educational organizations, once every three years.  
18.Availability and compliance of work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical councils, methodological councils and pedagogical ethics councils), confirming their activities.  
19.Availability of copies of documents confirming higher and/or postgraduate pedagogical education or technical and vocational, post-secondary pedagogical education in the relevant field, or other professional education in the relevant field, and/or certificates confirming completion of pedagogical retraining at higher and/or postgraduate education organizations.  
20.Prevention of admission to teaching activities in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to engage in professional teaching activities in accordance with a court judgment that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapable or partially capable, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) lacking documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offences involving murder, intentional infliction of bodily harm, offences against public health and morality, sexual integrity, extremist or terrorist offences, or human trafficking.  
21.Availability of minutes of pedagogical council meetings, entries in registers for recording and issuing certificates of basic secondary and general secondary education, confirming the objectivity of issuing state-standard education documents to citizens who have passed the final assessment.  
22.Compliance with the procedure for conducting ongoing assessment of students' academic performance in educational organizations implementing educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education.  
23.Compliance with the procedure for conducting the final assessment of students in educational organizations implementing educational curricula for basic secondary and general secondary education.  
24.Availability of materials confirming the organization of extracurricular activities for students and various extracurricular events in the Kazakh, Russian and foreign languages.  
25.Compliance with the requirements prohibiting: 1) involving teachers in types of work unrelated to their professional duties; 2) requesting reports or information from teachers that are unrelated to their official duties; 3) imposing on teachers the obligation to purchase goods and services; 4) involving teachers of state secondary education organizations, in the course of their professional activities, in conducting events organized by non-governmental organizations (verified if a complaint has been received).  
26.Availability of an order issued by the head of the organization and documents confirming activities related to the organization of mentoring.  
27.Availability of internal regulations of the educational organization and compliance with the working time and rest periods of teachers and students.  
28.Compliance with teachers' rights to material support, incentives and the provision of social guarantees to teachers.  
29.Compliance with the procedure for conducting competitions for appointment to and dismissal from teaching positions in state educational organizations (verified if complaints have been received).  
30.Compliance with the requirements of the Regulations on Class Supervision in secondary education organizations (verified if complaints have been received).  
31.Availability and compliance of educational and upbringing work plans, school development plans and internal school supervision plans, ensuring the quality of educational services provided and the full implementation of curricula and programs.  
32.Assessment of learning outcomes among students in Grades 4 and 9 in the event of unsatisfactory completion of comprehensive testing following preventive control without a site visit.  
33.Compliance with the procedure for organizing the educational process using distance learning technologies (hereinafter referred to as DLT) for students under restrictive measures, including quarantine and emergencies of a social, natural and technological nature, on the basis of a recommendation issued by the authorized body in the field of education.  
34.Availability of an educational portal and/or information system with pages containing educational-methodological and organizational-administrative information for students in educational organizations when organizing the educational process using DLT.  
35.Availability of confirmed information on violations of legislation in the field of education on the official Internet resources of state bodies and in the mass media.  
36.Availability of an annual self-assessment of educational activities.  
37.Availability of academic subjects included in the working curriculum of the educational organization that are not taught due to the absence of specialists.  

Official(s) ____________________________________________________________ ___________________________

Position, signature ______________________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity ______________________________________________________ ___________________________

Position, signature ______________________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

 

 Appendix 4 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Checklist

in the field of state control over the education system in relation to educational organizations implementing general education curricula for basic secondary education

Note. Appendix 4 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 15, 2018 No. 632 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 15, 2018 No. 71 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

 

 Appendix 4 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Checklist for the education system in terms of primary, basic secondary and general secondary education in accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in relation to educational organizations implementing educational curricula for primary, basic secondary and general secondary education

Note. Appendix 4 was added to the Joint Order in accordance with the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication); as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 27, 2024 No. 121 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated May 28, 2024 No. 26 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

State body that ordered the inspection ___________________________________________________________

Inspection appointment act _________________________________________________________________

No., date

Name of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________

 

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the controlled entity (facility)

 

Location address ___________________________________________________________________________

Checklist

No.List of requirementsComplies with the requirementsDoes not comply with the requirements
 Subsection 1. For the activities of educational organizations implementing general education curricula for primary education  
1.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula and the State Compulsory Standard of Primary Education.  
2.Availability of teachers corresponding to the subjects included in the working curriculum, who have pedagogical education in the relevant field or professional education supplemented by pedagogical retraining. The proportion of teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, must be at least 90%, with the exception of small-completion schools. The proportion of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers and teacher-masters for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers at the primary education level in small-completion and special schools, must be at least 20%; for general education schools, at least 25%. Compliance of the education and work experience of the head and teachers of the educational organization with the requirements of the qualification characteristics for teaching positions.  
3.Availability of a library collection of educational and fiction literature in accordance with the standards for the formation, use and preservation of library collections and the list of textbooks and teaching-methodological complexes determined by the authorized body in the field of education. Availability of a set of textbooks for each student in accordance with the working curriculum and the projected student population.  
4.Provision of buildings (educational buildings) with equipped medical rooms. Availability of a license for medical activities or an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children in accordance with the standard for the provision of medical care in secondary education organizations. In the event of an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children, availability of an annex to the license specifying the educational organization as a production base.  
5.Availability of a food service facility for students in buildings (educational buildings) on the basis of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion issued by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population, in accordance with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare. Availability of an agreement for the provision of meals to students.  
6.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, or leased material assets under a lease agreement with a term of at least 10 years, ensuring the quality of educational services, with educational premises complying with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare, state standards in the field of architecture, urban planning and construction, and fire safety requirements established by the authorized body in the field of emergency situations. The lease of a sports hall and/or sports facility is permitted, except where the sports hall and/or sports facility is located more than 1,000 metres from the building of the educational organization, as well as where the route involves crossing motor roads or railway tracks, provided that a copy of the sanitary and epidemiological conclusion for the facility is available.  
7.Equipment with computer classrooms, computers connected to the Internet, educational classrooms and sports halls; availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone; availability of equipment and furniture; availability of equipped individual-use lockers; organization of drinking water provision in accordance with the requirements of sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; availability in the building of sanitary facilities (toilets and washbasins) complying with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; minimum Internet speed of at least 20 Mbps for up to 400 students, plus 1 Mbps for every additional 20 students, taking into account the number of students attending one shift. For educational organizations, availability of video surveillance in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of the educational organization.  
8.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every three years, with a duration of at least 36 hours. Heads of educational organizations must undergo professional development in the relevant field and in education management at least once every three years.  
9.Availability of an education management information system with up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with the administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring.  
10.Creation of conditions (ramps, painting doors and staircases in contrasting colours) for persons with special educational needs in buildings (educational buildings) in accordance with the standards established by the authorized body in the field of education.  
 Subsection 2. For the activities of educational organizations implementing general education curricula for basic secondary and general secondary education  
1.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula and the State Compulsory Standard of Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education.  
2.Availability of teachers corresponding to the subjects included in the working curriculum, who have pedagogical education in the relevant field or professional education supplemented by pedagogical retraining. The proportion of teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers, must be at least 90%, with the exception of small-completion schools. The proportion of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers and teacher-masters for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment, out of the total number of teachers at the basic secondary and general secondary education levels, must be at least 25% for small-completion and special schools; at least 35% for general education schools, gymnasium schools and lyceum schools; at least 40% for lyceums, of which the proportion of teachers in the natural sciences and mathematics fields must be at least 30%; at least 40% for gymnasiums, of which the proportion of teachers in the social sciences and humanities fields must be at least 30%; at least 45% for specialized educational organizations for gifted students, including (where available) teachers who have prepared winners of district and/or regional stages of competitions and contests and/or participants and winners of republican competitions and contests over the past five years, approved by the authorized body in the field of education. Compliance of the education and work experience of the head and teachers of the educational organization with the requirements of the qualification characteristics for teaching positions.  
3.Availability of a library collection of educational and fiction literature in accordance with the standards for the formation, use and preservation of library collections and the list of textbooks and teaching-methodological complexes determined by the authorized body in the field of education. Availability of a set of textbooks for each student in accordance with the working curriculum and the projected student population.  
4.Provision of buildings (educational buildings) with equipped medical rooms. Availability of a license for medical activities or an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children in accordance with the standard for the provision of medical care in secondary education organizations. In the event of an agreement with a healthcare organization holding a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children, availability of an annex to the license specifying the educational organization as a production base.  
5.Availability of a food service facility for students in buildings (educational buildings) on the basis of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion issued by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population, in accordance with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare. Availability of an agreement for the provision of meals to students.  
6.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, or leased material assets under a lease agreement with a term of at least 10 years, ensuring the quality of educational services, with educational premises complying with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare, state standards in the field of architecture, urban planning and construction, and fire safety requirements established by the authorized body in the field of emergency situations. The lease of a sports hall and/or sports facility is permitted, except where the sports hall and/or sports facility is located more than 1,000 metres from the building of the educational organization, as well as where the route involves crossing motor roads or railway tracks, provided that a copy of the sanitary and epidemiological conclusion for the facility is available.  
7.Equipment with computer classrooms, computers connected to the Internet, subject-specific classrooms and laboratories (for small-completion schools, special schools and schools at educational and health-improving centres, the availability of recommended educational laboratory equipment for physics, chemistry and biology subjects is sufficient), and sports halls; availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone; availability of equipment and furniture; organization of drinking water provision in accordance with the requirements of sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; availability in the building of sanitary facilities (toilets and washbasins) complying with sanitary regulations determined by the authorized body in the field of healthcare; minimum Internet speed of at least 20 Mbps for up to 400 students, plus 1 Mbps for every additional 20 students, taking into account the number of students attending one shift. For educational organizations, availability of video surveillance in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of the educational organization.  
8.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every three years, with a duration of at least 36 hours. Heads of educational organizations must undergo professional development in the relevant field and in education management at least once every three years.  
9.Availability of an education management information system with up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with the administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring.  
10.Creation of conditions (ramps, painting doors and staircases in contrasting colours) for persons with special educational needs in buildings (educational buildings) in accordance with the standards established by the authorized body in the field of education.  

Official(s) ____________________________________________________________ ___________________________

Position, signature ______________________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity ______________________________________________________ ___________________________

Position, signature ______________________________________________________________

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

 

 Appendix 5 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Inspection Checklist in the Field of State Control over the Education System in Relation to Educational Organizations Implementing General Education Curricula of General Secondary Education

Note. Appendix 5 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 15, 2018 No. 632 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 15, 2018 No. 71 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

 Appendix 5 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Inspection Checklist for the Education System in Terms of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Relation to Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Programs of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education

Note. The Joint Order was supplemented with Appendix 5 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

State body that ordered the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility) ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Act on the appointment of an inspection/preventive control of the controlled entity (facility) ______________________________ No., date

Name of the controlled entity (facility) ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the controlled entity (facility) ____________________________________________________________________

Location address ____________________________________________________________________

Download

No.List of RequirementsComplies with RequirementsDoes Not Comply with Requirements
1234
1.Availability of constituent and title documents of the educational organization.  
2.Compliance by the teacher with official duties and the standards of pedagogical ethics (checked if complaints have been received).  
3.Availability of certificates, orders, registers of registration and issuance of certificates on the assignment/confirmation of a qualification category, confirming that teachers have undergone professional development (confirmation) of their qualification category level at least once every five years.  
4.Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field and management personnel of educational organizations at least once every three years, with a duration of at least 36 hours.  
5.Compliance with the principle of state policy regarding the prohibition on the establishment and operation of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations (checked if complaints have been received).  
6.Compliance with the prohibition, in the educational process, of political campaigning, coercing students and pupils into adopting political, religious or other beliefs or renouncing them, inciting social, racial, national or religious discord, campaigning that promotes the exclusivity, superiority or inferiority of citizens on the grounds of social, racial, national, religious or linguistic affiliation or their attitude towards religion, including by providing students with inaccurate information about the historical, national, religious and cultural traditions of the nations and peoples of the Republic of Kazakhstan, as well as inducing students to take actions contrary to the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan (checked if complaints have been received).  
7.Compliance with the guarantee of compensation for the costs of maintaining citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan in need of social assistance during the period of their education (checked if a complaint has been received).  
8.Prevention of admission to professional teaching activities in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to carry out professional teaching activities in accordance with a court sentence that has entered into legal force; 2) recognized as legally incapable or having limited legal capacity, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue the employment relationship; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offenses involving murder, intentional infliction of bodily harm, offenses against public health and morality, sexual integrity, extremist or terrorist crimes, and human trafficking.  
9.Performance of the functions specified in the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of educational programs implemented; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process (including the language(s) of instruction and the schedule of classes for students); 4) system of ongoing assessment of knowledge, interim and final assessment of students, and the forms and procedures for conducting them; 5) grounds and procedure for expelling students; 6) list and procedure for providing paid services; 7) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and students and/or their parents and other legal representatives.  
10.Compliance of production training attendance registers of organizations providing technical and vocational, post-secondary education with working curricula and working educational programs, approved and coordinated calendars for professional practice, and educational programs with organizations designated by the educational organization as practice bases.  
11.Compliance in working curricula for evening and correspondence forms of education with the requirement concerning the volume of instructional time for compulsory classes in the ratio of 70% and 30% of the corresponding amount of instructional time provided for the full-time form of education.  
12.Performance by the head or other official of the educational organization of duties related to safeguarding the health of pupils, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process (checked if a complaint has been received).  
13.Availability of work plans approved by the educational organization and minutes of meetings of collegial bodies (pedagogical council, methodological council and council on pedagogical ethics) confirming their activities.  
14.Availability of registers for theoretical and production training and timesheets recording the implementation of educational programs in academic hours.  
15.Availability of a class schedule ensuring that the duration of an academic hour for all types of classroom instruction is 45 minutes; double classes are permitted.  
16.Availability of holidays for students at least twice during the academic year.  
17.Availability of applications or requests submitted through the web portal of the "electronic government" by persons seeking admission to study at educational organizations under: 1) educational programs of technical and vocational education providing for the training of qualified workers, under special educational programs, as well as for admission to spiritual (religious) educational organizations and educational organizations in correctional institutions of the penal enforcement system – from June 25 to August 25 of the calendar year; for the evening form of education – from June 25 to September 20 of the calendar year; 2) educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education providing for the training of mid-level specialists and applied bachelor's degree holders, for full-time study under the state educational order – from June 25 to August 18 of the calendar year for applicants based on basic secondary education, and from June 25 to August 20 of the calendar year for applicants based on general secondary, technical and vocational, or post-secondary education; on a paid basis – from June 25 to August 25 of the calendar year; for evening and correspondence forms of education – from June 25 to September 20 of the calendar year; for specialties requiring creative preparation – from June 25 to July 20 of the calendar year; for pedagogical and medical specialties – from June 25 to August 15 of the calendar year.  
18.Availability of minutes and orders confirming the conduct of special or creative examinations under programs approved by the educational organization for persons applying for admission to educational organizations in the specialties of art and culture.  
19.Compliance with the deadlines for conducting the competition among applicants based on basic secondary education: under the state educational order, the competition is held from August 19 to August 22 of the calendar year; on a paid basis – from August 26 to August 28 of the calendar year; for applicants based on general secondary education and applicants based on technical and vocational, post-secondary education (TVPE) – from August 22 to August 25 of the calendar year; on a paid basis – from August 26 to August 28 of the calendar year; for applicants to specialties in art and culture – from July 29 to August 2 of the calendar year. Compliance with the deadlines for special and/or creative examinations, as well as psychometric testing for applicants to pedagogical and medical specialties, conducted by August 18 of the calendar year for applicants based on basic secondary education, by August 21 of the calendar year for applicants based on general secondary education, and from July 21 to July 28 of the calendar year for specialties requiring creative preparation.  
20.Compliance of the list of specialized subjects for specialties of technical and vocational, post-secondary education with Appendix 5 to the Standard Admission Rules for admission to educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education. Compliance with the determination of the average competition score as the average value of the sum of grades in subjects/disciplines and grades in special and/or creative examinations in accordance with Appendices 4 and 5 to the Standard Admission Rules for admission to educational organizations implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education, divided by their total number.  
21.Availability of minutes of meetings of the appeals commission confirming compliance with the procedure for admission and consideration of appeals (if a complaint has been received).  
22.Compliance with the deadlines for enrollment as students under educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education providing for the training of mid-level specialists and applied bachelor's degree holders. Enrollment is carried out by order of the head of the TVPE organization on the basis of the minutes of the admissions committee meeting: 1) for full-time study – by August 31 of the calendar year; 2) for evening and correspondence forms of education – by September 30 of the calendar year; 3) in TVPE organizations under the jurisdiction of the authorized body in the field of culture and sports – by August 10 of the calendar year; 4) based on applications from enterprises (organizations, institutions) – by August 18 of the calendar year. Enrollment as students under educational programs of technical and vocational education providing for the training of qualified workers is carried out: 1) for full-time study – by August 31 of the calendar year based on the results of an interview; 2) for evening study – by September 30 of the calendar year based on selection taking into account grades in specialized subjects specified in the documents on basic secondary or general secondary education, and the results of the interview.  
23.Compliance with the procedure for transferring a student studying on a paid basis with full reimbursement of costs to study under the state educational order for available vacant places: 1) application or request through the web portal of the "electronic government" from the student (or other legal representatives) requesting transfer to further study under the state educational order; 2) consideration by the collegial body of the student's application for transfer to further study under the state educational order; 3) order on the transfer of the student to further study under the state educational order based on the decision of the collegial body.  
24.Transfer of a student is carried out: From one educational organization to another, provided that the following are available: 1) application for transfer of the student (legal representative); 2) a copy of the student's grade record book (or academic performance record book), certified by the signature of the head and the seal of the educational organization from which the student is transferring. From an organization implementing educational programs of technical and vocational, post-secondary education to organizations implementing general secondary education programs, provided that the following are available: 1) application for transfer (or from other legal representatives); 2) arrival slip issued by the other educational organization. Availability of orders issued by the head of the educational organization (when deciding on the transfer of students): 1) on admission to classes; 2) on taking examinations to cover differences in the curriculum; 3) on enrollment among the students of the educational organization.  
25.Compliance with the conditions for reinstatement: Persons who previously studied at educational organizations shall be reinstated in their former educational organization subject to the mandatory conditions of: availability of an application from the student; completion by the student of one semester (reinstatement of students in the first year shall be carried out upon completion of the first semester). Reinstatement of persons who previously studied at other educational organizations is permitted provided that the following are available: relevant study groups by year and specialty, subject to completion of the existing academic difference in academic disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes (in the absence of a corresponding group by year and specialty, reinstatement in other specialties is permitted subject to completion of the existing academic difference in academic disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes); an order issued by the head of the educational organization approving the procedure and deadlines for eliminating differences in academic disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes in the curricula; the student's personal file; an order on reinstatement of the student in the educational organization indicating the specialty, year and group. Reinstatement of students studying on a paid basis (expelled during the semester for failure to pay for education at the educational organization) is permitted provided that the following are available: application from the student; order on reinstatement of the student in the educational organization. Reinstatement from a foreign educational organization to an educational organization of the Republic of Kazakhstan is permitted provided that the following are available: document confirming completion of educational programs (academic certificate or transcript); document confirming completion of the previous level of education, which undergoes the recognition procedure in the Republic of Kazakhstan; results of entrance examinations for admission to foreign educational organizations; order on reinstatement of the student in the educational organization.  
26.Compliance with the conditions for determining the academic difference in the number of disciplines/modules/credits and/or learning outcomes when transferring students from one educational organization to another, from one form of education to another, from one language department to another, from one specialty to another, and from paid education to education under the state educational order.  
27.Compliance with the conditions for granting academic leave to students is ensured on the following grounds, provided that the following are available: 1) conclusion of the Medical Advisory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the MAC) at an outpatient and polyclinic organization for a period of 6 to 12 months due to illness; 2) decision of the Centralized Medical Advisory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the CMAC) of an anti-tuberculosis organization in the event of tuberculosis, for a period not exceeding 36 months; 3) summons for military service; 4) birth, adoption or fostering of a child until the child reaches the age of three.  
28.Compliance with the requirements of the Standard Rules for Ongoing Monitoring of Academic Performance, Interim and Final Assessment of Students is ensured by the availability of: examination records for interim assessment; orders admitting students to interim assessment, subject to the following requirements: students who have fully completed all practical, laboratory, calculation and graphic assignments, and course papers (projects), and passed the required assessments in accordance with the standard educational programs for each discipline; students who do not have unsatisfactory grades based on the results of ongoing assessment of knowledge; students who have unsatisfactory grades in 1–2 disciplines may be admitted with the permission of the head of the educational organization; students who have more than two unsatisfactory grades may be admitted by decision of the pedagogical council; order of the head of the educational organization admitting students who have not undergone interim assessment due to illness or other valid reasons, with individual deadlines for taking the assessment specified; decision of the pedagogical council and order of the head of the educational organization on expulsion of students who have more than three unsatisfactory grades based on the results of interim assessment; register of issuance of certificates of the established form to students; order of the head of the educational organization on transferring to the next year students who have fully fulfilled the requirements of the curriculum for the relevant year and successfully passed all assessments and examinations of the interim assessment.  
29.Compliance with the requirements of the Standard Rules for Ongoing Monitoring of Academic Performance, Interim and Final Assessment of Students is ensured by the availability of: minutes of meetings of commissions conducting the final assessment of students; minutes of meetings of commissions conducting the final assessment of students concerning the taking of final assessment examinations (individual); minutes of meetings of commissions conducting the final assessment of students concerning the awarding of qualifications (summary); minutes of meetings of commissions conducting the final assessment concerning the review of a student's graduation paper (diploma project (paper)); decision of the attestation commission admitting persons who received an "unsatisfactory" grade when defending a diploma project or taking a final examination to a repeated retake of the final assessment, specifying the deadlines for the repeated final examination in the discipline and/or module for which the unsatisfactory grade was received; certificate of the established form confirming completion of the full course of study in the specialty (profession) for a student who received an "unsatisfactory" grade upon repeated defense of the diploma project or taking final examinations; order of the head of the educational organization admitting students who failed to appear for the defense of a diploma project (paper) or a final examination for a valid reason confirmed by relevant documents, specifying the deadlines for completing the final assessment; diploma issuance books for organizations providing technical and vocational, post-secondary education upon completion of the full course of study, as well as availability of documents confirming the objectivity of issuing a diploma with honors to students who received "excellent" grades in at least 75% of all disciplines in the curriculum, and "good" grades in the remaining disciplines, and defended their diploma project (paper) with "excellent" grades.  
30.Compliance with the requirements prohibiting: 1) assigning teachers to types of work unrelated to their professional duties; 2) requesting from teachers reports or information unrelated to their official duties; 3) imposing on teachers the obligation to purchase goods and services (checked if a complaint has been received).  

Official(s) ________________________________________________________________ ______________________Position Signature

 

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity ________________________________________________________________ ______________________Position Signature

 

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

 Appendix 6 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Separate the repealed and current appendicesRemove the stray Download heading

Checklist for the Education System in the Part of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Respect of Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Programmes of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education

Note. Appendix 6 is set out in the wording of the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication); as amended by the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27 May 2024 No. 121 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 28 May 2024 No. 26 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of sixty calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

State body that appointed the inspection__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Inspection appointment act __________________________________________________________________________________________ No., date

Name of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the controlled entity (facility)

Location address __________________________________________________________________________________________

Download

| No. | List of Requirements | Complies with Requirements | Does Not Comply with Requirements || -- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------- | ---------------------------- || 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 || 1 | Availability of an educational programme entered in the register of educational programmes of the authorised body in the field of education, complying with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education and the professional standard (if available). For medical and pharmaceutical specialities, compliance with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational Education in the Field of Healthcare, standard curricula (if available), and the professional standard (if available) (in the Kazakh and Russian languages). For the training of specialists in the field of education, availability of an educational programme entered in the register of educational programmes of the authorised body in the field of education, in accordance with the professional standard “Teacher”, standard curricula and programmes (if available) (in the Kazakh and Russian languages), taking into account the State Compulsory Standards of Preschool Education and Training and/or Primary and Basic Secondary Education. For educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, compliance of the educational programme, including general education and religious disciplines, coordinated with the authorised body in the field of religious activities. |   |   || 2 | Availability of teachers in accordance with the disciplines and/or modules of the working curriculum for the speciality being taught, including compliance of teachers' education with the profile of the disciplines and/or modules taught, or completion of pedagogical retraining in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of education, as well as industrial training instructors who have completed an internship in organizations and/or at production facilities for at least 36 hours over the last 3 years in the relevant profile. The proportion of teachers and industrial training instructors for whom the licensee is the main place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the speciality being taught, shall be at least 70%, including, for educational organizations implementing medical educational programmes, the proportion of teachers among nurses with an applied bachelor's degree or a master's degree out of the total number of teachers in the speciality shall be at least 10%. The proportion of teachers in educational organizations implementing educational programmes in the field of art and culture, for whom the licensee is the main place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the speciality being taught shall be at least 50%. The proportion of teachers in educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, for whom the licensee is the main place of employment, out of the total number of teachers in the speciality being taught shall be at least 50%. |   |   || 3 | The proportion of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers, teacher-masters and/or persons holding a master's degree, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Doctor by Profile, academic degree of Doctor of Sciences, Candidate of Sciences, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), out of the number of teachers in the speciality being taught for whom the licensee is the main place of employment shall be at least 30%; at least 40% in post-secondary education organizations. The proportion of teachers of specialised disciplines and industrial training instructors who have completed an internship in organizations and/or at production facilities for at least 36 hours over the last 3 years, out of the number of teachers in the speciality being taught for whom the licensee is the main place of employment, shall be at least 10%. The proportion of teachers in educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, teaching general education disciplines and having higher education, and teaching specialised disciplines and having higher education in the relevant field and/or having graduated from a religious seminary or madrasa with a total work experience in the religious sphere of at least 5 (five) years, out of the number of teachers in the speciality being taught, shall be at least 50%. For post-secondary education organizations, the proportion of teachers and industrial training instructors holding a master's degree, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Doctor by Profile, academic degree of Doctor of Sciences, Candidate of Sciences, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), out of the total number of teachers in the speciality being taught, shall be at least 10%. |   |   || 4 | Availability of a library collection of educational and scientific literature in accordance with the working curriculum, relative to the number of students, including by languages of instruction, for the entire period of study in the speciality being taught, in accordance with the State Compulsory Standard of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education, in printed and electronic formats. For educational organizations implementing religious educational programmes, availability of a collection of educational literature that has undergone religious studies examination, in accordance with the educational programme. |   |   || 5 | Availability, for the speciality being taught, of educational and laboratory equipment and technical teaching aids, as well as computer classrooms and computers connected to the Internet, complying with the standards for equipping technical and vocational education organizations with equipment and furniture. For educational organizations in the field of healthcare, availability of a simulation classroom (centre) within the structure of the educational organization. Where necessary, for military educational institutions of the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Kazakhstan, availability of a departmental order on the use of the educational and material facilities of military units and other military educational institutions, and memoranda with organizations of higher and postgraduate education on cooperation in the joint use of the educational and material facilities of military departments. |   |   || 6 | Availability of agreements with organizations designated as practical training bases for the speciality being taught, covering the entire period of study. |   |   || 7 | Availability of medical services for students on the basis of a licence for medical activities. |   |   || 8 | Availability of a food service facility for students. |   |   || 9 | Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, ensuring the quality of educational services (classrooms, workshops, laboratories, checkpoints, sanitary facilities, availability of video surveillance in the premises and/or on the adjacent territories of the educational organization), including educational premises with an area complying with sanitary standards and fire safety requirements. |   |   || 10 | Availability of educational programmes developed by technical and vocational, post-secondary education organizations (hereinafter referred to as TVPE) with the participation of employers, based on the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standard (SCES), professional standards (if available), and WorldSkills professional standards (if available); Compliance of the list and scope of compulsory general education disciplines, as well as advanced and standard-level disciplines, taking into account the profile of the speciality in the following areas: social sciences and humanities, natural sciences and mathematics (for technical and vocational education organizations); Availability in educational programmes of general humanities and socio-economic disciplines or basic modules, as well as professional modules or general professional and specialised disciplines (except for military specialities). |   |   || 11 | Availability of an education management information system with up-to-date databases on the student population in accordance with the requirements approved by the authorised body in the field of education, and compliance of actual data with the National Educational Database. Availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone. |   |   || 12 | For the training of specialists in the field of education specified in the Classifier of Specialities and Qualifications of Technical and Vocational, Post-Secondary Education, availability of a licence and/or an annex to the licence for at least 5 specialities in the field of education, except for educational organizations in the field of culture and sports, educational organizations subordinate to the Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Kazakhstan, and educational organizations ensuring employment of at least 90% of graduates in the relevant speciality within the year of graduation. For the training of specialists in the field of healthcare specified in the Classifier of Specialities and Qualifications of Technical and Vocational Education, availability of a licence and/or an annex to the licence for at least 4 specialities in the field of healthcare, except for educational organizations ensuring employment of at least 90% of graduates in the relevant speciality in the field of healthcare within the year of graduation. |   |   || 13 | Admission of students by colleges in the speciality being taught at least once every 3 years, except for newly established educational organizations. |   |   || 14 | Information on the employment and engagement in work of graduates of the educational organization by specialities, whereby the proportion of employed and working graduates out of the total number of graduates in the speciality within the year of graduation shall be at least 75%. |   |   || 15 | Creation of accommodation conditions (provision of dormitories and/or hostels and/or hotels complying with the requirements of the Sanitary Rules established by the authorised body in the field of healthcare) for students in need, in accordance with the rules established by the authorised body in the field of education. |   |   || 16 | Creation of conditions (ramps, painting doors and staircases in contrasting colours) for persons with special educational needs in buildings (educational buildings). |   |   || 17 | Ensuring professional development of teachers in the relevant field at least once every 3 years, with a duration of at least 36 hours. For heads of educational organizations, professional development in the relevant field and management in the field of education shall be provided at least once every 3 years. |   |   |

Official(s) _____________________________________________________________________________ _______________________

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity ___________________________________________________________ _______________________

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

|   | Appendix 7 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 843 || - | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |

Checklist for the Education System in the Part of Supplementary Education in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Respect of Organizations Providing Supplementary Education to Children

Note. Appendix 7 is set out in the wording of the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

State body that appointed the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility) ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Act appointing the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________ No., date

Name of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________________

Location address __________________________________________________________________________________________

Download

No.List of RequirementsComplies with RequirementsDoes Not Comply with Requirements
1234
1.Availability of constituent and title documents of the supplementary education organization.  
2.Compliance of the activities of the supplementary education organization with the type of educational organization.  
3.Compliance by the supplementary education teacher with official duties and standards of pedagogical ethics (checked where complaints have been received).  
4.Compliance with the principle of state policy regarding the prohibition of the establishment and activities of organizational structures of political parties and religious organizations (associations) in educational organizations (checked where complaints have been received).  
5.Performance of the functions defined by the Charter of the educational organization: 1) list of implemented educational programmes; 2) procedure for admission to the educational organization; 3) procedure for organizing the educational process; 4) grounds and procedure for expelling children; 5) list and procedure for providing paid services; 6) procedure for formalizing relations between the educational organization and children and/or their parents and other legal representatives.  
6.Performance by the head or other official of the supplementary education organization of duties related to ensuring the safety and health of pupils, students and employees of educational organizations during the educational and upbringing process (checked where complaints have been received).  
7.Availability of work plans approved by the supplementary education organization and minutes of meetings of the pedagogical council, methodological council and pedagogical ethics council, as well as materials confirming their activities.  
8.Compliance with the procedure for conducting the certification of teachers, heads and deputy heads of supplementary education organizations and awarding (confirming) qualification categories.  
9.Availability of certificates confirming professional development of management personnel and teachers of supplementary education organizations at least once every three years.  
10.Availability of copies of diplomas with supplements and tariff lists of teachers approved by the educational organization, confirming the provision of teachers having pedagogical or other professional education in the relevant field.  
11.Prevention of the admission to professional teaching activities in an educational organization of persons: 1) deprived of the right to carry out professional teaching activities in accordance with a court verdict that has entered into legal force; 2) declared legally incapacitated or partially incapacitated, as a result of which the employee is unable to continue employment relations; 3) having medical contraindications and being registered with psychiatric and/or narcological services; 4) not having documents confirming technical and vocational, post-secondary, higher or postgraduate education; 5) having or having had a criminal record, or being or having been subject to criminal prosecution for criminal offences involving murder, intentional infliction of harm to health, offences against public health and morality, sexual inviolability, extremist or terrorist crimes, or human trafficking.  
12.Availability of the material and technical facilities necessary for obtaining quality supplementary education.  
13.Availability of supplementary education programmes taking into account the requests of children, the needs of families, educational organizations and public organizations (including children's and youth organizations), the socio-economic development characteristics of the region, and national and cultural traditions.  
14.Availability of registers confirming the recording of grades and the issuance of certificates of qualification in the provision of specialised training for children (art, music and art schools).  
15.Availability of approval from the authorised body in the field of education when establishing relations with foreign and international educational organizations and foundations, participating in international programmes, joining international non-governmental organizations (associations) in the fields of education, culture, sports and tourism, and concluding cooperation agreements in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan.  
16.Compliance with the requirements prohibiting: 1) involving a teacher in types of work unrelated to their professional duties; 2) requesting from a teacher reports or information unrelated to their official duties; 3) imposing on a teacher the obligation to purchase goods and services (checked where a complaint has been received).  
17.Compliance of statistical data in the National Educational Database with the actual data of the educational organization.  
18.Compliance with the procedure for enrolment in supplementary education organizations for children for the purpose of providing them with supplementary education.  
19.Familiarization of parents (legal representatives) of children with the procedure for conducting and the content of the educational and upbringing process, and with the Charter upon admission of children to a supplementary education organization for children.  
20.Availability of a methodological, socio-pedagogical and psychological service.  
21.Organization of the educational and upbringing process in children's music schools, children's art schools and schools of arts in accordance with standard curricula and educational programmes.  
22.Completion of supplementary education programmes in children's music schools, children's art schools and schools of arts and conducting the final state attestation.  
23.Compliance with the procedure for conducting a competition for appointment to and dismissal from the positions of teachers of state educational organizations (checked where complaints have been received) of a state educational organization (checked where complaints have been received).  
24.Compliance of the number and positions of teachers of supplementary education organizations with the standard staffing levels for employees of supplementary education organizations and the list of teaching positions (for state educational organizations).  
25.Availability of subjects in the working curriculum of the supplementary education organization that are not taught due to the absence of specialists.  

Official(s) _____________________________________________________________________________ _______________________

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

Head of the controlled entity ___________________________________________________________ _______________________

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)

|   | Appendix 8 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 843 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Checklist in the Field of State Control over the Education System in Respect of Educational Organizations Implementing Educational Programmes of Higher and Postgraduate Education

Note. Appendix 8 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30 March 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

|   | Appendix 8 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31 December 2015 No. 843 || - | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

Checklist for the Education System in the Part of Providing Educational and Health-Improvement Services to Minors in Accordance with Article 138 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan in Respect of Educational Organizations Providing Educational and Health-Improvement Services to Minors

Note. The Joint Order was supplemented by Appendix 8 in accordance with the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26 June 2024 No. 158 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 26 June 2024 No. 42 (shall enter into force on 1 January 2025).

State body that appointed the inspection __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Inspection appointment act __________________________________________________________________________________________ No., date

Name of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(Individual Identification Number), Business Identification Number of the controlled entity (facility) __________________________________________________________________________________

Location address __________________________________________________________________________________________

Appendix 8

No.List of RequirementsComplies with the RequirementsDoes Not Comply with the Requirements
1234
1.Compliance of working curricula with standard curricula and the State Compulsory Standards of Primary, Basic Secondary and General Secondary Education.  
2.Availability of teachers in accordance with the subjects included in the working curriculum, holding pedagogical education in the relevant fields or professional education supplemented by pedagogical retraining. The proportion of teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment shall be at least 50% of the total number of teachers. The proportion of teacher-experts, teacher-researchers and master teachers for whom the licensee is the primary place of employment shall be at least 25% of the total number of teachers. Compliance of the education and work experience of the head and teachers of the educational organization with the requirements of the Standard Qualification Characteristics of Positions of Teaching Staff.  
3.Availability of a library collection of educational and fiction literature in accordance with the standards and the list of textbooks approved by the authorized body in the field of education. Availability of a set of textbooks per student in accordance with the working curriculum for the projected student enrolment.  
4.Provision of buildings (educational facilities) with equipped medical rooms. Availability of a license for medical activities with the right to provide medical services to children in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of healthcare. Availability of full-time medical personnel in accordance with the rules approved by the authorized body in the field of healthcare.  
5.Availability of a catering facility for students in buildings (educational facilities) on the basis of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion, in accordance with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population.  
6.Availability of material assets owned by the organization or held under the right of economic management, operational management or trust management, or leased material assets with a lease term of at least 10 years, ensuring the quality of educational services, with educational premises complying with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population and fire safety requirements approved by the authorized body in the field of emergency situations. Availability of indoor swimming pools/baths/beaches, children's playgrounds and sports grounds in accordance with the sanitary and epidemiological requirements for children's health and sanatorium facilities, as well as availability on the staff of a sports instructor in therapeutic physical training (LFC) for swimming, in accordance with the Standard Staffing Regulations for Employees of State Educational Organizations.  
7.Equipment with computer classrooms, computers connected to the Internet, subject-specific classrooms, laboratories (for educational and recreational organizations, the availability of recommended educational and laboratory equipment for the subjects of Physics, Chemistry and Biology is sufficient), and sports halls; availability of a third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone; availability of equipment and furniture; organization of drinking water arrangements in accordance with sanitary rules; availability in the building of sanitary facilities (toilets and washbasins) complying with sanitary rules; minimum Internet speed of at least 20 Mbps for up to 400 students, plus 1 Mbps for every 20 students, taking into account the number of students enrolled in one shift. Availability of security service providers, an alarm button, access control arrangements and video surveillance in the premises and/or on the adjacent territory of the organization.  
8.Provision of professional development for teachers in the relevant field at least once every 3 years, with a duration of at least 36 hours. For heads of educational organizations, professional development in the relevant field and in management in the field of education shall be provided at least once every 3 years.  
9.Availability of the National Educational Database (NOBD) information system with up-to-date databases in accordance with the administrative data forms within the framework of educational monitoring, and an education management information system with up-to-date databases corresponding to the administrative data of the NOBD.  
10.Availability of accommodation facilities for children in accordance with the sanitary rules approved by the authorized body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population.  
11.Availability of motor vehicles for transporting children and a driver carrying out the transportation of children, complying with the requirements of the rules approved by the authorized body in the field of road transport.  

Official(s) of the inspection body

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if available)

Head of the Controlled Entity

Position, signature

Surname, first name, patronymic (if available)

 Appendix 9 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Inspection Checklist in the Field of State Control over the Education System in Relation to Education Management Bodies

Note. Appendix 9 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 76 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 30, 2023 No. 41 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

 Appendix 10 to the Joint Order of the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 719 and the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2015 No. 843

Note. Appendix 10 was excluded by the Joint Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 22, 2018 No. 24 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 3, 2018 No. 91 (shall enter into force upon expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).

Constitution Law Code Normative Act Decree Order Resolution Decision Advocate Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Program Charter Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages