On Approval of Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Order of the Acting Minister of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 13, 2021 No. 327. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on August 16, 2021 No. 23994.
In accordance with paragraph 4 of Article 406 of the Environmental Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan and subparagraph 69) of paragraph 15 of the Regulations on the Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan, approved by Resolution No. 479 of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2019, I HEREBY ORDER:
Footnote. The preamble is set out in the wording of Order No. 123 of the Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 17, 2024 No. 123 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
1. To approve the attached Criteria for assessing the environmental conditions of territories.
2. The Department of Environmental Policy and Sustainable Development of the Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall, in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, ensure:
1) state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
2) publication of this Order on the Internet resource of the Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan after its official publication;
3) within ten working days after state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan, submission to the Legal Service Department of the Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan of information on the implementation of the measures provided for in subparagraphs 1) and 2) of this paragraph.
3. To declare invalid:
1) Order of the Minister of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 16, 2015 No. 202 "On Approval of Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 10928).
2) Order of the Acting Minister of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 7, 2017 No. 437 "On Amendments to Order No. 202 of the Minister of Energy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 16, 2015 'On Approval of Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories'" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 16310).
4. Control over the implementation of this Order shall be entrusted to the Vice-Minister of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan overseeing the relevant area.
5. This Order shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication.
| Acting Minister of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan | A. Primkulov |
|---|
"AGREED"Ministry of Agriculture of the Republic of Kazakhstan
"AGREED"Ministry of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan
"AGREED"Ministry of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan
| | Appendix to the Order of the Acting Minister of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 13, 2021 No. 327 || - | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Chapter 1. General Provisions
1. The Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with paragraph 4 of Article 406 of the Environmental Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan and subparagraph 69) of paragraph 15 of the Regulations on the Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan, approved by Resolution No. 479 of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2019.
Footnote. Paragraph 1 is set out in the wording of Order No. 123 of the Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 17, 2024 No. 123 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
2. The criteria for assessing the environmental conditions of territories are a set of indicators characterizing the deterioration of public health and the environment.
3. The criteria for assessing the environmental conditions of territories are used in determining zones of environmental emergency or environmental disaster.
4. The determination of a zone of environmental emergency or a zone of environmental disaster shall be carried out on the basis of one or several main and additional indicators reflecting a higher degree of an unfavorable environmental situation.
5. The criteria for assessing the environmental conditions of territories may be used for other purposes related to determining the state of public health and the environment.
Chapter 2. Criteria for Assessing Air Pollution in Residential Areas
6. During surveys of areas potentially affected by environmental disaster or environmental emergency, the negative impact of air basin pollution shall be taken into account as a result of direct contact with polluted air and/or as a result of the deposition of pollutants from the atmosphere and secondary pollution of water and soil.
7. The concentration of pollutants from individual local sources decreases with distance as a result of dispersion and deposition processes. Maximum concentrations are observed at a distance of approximately 20 stack heights from the source. Concentrations from such sources that are hazardous to human health are observed over an area of no more than 10–100 km2. For coniferous forests, sensitivity to atmospheric pollution is several times higher than that of humans, and the area of vegetation damage reaches 100–1000 km2.
8. The degree of atmospheric air pollution shall be established based on the multiple by which the maximum permissible concentration (hereinafter referred to as MPC) is exceeded, taking into account the hazard class, the summation of the biological effects of air pollutants, and the frequency of MPC exceedances.
9. Actual maximum one-time and daily average concentrations for the last several years, but for no less than 2 years, shall be used to assess the degree of air pollution.
10. Measurement results shall be processed separately for each monitoring station, substance, and year. At least 200 observations (samples) shall be carried out for each substance:
1) assessment of the degree of atmospheric air pollution based on daily average concentrations.
Daily average samples obtained through continuous aspiration over 24 hours, or intermittent aspiration at least 4 times a day at equal time intervals, shall be used to assess the degree of pollution. All concentrations from the collected daily average samples shall be analyzed.
For each daily average concentration, the exceedance ratio "K" shall be calculated. The series calculated using indicator "K" for the analyzed period (year) shall be assessed in accordance with the criteria for assessing the degree of atmospheric air pollution based on daily average concentrations, in accordance with Appendix 1 to these Criteria.
In the presence of a combination of substances having a summation effect, the adjusted daily average concentration (hereinafter referred to as Ссс пр) shall be calculated using formula (1.1). The assessment shall be carried out based on Ссс пр.
Taking into account the specified criteria, materials on all types of atmospheric pollution shall be considered, on the basis of which an expert assessment shall be made regarding the classification of the territory into one or another zone;
2) assessment of atmospheric air pollution based on maximum one-time (single) concentrations.
In order to increase the reliability of the assessment of measurement results and eliminate random values, statistical processing of the data shall be used, making it possible, taking into account variations in concentrations, to obtain a value that will be at or below the calculated concentration (С95) in 95% of cases.
The exceedance ratio (K) shall be calculated using formula (1.1):
К=С95/ПДКм.р. (1.1)
where:
К – exceedance ratio;
С95 – the value that will be at or below the calculated concentration in 95% of cases;
ПДКм.р. – maximum one-time maximum permissible concentration.
In the presence of substances in atmospheric air that have a summation effect on biological action, the concentration adjusted to one of the summing substances (С95 пр) shall be calculated using formula (1.2):
С95пр=С1+С2\*ПДК1/ПДК2+С3\*ПДК1/ПДК3+…+Сn\*ПДК1/ПДКn (1.2)
where:
С1, С2 – concentrations of pollutants having a summation effect;
ПДК – maximum permissible concentration;
С95пр – the concentration value that is at or below the calculated concentration in 95% of cases.
The assessment of the degree of atmospheric air pollution for a combination of summing substances shall be carried out based on the adjusted concentration. The sum of such substances must be adjusted to the substance having the less favorable hazard class.
Atmospheric air pollution by benzo(a)pyrene (hereinafter referred to as BAP) is of predominant significance only in the territories of industrial enterprises for which BAP is one of the leading emission components (anode plants, the aluminum industry, the coke and pitch industry, and others).
Where exceedances of pollution are identified according to the specified criteria for suspended substances, data on the physicochemical properties of the substances shall also be submitted, in accordance with the assessment of the degree of atmospheric air pollution pursuant to Appendix 2 to these Criteria;
3) assessment of average annual atmospheric air pollution using the comprehensive indicator.
For the average annual concentration of pollutants in atmospheric air, data on the state of air pollution in cities and industrial centers for several years, but for no less than two years, shall be calculated or used.
The degree of air pollution shall be calculated taking into account the multiple by which the average annual MPC of substances is exceeded, their hazard class, the permissible frequency of concentrations at a specified level, the number of substances simultaneously present in the air, and the coefficient of their combined effect.
Average annual MPC values (ПДКг) shall be determined using formula (1.3):
ПДКг = а ПДКсс (1.3)
where:
ПДКг – average annual maximum permissible concentration;
ПДКсс – daily average maximum permissible concentration.
The values of coefficient "а" for various substances are provided in Appendix 3 to these Criteria.
The degree of air pollution by substances belonging to different hazard classes (КЗкл) shall be determined by "converting" their concentrations, normalized by MPC, to concentrations of substances of hazard class 3 in accordance with formula (1.4):
КЗкл = Кjn (1.4)
where:
n – isoeffectiveness coefficient;
j – hazard class (n = 2,3 for j = 1; n = 1,3 for j = 2; n = 0,87 for j = 4). (For values of concentrations normalized by MPC exceeding 2.5 for class 1, exceeding 5 for class 2, exceeding 8 for class 3, and exceeding 11 for class 4, "conversion" to class 3 shall be carried out by multiplying the values of concentrations normalized by MPC by 3.2; 1.6; 1; and 0.7, respectively).
In the event of atmospheric air pollution by substances belonging to different hazard classes, the comprehensive indicator P shall be calculated.
The comprehensive indicator P shall be calculated using formula (1.5):
P = Sqrt (Sum (K^2j)) (1.5)
where:
Sqrt (Sum (K^2j)) – the square root of the sum of the squares of concentrations normalized by MPC and converted to the corresponding concentrations of substances of hazard class 3;
j – substance number.
11. The assessment of the degree of total atmospheric air pollution using the comprehensive indicator for assessing average annual atmospheric air pollution using comprehensive indicator P shall be carried out in accordance with Appendix 4 to these Criteria.
12. If, in the comprehensive indicator, any of the substances has a value exceeding the value of the indicator for a single substance, the degree of pollution shall also be assessed for that substance.
Chapter 3. Criteria for Assessing the Sanitary and Epidemiological Situation Related to Drinking and Recreational Water of Centralized Water Supply Systems
13. The results of the assessment of the degree of the sanitary and epidemiological situation shall be based on the stable persistence of negative values of the main indicators over a period of at least one year.
Deviations from the standards must be observed according to several criteria, except in cases of contamination of water sources and drinking water by pathogenic microorganisms and causative agents of parasitic diseases, as well as particularly toxic (extremely hazardous) substances, when the assessment results may be based on a single criterion.
Indicators characterizing the contamination of water sources and drinking water by substances classified as hazard classes three and four, as well as the physicochemical properties and organoleptic characteristics of water, shall be classified as additional indicators.
Additional indicators shall be used to confirm the degree of intensive anthropogenic pollution of water sources determined on the basis of the main indicators, in accordance with Appendix 5 to these Criteria.
Chapter 4. Criteria for Assessing Soil Pollution in Populated Areas
14. Environmental assessment of radioactive contamination of soils in residential areas shall be carried out using the main indicators: the equivalent dose rate at a level of 1 meter above the soil surface (microsievert per hour – µSv/h) and the degree of radioactive contamination by individual technogenic (artificial radionuclides) radioisotopes (kilobecquerels per square meter – kBq/m2).
15. Chemical soil pollution shall be assessed using the total chemical pollution indicator (Zc). The total chemical pollution indicator (Zc) characterizes the degree of chemical contamination of the soils of the surveyed territories by various hazard classes and shall be determined using formula (1.6):
Zc=Kci+…+Kcn-(n-1) (1.6)
where:
Zc – total chemical pollution indicator;
п – number of elements determined;
Kci – concentration coefficient of the i-th pollutant, equal to the quotient obtained by dividing the mass fraction of the i-th substance in contaminated soil by its mass fraction in "background" soil, for heavy metals.
16. For pollutants of non-natural origin, the concentration coefficient shall be determined as the quotient obtained by dividing the mass fraction of the pollutant by its MPC.
Additional indicators of the environmental condition of soils in residential areas include genotoxicity and biological pollution indicators (the number of pathogenic microorganisms, coli-titer, and the content of helminth eggs) specified in the indicators for assessing the sanitary and epidemiological condition of soil in populated areas in accordance with Appendix 6 to these Criteria.
Chapter 5. Criteria for Assessing the Radiation Contamination of a Territory
17. The main criterion characterizing the degree of radioecological safety of a person residing in a contaminated territory is the annual average effective dose from man-made sources of ionizing radiation. Special limits are established for doses from natural and medical exposure, as well as doses resulting from radiation accidents.
The assessment of radiation contamination of a territory shall be carried out in accordance with Appendix 16 to the Hygienic Standards for Ensuring Radiation Safety, approved by Order of the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 2, 2022 No. ҚР ДСМ-71 (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 29012).
Note. Paragraph 17 – as amended by Order No. 123 of the Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 17.06.2024 (shall enter into force upon the expiration of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).
18. The unit of effective dose is the sievert (Sv). The International Commission on Radiological Protection has recommended a dose of 1 mSv/year (millisievert per year) (0.1 rem/year) as the dose limit for the public.
Territories within which the annual average effective dose of exposure to humans from man-made radionuclides does not exceed 1 mSv shall be classified as territories with a relatively satisfactory environmental situation; territories with an annual average effective exposure dose ranging from 1 to 5 mSv shall be classified as territories of an environmental emergency situation; and territories with a dose exceeding 5 mSv shall be classified as environmental disaster areas.
Chapter 6. Criteria for Assessing Changes in the Natural Environment
19. The criteria for changes in the natural environment shall be the following indicators:
1) for assessing atmospheric air pollution by substances affecting terrestrial vegetation and aquatic ecosystems, as specified in Appendix 7 to these Criteria.
The main indicators of atmospheric air pollution characterizing its impact on the natural environment (vegetation, soils, surface water and groundwater) are critical loads and critical levels of pollutants. These are understood as the maximum values of deposition or, respectively, concentrations of pollutants in atmospheric air that do not cause harmful effects on ecosystem structures and functions in the long term.
Exceeding the critical levels and loads for various components by 10–15 times, depending on the sensitivity of ecosystems, may serve as a criterion for identifying environmental disaster zones.
To assess the condition of natural environments, the measured values of pollutant concentrations in atmospheric air or the measured values of deposition intensity U shall be compared with the corresponding data in the table. For acid-forming substances, the measured value of U shall be adjusted by the value of the proportion of the sum of strong acids that has not been neutralized, according to the following ratio:
L = DU,
where:
L – values of atmospheric loads that are compared with critical loads;
D is determined as follows:
D = 1 - R when 0 < R < 1
D = 0 when R > 1
where:
D – A/K – the ratio of the sum of the molar concentrations of anions
to the sum of the molar concentrations of cations
2) for assessing the degree of chemical pollution of surface waters, as specified in Appendix 8 to these Criteria.
Toxic, priority pollutants, including those with cumulative properties that enable them to accumulate in the organs and tissues of aquatic organisms, have been selected as the main indicators for assessing the condition of surface waters.
For the comprehensive assessment of hazardous levels of pollution of water bodies when identifying environmental emergency zones and environmental disaster zones, the formalized total chemical pollution indicator ПХЗ(10) is used. The total chemical pollution indicator ПХЗ(10) is particularly important for territories where chemical pollution is observed simultaneously by several substances, each of which exceeds the permissible level (MPC) many times over.
The additional indicators include generally accepted physicochemical and biological characteristics that provide an overall understanding of the composition and quality of waters. These indicators are used to provide additional characteristics of the processes occurring in water bodies. The additional characteristics include indicators that take into account the ability of pollutants to accumulate in bottom sediments (the bottom accumulation coefficient) and aquatic organisms (Км).
The parameters of the indicators proposed for identifying zones must be observed continuously in the given territory over a sufficiently long period, with a minimum period of at least 3 years. When using saprobity indices according to Pantle and Buck, as modified by Sládeček, the indicator values of species differ in different climatic zones. When applying the Woodiwiss Biotic Index, regional characteristics are taken into account, and the weighting values of "taxonomic groups" depend on the condition of water bodies in different regions.
When assessing the condition of aquatic ecosystems, indicators relating to ichthyofauna are important, especially for unique, specially protected water bodies and water bodies belonging to the first and highest fishery categories. Any additional indicators not included in the mandatory list but providing the necessary information for a more comprehensive characterization of the condition of aquatic ecosystems are also used. As a generalized assessment of the condition of planktonic and benthic animal communities, it is permissible to use an indicator such as the ratio of community production (Рb) to the total metabolic expenditures of all animals comprising it (Rb). This indicator is determined as the ratio between the useful energy output from the system (animal community) and the energy dissipated by animals in metabolic processes in the form of heat;
3) for assessing the condition of aquatic ecosystems, as specified in Appendix 9 to these Criteria;
4) for assessing the depletion of water resources, as specified in Appendix 10 to these Criteria.
The main indicator for assessing the degree of depletion of water resources is the standard for irreversible withdrawal of surface runoff. The standard is the maximum permissible volume of irreversible withdrawal of surface runoff, amounting to 30% of the long-term average value of natural runoff. Irreversible withdrawal of surface runoff includes irreversible water consumption in municipal services, industry, thermal power generation, agricultural water supply, irrigation and industrial fish farming, taking into account evaporation losses, inter-basin transfers of river runoff and other factors. The assessment of the volume of irreversible runoff withdrawal is carried out for the terminal gauging stations of river water management sections. The standards for the maximum permissible withdrawal of surface runoff are established in order to preserve the ecologically sustainable condition of aquatic ecosystems, with the exception of small water bodies, the use of which is possible after a special study and subject to the availability of a positive conclusion from the state environmental assessment;
5) for assessing the ecological condition of marine areas, as specified in Appendix 11 to these Criteria.
The identification of environmental emergency zones and environmental disaster zones in marine areas shall be carried out on the basis of the main chemical and biological indicators, based on the analysis and generalization of the results of long-term observations. For the comprehensive assessment of hazardous levels of chemical pollution of marine waters in cases where several pollutants are identified at concentrations exceeding the MPC, it is proposed to apply, as for freshwater bodies, the formalized total chemical pollution indicator – ПХЗ (10) (based on the 10 pollutants with the highest MPC exceedances). This indicator is applied when identifying environmental emergency zones and environmental disaster zones. Additional indicators of chemical pollution include Biochemical Oxygen Demand-5 and dissolved oxygen. Structural and functional characteristics of bacterio-, phyto- and zooplankton, benthos and ichthyofauna, as well as individual taxa and species of aquatic organisms, are used to assess environmental emergency situations based on biological indicators.
An environmental disaster in a marine ecosystem is characterized by a sharp change in the abundance and biomass of the species remaining in the communities and, in the case of eutrophication of marine areas, by massive algal "blooms" (for example, "red tides"), the disappearance of benthic flora and fauna, and a sharp increase in the concentrations of indicator microorganisms. An additional biological indicator for assessing the condition of marine ecosystems is the indicator of "morphological changes in aquatic organisms".
Indicators not included in the main list of indicators but providing additional information on the nature, causes and degree of the adverse situation are also used. These include:
an integral assessment of pollution of marine waters and bottom sediments by substances having a mutagenic effect on test objects (standard strains of microorganisms). The mutagenic effect is expressed as the percentage of samples causing mutations in standard strains. A relatively satisfactory situation is characterized by a level of less than 5%. An environmental emergency situation is characterized by 20–30%, and an environmental disaster by more than 30%. Assessment of bottom sediment pollution by compounds with mutagenic activity reflects the duration of the environmental situation in the marine area;
critical concentrations of pollutant impact (КК). The values of КК characterize the maximum permissible level of pollution (μg/l) of the aquatic environment by toxic substances. In an environmental emergency situation, in which changes in the functioning of marine ecosystems are still reversible, КК ranges from 1 to 2.
In the event of an environmental disaster, expressed in the severe degradation of the marine ecosystem, КК exceeds 2–3;
6) for assessing the degree of groundwater pollution in areas within the zone of influence of economic facilities, as specified in Appendix 12 to these Criteria.
Groundwater pollution in areas within the zone of influence of economic facilities is characterized by the concentration of pollutants and the size of the area of contamination;
7) for assessing the condition of soils, as specified in Appendix 13 to these Criteria.
The selection of criteria for the environmental assessment of soil conditions is determined by the specifics of their location, genesis, buffering capacity, as well as the diversity of their uses. Identifying types of activities that cause soil pollution provides a complete understanding of the scale and degree of pollution in the surveyed territory and makes it possible to significantly narrow down and specify the number of indicators.
In assessing the environmental condition of soils, the main indicators of the degree of environmental deterioration are the criteria of physical degradation, chemical pollution and biological pollution.
The area of land withdrawn from agricultural use as a result of soil degradation (erosion, deflation, secondary salinization, solonetzization, waterlogging) is used as a criterion for the environmental condition of a territory. A number of negative processes (mechanical removal of the soil cover during open-pit mining and construction works; human-induced water erosion and deflation) lead to the destruction of soil horizons, the degree of which is also used as a criterion for soil degradation. The destruction of soil structure and the development of processes of compaction and loss of soil structure are characterized by the degree of increase in soil density, which is an important indicator of soil degradation. An increase in the groundwater level is recommended to be assessed relative to the critical value, which differs for each soil type. For the ecotoxicological assessment of soils, it is advisable to use the multiple by which the MPC of a specific pollutant is exceeded, differentiated according to the hazard class of the substances. Due to the absence of approved MPC values for a number of pollutants (for example, cadmium), the ratio of the content of pollutants in the liquid phase of the soil (soil solution) to the corresponding MPC value for natural waters is used.
Phytotoxicity is taken as the comprehensive indicator of soil pollution – the property of contaminated soil to suppress seed germination and the growth and development of higher plants (test indicator). A sign of biological soil degradation is a decrease in the vital activity of soil microorganisms, established by a reduction in the level of active microbial biomass, as well as by the more widely used but less accurate indicator of soil respiration. The assessment of the environmental condition of soils based on the criteria and parameters is carried out taking into account the area over which the criterion under consideration is manifested, the significance of which is determined by regional characteristics. The extent to which the maximum permissible standards for pollutants in soil are exceeded should primarily be assessed on the basis of the mobile forms of these substances.
One of the indicators of the environmental condition of soils is the biological productivity of coenoses, which characterizes potential fertility. For soils in agricultural territories, this indicator is average crop yield. For an environmental disaster territory, a reduction in crop yield of more than 75% is applied, and for an environmental emergency territory, a reduction of 50–75%, provided that the entire set of agrotechnical and agrochemical measures appropriate for the given locality and crop is observed. An additional indicator serving as an indicator of the degree of pollution of the territory under consideration (soil, air, irrigation and groundwater) is the share of products that do not comply with the requirements of regulatory and technical documentation on product quality (residual amounts of pesticides, toxic elements, mycotoxins, nitrates, nitrites, etc.).
Data on soil conditions shall be presented in the form of detailed thematic cartographic materials, including information on the main indicators and the component composition of pollutants;
8) indicators for assessing the environmental hazard of deformations and changes in the geological environment, as specified in Appendix 14 to these Criteria.
Geodynamic indicators of deformation of the geological environment with environmental consequences are presented in the form of the intensity and scale of manifestations of the current stress-strain state of the upper parts of the lithosphere. These indicators are determined by the parameters of critical deformation rates and the scale of the expected seismic effect. If we proceed from the value of the destruction threshold of any solid bodies, which is approximately 0.0001 relative units, then a deformation value of 0.00001 relative units may be used as the limiting (critical) level of geodynamic impact for all types of facilities, and is applied when assessing anomalous man-made deformations. Based on established facts of spatial and temporal changes in current deformation processes in fault zones, the limiting (critical) deformation level of 0.00001 is reached in local zones within 15–30 years. These periods are comparable to the minimum service life of particularly critical facilities and structures. Disruption of their functioning will lead to critical environmental consequences. A deformation level of 0.0001 relative units leads to such disturbances of the geological environment that they may be classified as environmental disaster zones.
Exogenous geological processes may occur independently of human activity. Technogenic factors intensify or weaken the manifestation of exogenous geological processes. Human intervention in the natural course of exogenous geological processes leads to irreversible changes in natural landscapes (landslides, mudflows, karst processes, surface subsidence and others);
9) for assessing the degradation of terrestrial ecosystems, as specified in Appendix 15 to these Criteria.
The degree of ecosystem degradation is assessed according to criteria that determine negative changes in the structure and functioning of ecosystems.
In an environmental emergency zone, the condition of ecosystems is characterized by a change in the ratio of the main trophic groups, with a decrease (or increase) in the specific mass of one of the groups within the range of 20–50%. In this case, relationships within the ecosystem are disrupted, but degradation processes have not yet become irreversible. In environmental disaster zones, the condition of ecosystems is characterized by a decrease (or increase) in the specific mass of one of the trophic links by more than 50%.
When assessing the environmental condition of a territory, both the area over which negative changes occur (since, with an equal degree of degradation of a territorial section, the possibility of its restoration is inversely proportional to its area) and the spatial heterogeneity of the distribution of areas with varying degrees of degradation within the territory under study shall be taken into account.
The rate of ecosystem degradation is calculated on the basis of 5–10-year observation series. The direction and rate of ecosystem degradation under conditions of environmental stress are assessed in order to forecast the deterioration of the environmental situation and implement measures to stabilize and improve it;
10) for assessing the condition of vegetation as an indicator of the environmental condition of a territory, as specified in Appendix 16 to these Criteria.
The criteria for assessing the condition of vegetation differ depending on geographical conditions and ecosystem types. At the same time, negative changes are taken into account both in the structure of vegetation cover (reduction in the area of native associations, changes in forest cover) and at the level of plant communities and individual species (populations): changes in species composition, deterioration in the degree of association and the age spectrum of coenopopulations of dominant species.
The population density of indicator species is one of the most important indicators of the condition of an ecosystem and is highly sensitive to the main anthropogenic factors. As a result of anthropogenic impact, the population density of negative indicator species will decrease, while that of positive indicator species will increase. A reduction (or increase) in the population density of an indicator species by 20% should be considered a threshold value, and a reduction (or increase) by 50% should be considered a critical value.
One of the significant parameters of coenopopulations (ЦП) is the age aspect – the proportion of individuals in different age states within a coenopopulation. Age states are established on the basis of a set of morphological characteristics or, where determining it does not present particular difficulties, on the basis of absolute age.
This parameter responds to various forms of anthropogenic impact, both direct (grazing, logging, technogenic impacts) and indirect, through changes in the ecotope.
The condition of vegetation is considered an indicator of the level of anthropogenic pressure on the natural habitat (damage to tree stands or needles caused by technogenic emissions, reduction in projective cover and productivity of pasture vegetation).
A decrease in the timber stock of the main forest-forming species indicates a process of degradation of forest ecosystems as a result of unsatisfactory forest management activities.
Forest fires are a hazardous factor leading to the degradation of significant areas of forest ecosystems. Extensive burned areas where forest regeneration does not occur for at least 10 years are a sign of irreversible changes in the ecosystem. When assessing the condition of forest plantations, the regional characteristics of the territory and the possibility of natural forest regeneration shall be taken into account.
Certain criteria for the condition of agrocenoses indicate an unfavorable environmental situation in the territory as a whole: the development of pests on crops, crop failure, etc. When using these criteria, the causes of crop failure shall be indicated and the areas of negative changes shall be shown on the map.
Damage to vegetation in nature reserves indicates changes in the habitat.
Changes in the qualitative and quantitative characteristics of vegetation cover may be objectively interpreted only in comparison with the natural condition of plant communities. In this case, background areas are understood to mean relatively undisturbed areas that are similar to the territory under study in terms of their natural and landscape characteristics;
11) for assessing the condition of fauna and changes in the animal gene pool as an indicator of the environmental condition of a territory, as specified in Appendix 17 to these Criteria.
Criteria and indicators of the condition of wildlife are considered at the level of zoocenoses and individual animal species (populations).
Changes in diversity, as a criterion for assessing the condition of a zoocenosis as a whole, must be calculated taking into account the fact that this criterion is related to the assessment of abundance and that the numbers of many animals are subject to cyclical changes.
A time interval for assessment must be established by comparing 10-year periods. Diversity is assessed using the Simpson criterion (D), which is calculated according to the formula:
D=1/P1²+…+Pn²
where:
Р1. Рn – the proportion of each species in the total abundance, taken as one unit. To conduct this assessment, it is not necessary to use data on the entire fauna; the analysis may be limited to characteristic groups of species for which reliable information is available.
Changes in economically significant animal species are assessed using data on absolute abundance averaged over 10-year periods and require statistical processing.
When assessing changes in the population density of species that indicate anthropogenic pressure, their different responses to impacts must be taken into account: populations of resistant species will increase in number, while populations of species sensitive to anthropogenic pressure will decrease;
12) biochemical indicators for assessing territories, as specified in Appendix 18 to these Criteria.
From a biochemical perspective, environmentally disadvantaged territories may be regarded as biogeochemical provinces characterized by a sharp change in the chemical elemental composition of environmental components. These provinces may be of both natural and technogenic origin.
To assess the environmental condition of territories, it is proposed to use indicators of changes in the ratios of C:N, Ca:P and Ca:Sr content in various environmental components, as well as the levels of toxic and biologically active trace elements in plant cuttings from test plots and in plant fodder.
Chapter 7. Medical and Demographic Indicators for Assessing the Health Condition of the Population Used to Assess the Environmental Situation in a Territory
20. The main medical and demographic indicators include morbidity, infant mortality, medical and genetic disorders, specific diseases and oncological diseases that may reflect the impact of the environment.
21. Medical and demographic indicators for environmentally disadvantaged territories shall be compared with similar indicators for control (background) territories located in the same climatic and geographical zones. Settlements or their individual parts with similar socio-economic living conditions, a favorable environmental situation and no factors affecting environmental quality shall be accepted as such control (background) territories.
These indicators shall be determined separately for urban and rural populations. The average value of several minimum indicators shall be accepted as the control (background) value. Average indicators for the Republic and the region, calculated over a period of 10 years, and/or their dynamics over this period shall be used as control values. The use of data for the territory from previous years is permitted. When calculating medical indicators, data from state medical statistics, specialized digital systems, disease-specific registers, and, as supplementary information, the results of specially conducted population-based or cohort studies may be used (taking into account the high degree of reliability of the information provided). As an exception, relatively rare diseases, as well as specific diseases and other health disorders etiologically associated with environmental factors of anthropogenic pressure, may be used.
Note. Paragraph 21 as amended by Order No. 88 of the Minister of Ecology and Natural Resources of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 13.05.2026 (shall enter into force on 12.07.2026).
22. When preparing materials on medical and demographic indicators, the complete primary data on the basis of which a decision is made to classify a territory as an environmental disadvantage zone according to medical and demographic indicators shall be submitted. In addition to the submitted materials, any other materials characterizing the health condition of the population and the impact of environmental pollution on it shall be submitted to the authorized state bodies in the field of healthcare.
Medical and demographic indicators for assessing the health condition of the population used to assess the environmental situation in a territory are specified in Appendix 19 to these Criteria.
23. The submitted materials shall include complete information on the "Main Indicators" appendices and, where possible, on the "Additional Indicators" appendices. The identification of an environmental emergency zone or an environmental disaster zone shall be carried out on the basis of one or several main and additional indicators reflecting a higher degree of environmental deterioration (in cases where environmental deterioration has been established).
Appendix 1 to the Criteria
Assessment of the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Criteria for assessing the degree of atmospheric air pollution based on average daily concentrations
Download
| Hazard class | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency ||---|---|---|| | K | Number of days (N) with K | K | Number of days (N) with K || I | >3 | 75 | 77.5 | >30 consecutive days | 5–7.5 | >30 consecutive days || IV | >12 | >30 consecutive days | 8–12 | >30 consecutive days |
Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Assessment of the Degree of Atmospheric Air Pollution
Download
| Indicators | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency ||---|---|---|| | K | % of measurements exceeding K | K | % of measurements exceeding K || Class I | >5 | >30 | >3–5 | >30 || Class II | >7.5 | >30 | >5–7.5 | >30 || Class III | 12.5 | >50 | 8–12.5 | >50 || Class IV | 20.0 | >50 | 12.5–20 | >50 |
Appendix 3 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Values of coefficient "a" for various substances:
Download
| Substances | Coefficient "a" |
|---|---|
| Ammonia, nitrogen oxide, nitrogen dioxide, benzene, benzo(a)pyrene, manganese dioxide, ozone, sulfur dioxide, carbon disulfide, synthetic fatty acids, phenol, formaldehyde, chloroprene. | 1 |
| Trichloroethylene | 0.4 |
| Amines, aniline, suspended substances (dust), carbon monoxide, chlorine | 0.34 |
| Soot, sulfuric acid, phosphorus anhydride, fluorides (solid) | 0.3 |
| Acetaldehyde, acetone, diethylamine, toluene, hydrogen fluoride, hydrogen chloride, ethylbenzene | 0.2 |
| Acrolein | 0.1 |
Appendix 4 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Comprehensive indicator for assessing average annual atmospheric air pollution using the comprehensive indicator
Download
| P for the number of substances | Parameter | Relatively satisfactory situation | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 substance | More than 16 | 8–16 | ||
| 2–4 substances | More than 32 | 16–32 | ||
| 5–9 substances | More than 48 | 32–48 | ||
| 10–16 substances | More than 64 | 48–64 | ||
| 16–25 substances | More than 80 | 64–80 | ||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | ||
| 4 | 5 |
Appendix 5 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Indicators for assessing the sanitary and epidemiological situation related to drinking water from centralized water supply systems
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameter | Satisfactory situation* | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Total microbial count (number of colony-forming bacteria in 1 ml) | More than 250 | 50–250 | No more than 50 | |
| 2 | Total coliform bacteria (number of bacteria in 100 ml)¹ | More than 10 | Single occurrence | Absence | |
| 3 | Thermotolerant coliform bacteria (number of bacteria in 100 ml)² | More than 10 | Single occurrence | Absence | |
| 4 | Coliphages (number of plaque-forming units (PFU) in 100 ml) | More than 10 | Less than 10 | Absence | |
| 5 | Spores of sulfite-reducing clostridia (number of spores in 20 ml)³ | More than 10 | Single occurrence | Absence | |
| 6 | Giardia cysts (number of cysts in 50 l)⁴ | More than 100 | 1–100 | Absence |
¹ Exceeding the standard for total coliform bacteria is not permitted in 95% of samples collected at water distribution points of the external and internal water supply networks over a period of 12 months, provided that at least 100 samples are tested per year.
² When determining thermotolerant coliform bacteria, a threefold examination of 100 ml of the collected water sample is carried out.
³ Determination of sulfite-reducing clostridia spores is carried out when assessing the effectiveness of water treatment technology.
⁴ Determination of coliphages and Giardia cysts is carried out only in water supply systems using surface water sources, before water is supplied to the distribution network.
*In accordance with sanitary and epidemiological requirements pursuant to Article 95 of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Public Health and the Healthcare System".
Indicators for assessing the sanitary and epidemiological hazard of contamination of drinking water and drinking water sources with chemical substances
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameter | Satisfactory situation* | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
| 1. Main indicators | |||||
| 1.1 | Content of toxic substances of hazard class 1 (extremely hazardous substances): beryllium, mercury, benzo(a)pyrene, lindane, 3, 4, 7, 8 dioxin², dichloroethylene, diethylmercury, gallium, tetraethyl lead, tetraethyl tin, trichlorobiphenyl, multiples of the MPC standards | >3 | 2–3 | Within hygienic standards (MPC)* | |
| 1.2 | Content of toxic substances of hazard class 2 (highly hazardous substances): aluminum, barium, boron, cadmium, molybdenum, arsenic, nitrites, lead, selenium, strontium, cyanides, in MPC | >10 | 5–10 | Within hygienic standards (MPC)* | |
| 2. Additional indicators | |||||
| 2.1 | Content of toxic substances of hazard classes 3 and 4 (hazardous and moderately hazardous substances): ammonium, nickel, nitrates, chromium, copper, manganese, zinc, phenols, petroleum products, phosphates (in MPC) | >15 | 10–15 | Within hygienic standards* | |
| 2.2. Physical and chemical properties | |||||
| 2.2.1 | pH | 0.75 | 0.75–0.25 | 0.25 | |
| 2.2.3 | Surfactants (anionic) (mg/l) | >2.5 | 2.5–0.5 | 0.5 | |
| 2.2.4 | Total mineralization (dry residue, mg/l) | >5000 | 5000–1000 | 1000 (1500) | |
| 2.2.5 | Total hardness (meq/l) | >21 | 21–7 | 7.0 (10) | |
| 2.2.6 | Total alpha radioactivity (Bq/l) | >0.5 | 0.5–0.1 | 0.1 | |
| 2.2.7 | Total beta radioactivity (Bq/l) | >5 | 5–1 | 1.0 | |
| 2.3. Organoleptic characteristics | |||||
| 2.3.1 | Odor and taste, points | >4 | 4–2 | 2 | |
| 2.3.2 | Turbidity (EMF) | >8 | 8–2.6 | 2.6 (3.5) | |
| Turbidity (mg/l, according to kaolin) | >4.5 | 4.5–1.5 | 1.5 (2) | ||
| 2.3.3 | Floating impurities (films, oil stains, etc.) | Dark-colored film covering up to 2/3 of the visible area | Bright stripes or dull-colored spots | Absence |
¹ The degree of contamination hazard of drinking water sources is assessed taking into account the effect of the threshold concentration of substances on the sanitary condition of water bodies and the barrier capacity of the water treatment technology used.
² For dioxins, the permissible level is 0.02 ng/l.
Explanation: The assessment of the hazard of contamination by substances not specified in Appendix 5 shall be carried out in accordance with sanitary standards and regulations.
*In accordance with sanitary and epidemiological requirements pursuant to Article 95 of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Public Health and the Healthcare System".
Indicators for assessing the sanitary and epidemiological situation related to the quality of water in water sources intended for drinking and recreational purposes
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameter | Satisfactory situation | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency ||---|---|---|---|---|---|| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | || 1. Water of water sources | | | | | || 1.1 | Intestinal pathogenic protozoa: Giardia cysts, dysentery amoebae, balantidia | More than 100¹ | 1–100 | Absence || 1.2 | Geohelminths: | | | | || | Ascarid, whipworm and trichostrongylid eggs | More than 5 | 1–5 | Absence || 1.3 | Biohelminths: | | | | || | Tapeworm eggs | More than 10 | 1–10 | Absence || 1.4 | Actinomycetes, CFU/dm³ – content of colony-forming units in 1 dm³ of water | More than 10,000 | 100–10,000 | Absence || 2. Recreational waters | | | | | || 2.1 | Intestinal pathogenic protozoa: Giardia cysts, dysentery amoebae, balantidia, cryptosporidia¹ | More than 100 | 1–100 | Absence || 2.2 | Geohelminths: ascarid, whipworm and trichostrongylid eggs¹ | More than 5 | 1–5 | Absence || 2.3 | Biohelminths: | | | | || 2.3.1 | Opisthorchid and diphyllobothriid eggs¹ | More than 100 | 1–100 | Absence || 2.3.2 | Tapeworm eggs¹ | More than 10 | 1–10 | Absence || 2.3.3 | Schistosomatid eggs (causative agents of cercarial dermatitis)¹ | More than 10 | 1–10 | Absence || 2.4 | Actinomycetes, CFU/dm³ – content of colony-forming units in 1 dm³ of water¹ | More than 1,000,000 | 1,000–1,000,000 | Absence, isolated occurrence |
¹ Number of pathogens (cysts, eggs) in 1 dm³ of water.
Appendix 6 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Indicators for assessing the sanitary and epidemiological condition of soil in populated areas
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameter | Relatively satisfactory situation* | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Content of helminth eggs in 1 kg of soil | More than 100 | 11–100 | Less than 10 | |
| 2 | Anaerobe titer | 0.0001 | 0.001–0.0001 | 0.001–0.1 | |
| 3 | Coli-titer | Less than 0.001 | 0.01–0.001 | 0.01–1.0 | |
| 4 | Number of fly larvae and pupae in an area of 0.25 m | More than 100 | 10–100 | 1–10 | |
| 5 | Indicator of contamination with exogenous chemical substances – multiple of MPC exceedance | More than 100 | 10–100 | 1–10 | |
| 6 | Soil self-purification indicator – thermophile titer | Less than 0.00001 | 0.00001–0.00002 | 0.001–0.0002 | |
| 7 | Khlebnikov Sanitary Number¹ | Less than 0.7 | 0.7–0.85 | 0.85–0.98 |
¹ "Khlebnikov Sanitary Number" – the ratio of the amount of soil protein nitrogen (in milligrams per 100 grams of absolutely dry soil) to the amount of organic nitrogen (in milligrams per 100 grams of absolutely dry soil).
*In accordance with sanitary and epidemiological requirements pursuant to Article 95 of the Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Public Health and the Healthcare System".
Appendix 7 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Indicators for assessing atmospheric air pollution by substances affecting terrestrial vegetation and aquatic ecosystems
Download
| Substance, mg/m³ | Parameter | Standard | Exposure time ||---|---|---|---|| Critical levels for terrestrial vegetation | | | || Sulfur dioxide | >200 (environmental disaster); 100–200 (environmental emergency); 300 (environmental disaster); 200–300 (environmental emergency); 20 (environmental disaster); 10–20 (environmental emergency); 1500 (environmental disaster); 1000–1500 (environmental emergency); 600 (environmental disaster); 400–600 (environmental emergency); 500 (environmental disaster); 300–500 (environmental emergency); 5.0 (environmental disaster); 3.0–5.0 (environmental emergency); 4.0 (environmental disaster); 2.0–4.0 (environmental emergency); 300 (environmental disaster); 200–300 (environmental emergency); 6.5 || 6 | Chemical oxygen demand (COD), anthropogenic component relative to background, mg/dm³ | | 20–30 | 10–20 | 50 || 8 | Biogenic substances: | | | | || 9 | Nitrites (NO₂), MPC | | More than 10 | 10–5 | 5–1 || 10 | Nitrates (NO₃), MPC | | More than 20 | 20–10 | 10–1 || 11 | Ammonium salts (NH₄), MPC | | More than 10 | 10–5 | 5–1 || 12 | Phosphates (PO₄), mg/dm³ | | More than 0.6 | 0.6–0.3 | 0.3–0.5 || 13 | Mineralization, mg/dm³ (exceedance of the regional level) | | 3–5 | 2–3 | Regional level || 14 | BAF (bottom accumulation factor) | | More than n·10⁴ | n·10³–n·10⁴ | n·10 || 15 | Kₙ (accumulation coefficient in aquatic organisms) | | More than n·10⁵ | n·10⁴–n·10⁵ | n·10⁴ |
Appendix 9 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Indicators for assessing the condition of aquatic ecosystems
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameters | Relatively satisfactory situation | Environmental disaster | Environmental emergency ||---|---|---|---|---|---|| | | | | | || Main indicators | | | | | || 1 | Phytoplankton | | Absence of algae or isolated specimens of species | Film of blue-green algae, strands of filamentous algae, individual representatives of other algal groups | Natural development of phytoplankton || 2 | Chlorophyll "a" concentration, μg/l | | More than 50 | 50–30 | 30–10 || 3 | Average summer phytoplankton biomass, mg/dm³ | | More than 100 | 100–50 | 50–10 || 4 | Filamentous algae phytomass, kg/m² | | More than 3 | 3.0–2.6 | 10 >20 | 0.4–0.1 or 5–10 >20 || 4 | Ca:Sr ratio in plants and feed (numerator), taking into account the area of the anomalous landscape, % (denominator) | | 20 | 20 || 5 | Content of biologically important trace elements in plant cuttings and plant feed, in mg/kg of air-dry matter: | | | || | Zinc | | Less than 10 or more than 500 | 10–30 or 100–500 || | Iron | | Less than 20 or more than 500 | 20–50 or 200–500 || | Molybdenum | | Less than 0.2 or more than 50 | 0.2–2 or more than 10–50 || | Cobalt | | Less than 0.1 or more than 50 | 0.1–0.3 or 5–50 || | Boron | | Less than 0.1 or more than 300 | 0.1–0.3 or 30–300 |
Appendix 19 to the Criteria for Assessing the Environmental Conditions of Territories
Medical and demographic indicators for assessing the health status of the population, used to assess the environmental conditions of a territory
Download
| No. | Indicator | Parameter | Environmental disaster zone | Environmental emergency zone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main indicators | ||||
| 1 | Increase and change in the structure of child mortality under the age of 5 | 1.5 times or more | From 1.3 to 1.5 times | |
| 2 | Increase in infant mortality | 1.5 times or more | From 1.3 to 1.5 times | |
| Medical and genetic indicators | ||||
| 3 | Increase in the frequency of congenital malformations in newborns and spontaneous miscarriages | 1.5 times or more | From 1.3 to 1.5 times | |
| 4 | Changes in morbidity among children and adults, increase in the prevalence by age groups of diseases of the respiratory system, diseases of the blood, hematopoietic organs and immune system, diseases of the digestive system, diseases of the genitourinary system, diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue, changes in the morbidity structure | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | |
| 5.1 | Morbidity structure for leading nosologies and oncological diseases among men | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | |
| 5.2 | Morbidity structure for leading nosologies and oncological diseases among women | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | |
| 6 | Malignant neoplasms in children | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | |
| Additional indicators | ||||
| 7 | Increase in disorders of women's reproductive function¹, ², ³ | |||
| Complications in the course and outcomes of pregnancy (total number of cases per 1,000 pregnant women); | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | ||
| Unsatisfactory condition of full-term newborns (assessment according to the APGAR score, number of cases per 1,000 full-term newborns) | 2 times or more | From 1.5 to 2 times | ||
| 8 | Frequency of births of children weighing less than 2500 g² | Criteria shall be established based on expert assessments, taking into account the severity of changes in the main indicators | ||
| 9 | Changes in body weight, height, head circumference in newborns, changes in the sex ratio, deviation from similar indicators in control territories | Criteria shall be established based on expert assessments, taking into account the severity of changes in the main indicators | ||
| 10 | Lag behind similar indicators in control territories, in years: | |||
| At the age of 15 | More than 3.4; 3.4 | More than 2.5; 2.5 | ||
| At the age of 35 | More than 2.5; 2.5 | More than 2.0; 2.4 | ||
| At the age of 65 | More than 2.0; 2.0 | More than 1.7; 1.8 | ||
| 11 | Physical development of children: increase in the proportion of children with deviations in physical development when assessed according to the regional standard dating back 7–10 years⁵ | 50% or more | From 30 to 50% | |
| 12 | Mental development of children: proportion of children with deviations in mental development | 20% or more | From 10 to 20% | |
| 13 | Genetic disorders: increase in the frequency of genetic disorders in human cells (chromosomal aberrations, DNA breaks) in territories where a significant or prolonged exceedance of the level of pollutants in air, water and other environmental components has previously been established | 3 times or more | From 1 to 3 times | |
| 14 | Changes in immune status: increase in the number of people with pronounced shifts in immunograms according to morphological and humoral indicators among the population of large urbanized cities | Criteria shall be established based on expert assessments, taking into account the severity of changes in the main indicators | ||
| 15 | Content of toxic chemical substances in human biosubstrates (blood, urine, hair, teeth, saliva, placenta, breast milk, etc.), exceeding permissible biological levels for the population of large urbanized cities or geochemical provinces | Criteria shall be established based on expert assessments, taking into account the severity of changes in the main indicators |
Notes:
For items 1 and 2: exceedance of average values compared with control (background) values in a territory with a population of at least 30,000 people, based on data for 5 years, and at least 50,000 people – for 3 years, separately for urban and rural populations;
Note to items 1 and 2: changes in the traditional structure of infant mortality are also taken into account;
Note to item 1 of the main indicators: the ratio of the number of stillbirths.
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Services Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases Disputes Defense Arbitration Law Firm Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Standards Note Rules Program Charter Constitution Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages