Payment for services is made exclusively to the company's account. For your convenience, we have launched Kaspi RED 😎

Home / Government Decrees / On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Knowledge of Students in Secondary, Technical and Vocational, and Post-Secondary Education

On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Knowledge of Students in Secondary, Technical and Vocational, and Post-Secondary Education

АMANAT партиясы және Заң және Құқық адвокаттық кеңсесінің серіктестігі аясында елге тегін заң көмегі көрсетілді

On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Knowledge of Students in Secondary, Technical and Vocational, and Post-Secondary Education

Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 21, 2016 No. 52. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on February 19, 2016 No. 13137.

Note. The title is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

RCPI Note!

For the procedure for bringing the Order into force, see paragraph 4.

In accordance with subparagraph 22) of Article 5 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Education", I HEREBY ORDER:

Note. The preamble is in the wording of Order No. 98 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30.04.2025 No. 98 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. To approve the attached criteria for assessing the knowledge of students in secondary, technical and vocational, and post-secondary education.

Note. Paragraph 1 is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. The Department of Preschool and Secondary Education and Information Technologies (Zhontayeva Zh.A.) shall, in accordance with the procedure established by law, ensure:
  2. state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
  3. within ten calendar days after state registration of this Order, submission of a copy thereof for official publication in periodicals and in the Information and Legal System "Adilet", as well as to the Republican State Enterprise on the Right of Economic Management "Republican Center for Legal Information of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan" for placement in the Reference Control Bank of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
  4. placement of this Order on the Internet resource of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
  5. within ten working days after state registration of this Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan, submission to the Legal Department of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan of information on the implementation of the measures provided for in subparagraphs 1), 2) and 3) of this paragraph.
  6. Control over the implementation of this Order shall be assigned to the Vice-Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Imangaliyev E.N.).
  7. This Order shall enter into force on September 1, 2016 for Grade 1, on September 1, 2017 for Grades 2, 5 and 7, on September 1, 2018 for Grades 3, 6, 8 and 10, and on September 1, 2019 for Grades 4, 9, 11 and 12, and shall be subject to official publication.

Note. Paragraph 4 is in the wording of Order No. 422 of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 04.07.2016 No. 422 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of KazakhstanA. Sarinzhipov
 Approved by Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 21, 2016 No. 52

Criteria for Assessing the Knowledge of Students in Secondary, Technical and Vocational, and Post-Secondary Education.

Note. The title is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

Chapter 1. General Provisions

Note. The title of Chapter 1 is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. These Criteria for Assessing the Knowledge of Students in Secondary, Technical and Vocational, and Post-Secondary Education (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with subparagraph 22) of Article 5 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Education", and determine the assessment of students' academic achievements in organizations providing primary, basic secondary and general secondary education, technical and vocational, and post-secondary education, regardless of their form of ownership and departmental subordination.

Note. Paragraph 1 is in the wording of Order No. 98 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 30.04.2025 No. 98 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. The following concepts are used in these Criteria:
  2. learning objectives – statements that formulate the expected results in terms of achieving knowledge, understanding and skills during a subject course in accordance with the curriculum;
  3. criterion-based assessment – a process based on comparing students' academic achievements against clearly defined assessment criteria, known in advance to all participants in the educational process, which correspond to the objectives and content of education;
  4. assessment criteria – statements that enable teachers and students to achieve learning objectives during formative assessment and statements that also assess work well performed by students during summative assessment (criteria for awarding points);
  5. formative assessment – assessment that determines the current level of knowledge acquisition and skill development of students during lessons and at home, provides prompt feedback between the student and the teacher during the learning process, and enables students to understand how correctly they are completing assignments while studying new material and achieving learning objectives;
  6. summative assessment – assessment that determines the level of knowledge acquisition and skill development of students upon completion of the study of sections of the curriculum and at the end of an academic term;
  7. annual grade – a grade awarded to students at the end of the academic year, incorporating the results of formative and summative assessments in a certain percentage ratio;
  8. electronic register of students' academic assessment results – a document recording the results of formative and summative assessments and automatically calculating term and annual grades;
  9. knowledge – the ability to reproduce or memorize specific facts, information and descriptions;
  10. understanding – the ability to comprehend and interpret the material studied through accurate reproduction, prediction or explanation of information;
  11. application – the ability to use the material studied under specific conditions and in new situations to solve problems. Ways of demonstrating the application of knowledge include practical work, experiments, project work, problem-solving and the creation of new and/or different products;
  12. analysis – the ability to divide informational material into its constituent parts and study information in order to draw various conclusions by identifying motives or causes, making inferences and finding evidence to substantiate general rules;
  13. synthesis – the ability to combine and integrate parts (ideas, elements) into a new context, for example, a message (presentation, report), action plan or diagrams that organize existing information. Achievement of the relevant expected learning outcomes involves creative activity;
  14. evaluation – the ability to assess the significance of a particular material (statements, works of art, research data);
  15. listening – the ability to understand the main content of oral statements on various topics, identify key information in them, recognize the speaker's opinion, determine the meaning of words from context, perceive and understand the content of various types of texts corresponding to the students' level, using different strategies;
  16. speaking – the ability to use words from formal and conversational speech styles in conversations on various topics, identify more complex questions in order to obtain the necessary information, express one's own opinion, respond to unexpected comments, communicate with peers while performing an assignment, correctly use specific vocabulary, and retell stories and events;
  17. reading – the ability to understand the main content of literary and scientific texts on various topics, identify key information using different information-search strategies, determine the meaning of words from context, recognize the author's attitude and opinion, and use various paper-based and digital sources to verify word meanings and understand what has been read;
  18. writing – the ability to plan, write, edit and proofread written assignments on various topics about real and fictional events, write critical reviews of what has been read, write competently without spelling and grammatical errors, adhere to a specific style, connect sentences into paragraphs, and use various linking words;
  19. portfolio – a method of recording, accumulating and assessing students' individual academic achievements over a certain period of study. A student's portfolio is intended to collect the results of formative and summative assessments as evidence of achievement of learning objectives. A portfolio is introduced for the purpose of increasing the objectivity and transparency of assessment and ensuring that students' results are accessible to interested parties.

Chapter 2. Criteria for Assessing Students' Academic Achievements in Non-Language and Language Subjects

Note. The title of Chapter 2 is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. The criteria for assessing students' academic achievements in non-language subjects are based on the assessment of the following levels of mastery of educational material:
  2. knowledge;
  3. understanding;
  4. application;
  5. analysis;
  6. synthesis;
  7. evaluation.
  8. The criteria for assessing students' academic achievements in language subjects are based on the assessment of the following levels of mastery:
  9. listening;
  10. speaking;
  11. reading;
  12. writing.

Chapter 3. Criteria for Assessing Students' Academic Achievements by Levels of Education

Note. The title of Chapter 3 is in the wording of Order No. 244 of the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 02.08.2023 No. 244 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).

  1. Criteria for assessing students' academic achievements at the primary education level:
  2. "Kazakh Language and Literature" for classes with Kazakh as the language of instruction, "Russian Language and Literature" for classes with Russian as the language of instruction, and "Native Language and Literature" for classes with Uzbek, Tajik and Uyghur as the languages of instruction:

listening and speaking:

the student understands and conveys the main content of a conversation, a text read or heard, determines how the speaker's point of view is presented, draws conclusions, understands the topic of a discussion and participates in its discussion while observing speech norms, consciously uses synonyms, antonyms, homonyms, words in their literal and figurative meanings in speech, uses various techniques for retelling the content of narrative and descriptive texts, using emotionally expressive means, applies various techniques for retelling the content of literary works, reflects on what has been read and heard, shares their thoughts and emotions, argues their point of view while maintaining logical consistency, independently produces coherent, logical and reasoned statements in accordance with the proposed topic and communicative purpose, participates in dialogue using various techniques of verbal communication, and analyzes ideas about the spiritual and moral values of the Kazakh and other peoples based on information read and heard;

reading:

the student reads works of oral folk art and children's literature, analyzes the characters of heroes and evaluates their actions, distinguishes literary texts from non-literary texts, determines the main idea and composition of literary works, determines the genre of a work and substantiates their answer/choice, identifies the figurative and expressive means used by the author to create an image, draws conclusions about the writer's attitude towards their characters, reads texts using specific types and strategies of reading, determines the types of texts (description, narration and reasoning), reads stories/poems expressively, recites poems expressively from memory, and identifies universal human values in works of fiction;

writing:

the student writes their own texts of various types, genres and styles, selecting appropriate words in a reasoned manner, writes in accordance with the studied grammatical, punctuation and spelling rules, writes texts using various forms of presentation (drawings, diagrams, graphs, tables), observes hygienic and calligraphic writing skills, synthesizes short texts on topics related to the culture and customs of their own and other peoples, expressing their moral position;

  1. "Kazakh Language" in classes with a non-Kazakh language of instruction, and "Russian Language" in classes with a non-Russian language of instruction:

listening:

the student understands the meaning of audiovisual material relevant to the social and everyday and socio-cultural spheres of communication, understands the topic, main idea, primary and secondary information of a text with sufficient completeness, depth and accuracy, understands how the style of speech changes depending on the communication situation, the place of communication and the participants in communication, and predicts the content of a story/narrative taking into account different opinions;

speaking:

the student conveys the content of stories and narratives, including by using preliminary notes and an outline, formulates questions and expresses their point of view regarding what has been read or heard, independently produces coherent and logical statements in accordance with the proposed topic and communicative purpose, participates in dialogue by expressing their communicative intention in various speech situations within the social and everyday and socio-cultural spheres of communication, and understands and explains the contribution of national culture to world heritage;

reading:

the student reads texts using different types and strategies of reading, understands key information, conclusions and the author's assessments in a text containing unfamiliar words, distinguishes literary and non-literary texts, finds the necessary information in various sources, demonstrates an understanding of the ideas, events and motives behind the actions of characters, clarifies the meanings of unfamiliar words and phrases using dictionaries and reference books, and identifies universal human values in works of Kazakh and world literature;

writing:

the student makes short notes on a listened-to text, information read and an event observed (headings, individual facts, opinions), summarizes information from a listened-to/read text according to a model, creates texts taking into account their stylistic affiliation, and uses appropriate lexical units to create narrative/non-narrative texts while observing spelling, grammatical and punctuation rules;

  1. "Foreign Language":

listening:

the student understands the main content of a short conversation on a familiar topic, recognizes the sounds of familiar words and phrases, understands short questions about colors and numbers, uses contextual clues to predict the content and meaning of a short conversation on a familiar topic, and understands the general meaning of short stories spoken slowly and clearly;

speaking:

the student formulates basic statements and utterances about themselves, formulates questions, answers questions, pronounces basic words and phrases with correct intonation and stress when describing objects and events, and expresses what they like and dislike;

reading:

the student uses an illustrated dictionary, reads and understands short literary and non-literary texts on social and everyday topics, identifies the main meaning of short texts, identifies specific information and details in short texts, and identifies universal human values in works of Kazakh and world literature;

writing:

the student correctly writes frequently used words, demonstrating knowledge of the differences between their spelling and pronunciation, writes short sentences from dictation, and correctly places punctuation marks at the ends of sentences;

  1. "Mathematics", "Information and Communication Technologies":

knows the meanings of the concepts: "digit", "number", "coordinate ray", "fraction of a number", "common fraction", "mixed number", "numerical expression", "literal expression", "equation", "inequality", "degree measure of an angle", "straight angle", "adjacent angle", "percentage", "set", "symmetry", "information", "object", "file", "folder", "shortcut", "model", "computer network", "Internet", the place values of digits in the decimal number system, plane and three-dimensional geometric figures and their elements, formulas for calculating the perimeter and area of a square and rectangle, rules for adding and subtracting fractions with equal denominators, the purpose of operating system objects, types of information representation and units of information measurement, the main parts of a computer, input and output devices, the purpose of application and utility programs and the operating system, and computer safety rules;

understands the meaning and order of arithmetic operations on natural numbers and quantities and the relationships between them, simple dependencies between quantities, the meaning of the operations "intersection" and "union" of sets, the conversion of percentages into fractions and fractions into percentages, the difference between constant and variable quantities, the purpose of the main parts of a computer, input and output devices, elements of the operating system interface, the impact of computer technology on human health, the importance of protecting information and devices from malicious programs, and the need to accompany information with references to authors;

applies mathematical symbols, arithmetic operations and their properties to write expressions and transform numerical expressions and to solve problems, mental and written calculation techniques for operations with natural numbers, standard and non-standard units of measurement of quantities (length, area, volume, mass, time), instruments for measuring quantities, mathematical language and graphical models for recording problem conditions, algorithms for solving equations and inequalities, formulas for calculating the perimeter and area (of a square, rectangle and right triangle), Venn diagrams for representing relationships between sets of elements, the ability to find a fraction of a number and a number from its fraction, information and communication technology tools for collecting, storing, processing and transmitting information, application programs for working with various types of information and for creating models, Internet services for solving assigned tasks, and computer operating rules;

analyzes rational methods of mental and written calculation, the characteristics of geometric figures, the results of comparing the values of numerical expressions and expressions with variables, dependencies between various quantities (quantity, cost, speed, time, distance, labor productivity, duration of work, amount of work), patterns for finding missing elements in sequences, simple combinatorial and logical problems, records of problem conditions in the form of diagrams, drawings and tables, data and results related to counting and measurement, the capabilities of application programs, the consequences of violating ethical and legal standards on the Internet, and information from various sources selected in accordance with the stated requirements;

synthesizes the classification of objects according to their characteristics and spatial arrangement, a mathematical model of dependencies between quantities, simple models of real-world objects and processes in the form of images and drawings, a problem and its inverse problem based on the proposed data or mathematical model, a sequence according to a given pattern, models of objects and situations for solving practical problems using information and communication technologies, and knowledge about the capabilities of application programs and network services for solving various tasks;

evaluates measurement results, the truth or falsity of simple statements about numbers, quantities and geometric figures, data presented in the form of a graph, table or diagram, the compliance of a model with specified criteria, and the possibilities of using application programs and network services to solve problems;

  1. "Natural Science":

knows the planets of the Solar System and their characteristics, basic natural science concepts about the Earth and its nature and the Universe, methods of scientific inquiry: observation, experiment and practical trial, the basics of safety precautions when planning and conducting research, rules of conduct during natural disasters, the life cycle of humans, plants, animals and fungi, the structural features and location of the main organs of humans, plants, animals and fungi and their functions, the classification of plants, animals and fungi, the basics of the photosynthesis process, certain properties of light, some physical forces and the causes of their occurrence, certain types of energy, the composition and properties of the most common substances on Earth, the properties of various bodies and some areas of their application, the main types of mineral resources and their significance, and the main mineral deposits in the Republic of Kazakhstan;

understands the meaning of the concepts of macro- and microworld, the importance of caring for the environment and preserving biodiversity on Earth, the need to observe personal hygiene, the protective functions of the body, the importance of natural components for living organisms, the characteristics of organisms as means of adaptation to the environment, simple differences between vertebrate and invertebrate animals, and the need for the rational use of natural resources;

applies certain research methods to study natural objects, processes and phenomena, standard and non-standard units of measurement of natural objects, phenomena and processes, simple instruments for measuring certain characteristics of natural objects, processes and phenomena, appropriate scientific terminology to explain the research conducted, and knowledge of simple characteristics of plant and animal species in their locality to compile their classification;

analyzes cause-and-effect relationships between components of nature, the properties of materials to determine their possible applications, the animal and plant life of a particular territory, similarities and differences between different habitats, data from their own research and materials from various sources;

synthesizes the knowledge and skills acquired for planning and conducting research on objects and phenomena of living and non-living nature, information materials in the form of drawings, diagrams, graphs, charts and tables, ideas concerning environmental protection, and simulation and graphic models of objects, phenomena and processes of the micro- and macroworld;

evaluates factors influencing the development and condition of natural objects, phenomena and processes, human activity and the consequences of scientific and technological progress for the state of the environment, the impact of scientific and technological progress on human life, and the extent to which the results of their own research correspond to the forecast made;

  1. "Knowledge of the World":

knows the structure, composition and functions of the family and school community in which the student's everyday life takes place, the main social functions of a person, basic information about the relationship between "individual – society", the concepts of "safety" and "health" and their main characteristics, the characteristics of individuals, families, communities and society as a whole, their significance and role in human life, the main types of household items, their composition, properties and sources, general information about the geography and history of Kazakhstan, the main traditions and folklore of the Kazakh people and the peoples of Kazakhstan, the role and place of Kazakhstan in the world, the state symbols of Kazakhstan, universal human values, rules of positive and friendly communication, etiquette rules, the rights and responsibilities of a school student, and the rules of a healthy lifestyle;

understands the causal determination of a person's external characteristics, their civic identity in the form of awareness of themselves as a young citizen of Kazakhstan and their belonging to a particular ethnic group, the value of family, their small homeland and the Fatherland, the values of Kazakhstan's multi-ethnic society, the significance of the state symbols of Kazakhstan, the standards of moral behavior of a person in society, their involvement in the life of their school, village, city and country, the importance of serving society, the functional and structural characteristics of different types of settlements, the importance of consistency between thoughts, words and actions and responsibility for them, the significance of national traditions and customs, the role of travel in people's lives and in the development of society, the importance of human self-knowledge and self-development, the content of the concepts of "labor", "mutual understanding", "cheerfulness", "optimism", "benevolence", "generosity", "magnanimity", "patriotism", "creativity" and their significance, the need to lead a healthy lifestyle, the importance of nature as a source of life, and the importance of caring for nature;

applies methods of cognition to study social processes and phenomena, complete educational assignments and perform creative, cognitive, research and design work, personal experience and knowledge in the field of travel, simple financial relationships, knowledge about a healthy lifestyle, personal hygiene, nutrition and daily routine, basic knowledge of providing first aid before medical assistance arrives, personal and public experience in adapting to the surrounding world, etiquette rules, and communication rules for maintaining positive and friendly relationships within the family and team;

analyzes Kazakhstan's position in the world, the role and significance of the social phenomena and processes being studied in people's lives, similarities and differences in the cultural and ceremonial traditions of the Kazakh people and other peoples, factors influencing the development of individuals, families and school communities, the importance of basic resources in human life, factors affecting health and safety, manifestations of human feelings and people's actions, their causes and consequences, and their own emotional state;

synthesizes knowledge and skills for systematizing and classifying social phenomena and processes, knowledge and skills for identifying certain current problems in society, their own solutions for orientation in space (place), time (chronology) and the social environment (society), communication models in family, interpersonal and public spheres, their own projects on life safety and the organization of travel, and solutions for their own spiritual and moral development;

evaluates their own behavior and the actions of people around them from the standpoint of moral standards, the importance of family, society and country in the life of every person, the role of traditions and folklore in modern life, the value of consumer goods according to their degree of importance and cost, the degree of satisfaction with their work in class, the level of their progress in the field of interpersonal, social and financial-economic relationships, their own emotional and physical condition, and people's behavior from the standpoint of generally accepted moral standards.

 For personnel training areas in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs” – the implementation of academic supervision of master's students by an academic and teaching staff member whose primary place of employment is a Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI), who holds an academic degree and (or) an (academic) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field, or a military (special) rank not lower than Lieutenant Colonel, or a class rank not lower than Justice Adviser or Judge, or a retired Judge, with at least 3 (three) years of academic and teaching experience during the last 10 (ten) years in the relevant personnel training area, who is the author of at least 5 (five) scientific articles over the last 5 (five) years in publications included in the List of Publications, and who is the author of a textbook or teaching manual in the relevant personnel training area.

For the personnel training area “Information and Communication Technologies” – supervision of students’ research work (projects) by teachers of the relevant profile who are the authors of at least 5 (five) scientific articles over the last 5 (five) years in publications included in the List of Publications, and (or) by specialists having at least 5 (five) years of practical work experience during the last 10 (ten) years;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the academic supervisors carrying out academic supervision in the relevant personnel training area, indicating their education, work experience, scientific publications, and the textbook or teaching manual prepared (in the form prescribed in Appendix 11 to these Criteria);

4) availability of places for students to undertake practical training in accordance with the educational programme and to undergo scientific internships in the relevant personnel training areas, except for Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs”;

copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) with organizations designated as practical training bases for undertaking scientific internships in the relevant personnel training areas shall be submitted; copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) for undertaking practical training at Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) – copies of supporting documents. Contracts (agreements) for practical training and scientific internships must be valid at the time of study. Where contracts (agreements) concluded exclusively in foreign languages are submitted, they must be accompanied by a notarized translation into the state or Russian language.

17. Specialized qualification requirements imposed on the educational activities of a Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI) for the implementation of postgraduate educational programmes awarding the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) and Doctor in the field:

1) availability of teachers in accordance with the disciplines of the educational programme;

compliance of the teachers’ education and their academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field and (or) academic title, issued/recognized by the authorized body in the field of science and higher education, with the profile of the disciplines taught;

the proportion of teachers in the personnel training area whose primary place of employment is the Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI), holding an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field and (or) an academic title issued/recognized by the authorized body in the field of science and higher education (for HMEIs implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs” – or holding a military (special) rank not lower than Lieutenant Colonel, or a class rank not lower than Justice Adviser or Judge, or being a retired Judge, with at least 3 (three) years of teaching experience during the last 10 (ten) years) in the relevant personnel training area, out of the total number of teachers in the personnel training area – at least 80%;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the staffing of educational programmes in the personnel training area with teaching staff (in the form prescribed in Appendix 7 to these Criteria).

The qualification requirements regarding the compliance of teachers’ education with the profile of the social sciences and humanities disciplines taught shall not apply to Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs”;

2) availability of at least 3 (three) teachers whose primary place of employment is the Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI), who hold an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field in the relevant personnel training area, and who are the authors of at least 3 (three) articles and (or) reviews in peer-reviewed international scientific journals over the last 5 (five) years:

for personnel training areas 8D06 “Information and Communication Technologies”, 8D11 “Services” – in publications included in the first 3 (three) quartiles according to the Journal Citation Reports (JCR) of Clarivate or having a CiteScore percentile of at least 50 (fifty) in the Scopus database in one of the scientific subject areas corresponding to the educational programme;

for all other personnel training areas – in publications included in the first 3 (three) quartiles according to the Journal Citation Reports (JCR) of Clarivate or having a CiteScore percentile of at least 35 (thirty-five) in the Scopus database in one of the scientific subject areas corresponding to the educational programme.

At least two (out of the three specified) teachers whose primary place of employment is the Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI) must have supervised persons who obtained an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field and (or) a master's degree; and must be corresponding authors or first (principal) authors of an article and/or review in a publication meeting the requirements of the preceding subparagraph, depending on the personnel training area, and (or) must be managers and (or) implementers of successfully completed scientific projects and programmes financed from the state budget and (or) international projects over the last 3 (three) years;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the staffing of educational programmes in the personnel training area with teaching staff (in the form prescribed in Appendix 7 to these Criteria).

The qualification requirements shall not apply to Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs”;

3) academic supervision by a teacher holding an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field, who is the author of:

for personnel training area 8D06 “Information and Communication Technologies” – at least 2 (two) articles in international peer-reviewed scientific journals included in the 1st, 2nd or 3rd quartile according to JCR (Journal Citation Reports) in the Web of Science Core Collection or having a CiteScore percentile of at least 35 (thirty-five), or having an h-index of 2 (two) or higher;

for all other personnel training areas: being the author of at least 5 (five) scientific articles published over the last 5 (five) years in publications relevant to the profile and included in the List of Scientific Publications, and 1 (one) scientific article in an international peer-reviewed scientific journal having an impact factor according to JCR (Journal Citation Reports) or indexed in one of the following databases: Science Citation Index Expanded, Social Science Citation Index or Arts and Humanities Citation Index in the Web of Science Core Collection, or having a CiteScore percentile of at least 35 (thirty-five).

For personnel training areas in the field of “8D12 – National Security and Military Affairs”, academic supervision shall be carried out by an academic and teaching staff member holding an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field, with at least 3 (three) years of academic and teaching experience during the last 10 (ten) years in the relevant personnel training area, who is the author of at least 7 (seven) scientific articles in the relevant personnel training area, published over the last 5 (five) years in publications included in the List of Publications, as well as the author of a textbook or teaching manual in the relevant personnel training area.

The information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the academic supervisors carrying out academic supervision in the relevant area, indicating their work experience, scientific publications, and the textbook or teaching manual prepared (in the form prescribed in Appendix 11 to these Criteria);

4) availability of cooperation contracts (agreements), in accordance with civil legislation, with foreign educational and (or) scientific organizations implementing postgraduate educational programmes in the relevant personnel training area, for the engagement of foreign consultants and implementation of joint scientific projects;

copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) on academic exchange with foreign Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs), including those concerning the engagement of foreign consultants and implementation of joint scientific projects; copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) on cooperation with scientific organizations for the implementation of joint scientific projects shall be submitted; the existence of valid contracts (agreements) at the time of study shall be confirmed.

The qualification requirements shall not apply to Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs”;

5) availability, in accordance with civil legislation, of contracts (agreements) on doctoral students’ practical training concluded with domestic organizations, and contracts (agreements) on foreign scientific internships in the relevant personnel training area;

copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) for undertaking scientific internships in the relevant personnel training areas shall be submitted; copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) with organizations designated as practical training bases shall also be submitted;

contracts (agreements) for practical training and scientific internships must be valid at the time of study and contain a clause on the extension of the contract.

The qualification requirements shall not apply to Higher Military Educational Institutions (HMEIs) implementing personnel training in the field of “National Security and Military Affairs”;

6) availability of accredited laboratories or provision of access to accredited laboratories on the basis of contracts (agreements) in the personnel training area in the field of “Information and Communication Technologies”;

copies of laboratory accreditation certificates or copies of contracts (agreements) (at least two) with accredited laboratories shall be submitted. Contracts (agreements) must be valid at the time of study and contain a clause on the extension of the contract.

18. Qualification requirements imposed on the educational activities of a Higher Military Educational Institution (HMEI) for the implementation of educational programmes in the form of online learning, except for personnel training areas approved by the Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated October 2, 2018 No. 530 “On Approval of the List of Personnel Training Areas in Higher and Postgraduate Education for Which Education in the Form of External Studies and Online Learning Is Not Permitted” (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 17513):

1) availability of broadband Internet access with a network bandwidth of at least 500 (five hundred) megabits per second, including wireless technologies. Ensuring information security of systems and data protection;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the availability of broadband Internet, wireless technologies and the educational organization's information security policy (in the form prescribed in Appendix 8 to these Criteria);

2) availability of the institution's own information technology infrastructure, an educational management information system (information and educational portal, website, automated system for ensuring the credit-based learning technology, information security and data protection systems), and other information and educational resources and conditions for organizing the educational process as provided for by the Order of the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 20, 2015 No. 137 “On Approval of Requirements for Educational Organizations Regarding the Provision of Distance Learning and the Rules for Organizing the Educational Process through Distance Learning and Online Learning in Higher and (or) Postgraduate Educational Programmes” (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 10768);

provision of conditions for supporting students in a 24/7 format, with minimum server specifications calculated for 1,000 concurrent users (at least 24 processing cores, 60 gigabytes of random access memory (RAM), and 1.5 terabytes of disk space). Availability in the HMEI's learning management system of digital content and digital platforms with synchronous (video conferencing software capable of simultaneously connecting 200 (two hundred) users) and asynchronous learning functions, as well as an online proctoring system;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the availability of fixed assets, technological equipment, a link and test access (in the form prescribed in Appendix 8 to these Criteria);

3) availability of a library collection of educational, teaching-methodological and scientific literature in electronic publication format, covering 100% of the disciplines of educational programmes in the languages of instruction;

ensuring annual renewal of at least 3% of the educational literature collection broken down by disciplines of educational programmes;

availability of agreements with libraries and scientific organizations on the joint use of library collections (access to an electronic database or information resources);

ensuring access for students and academic and teaching staff to electronic information resources and databases;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the availability of a collection of educational and scientific literature on digital media (in the form prescribed in Appendix 3 to these Criteria);

4) compliance of the educational programme entered into the Register of Educational Programmes of the authorized body in the field of science and higher education, developed in accordance with Order No. 2;

availability of massive open online course programmes (with a map of learning outcomes to be developed, reflecting the specification of the knowledge assessment system with a description of assessment indicators and criteria), constituting at least 10% of the total number of disciplines of the educational programme, posted on the official platform of the HMEI, as well as subscriptions to international educational platforms;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching a copy of the educational programme entered into the Register of Educational Programmes of the authorized body in the field of science and higher education in the relevant personnel training area, developed for the full period of study in accordance with Order No. 2, in the state language and the language(s) of instruction.

A link and test access to the massive open online course and the subscription to international educational platforms on the official platform of the HMEI shall be provided;

5) availability of an anti-plagiarism system integrated into the learning management system;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching a copy of a document concerning the availability of computer software for checking the presence of borrowed material and the use of text with words and expressions replaced by synonyms without changing the meaning (paraphrasing), including the use of text translated from another language;

6) integration of the HMEI's learning management system with the Unified Higher Education Platform (UHEP);

the information shall be confirmed by attaching a copy of a document concerning the integration of the HMEI's management system with the UHEP (in the form prescribed in Appendix 8 to these Criteria);

7) availability of at least 80% of teachers whose primary place of employment is the HMEI and who have undergone professional development in the field of IT competencies and online learning methodology in the relevant personnel training area over the last 3 (three) years, in an amount of at least 72 (seventy-two) hours per training course; for teachers with basic IT education – completion of courses in online learning methodology over the last 3 (three) years, amounting to at least 36 (thirty-six) hours per training course;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the staffing of educational programmes in the personnel training area with teaching staff (in the form prescribed in Appendix 7 to these Criteria), and concerning the professional development of teachers in accordance with the profile of the disciplines taught (in the form prescribed in Appendix 9 to these Criteria);

documents confirming completion of the professional development course shall be submitted, including: a certificate indicating the course topic, the number of hours completed, the course period, and the participant's report following completion of the course;

8) availability of teachers in accordance with the disciplines of the educational programme, and compliance of their educational profile and academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field and (or) academic title, issued/recognized by the authorized body in the field of science and higher education, with the profile of the disciplines taught;

the proportion of teachers in accordance with the disciplines of the educational programme whose primary place of employment is the HMEI, out of the total number of teachers in the educational programme – at least 80%;

the information shall be confirmed by attaching copies of documents concerning the staffing of educational programmes in the personnel training area with teaching staff (in the form prescribed in Appendix 7 to these Criteria);

9) the proportion of teachers in the personnel training area whose primary place of employment is the HMEI and who hold an academic degree and (or) degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)/Doctor in the field and (or) an academic title issued/recognized by the authorized body in the field of science and higher education, out of the total number of teachers in the educational programme of the personnel training area – at least 70%;

information on staffing of educational programmes in the personnel training area with teaching staff (in the form prescribed in Appendix 7 to these Criteria).

19. Requirements for the maximum volume of students' academic workload:

1) compliance with and observance of the requirements for the maximum volume of students' academic workload established by the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES);

2) observance of the academic period in accordance with the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES);

3) completion of academic credits in accordance with the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES);

4) availability of an individual work plan and its compliance with the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES).

20. Requirements for the level of student preparation:

1) compliance with the requirements for the level of student preparation, determined on the basis of the Dublin Descriptors for the respective levels of higher and postgraduate education and reflecting the acquired competencies expressed in achieved learning outcomes;

2) assessment of learning outcomes to determine the achievement by final-year students of the expected learning outcomes and mastery of the competencies provided for by the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES), except for doctoral studies (copies of assessment records concerning the quality of students' knowledge, abilities and skills shall be attached).

21. Requirements for the duration of study: compliance with the periods for completion of the main volumes of academic credits in accordance with the requirements of the State Compulsory Education Standards (SCES).

| | Appendix 1 to the Criteria for Assessing Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and (or) Postgraduate Educational Programmes || - | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- || | Form |

Information on the student population by languages of instruction for the academic year (in the denominator, indicate students studying in the state language)

Download

TotalBachelor's degree programmeMaster's degree programmeDoctoral programme  
123456
No.Name and code of the personnel training areaStudent population   

Head of the educational organization _______________________________(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

| | Form || | Form || | Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Assessing Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and (or) Postgraduate Educational Programmes || | Form |

Results of testing of final-year students

Download

12345678910
No.Year of study, personnel training areaNumber of students on the listActual number of students presentNumber of grades “5” (A, A+)Number of grades “4” (B+, B, B-, C+)Number of grades “3” (C, C-, D+, D)Number of grades “2” (F)Average scorePercentage of positive grades

Head of the educational organization _______________________________(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

| | Appendix 3 to the Criteria for Assessing Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and (or) Postgraduate Educational Programmes || - | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- || | Form |

Information on the availability of a collection of educational, teaching-methodological and scientific literature _______________________________ (name of educational organization) (as of _______________)

 

 

 

   Download

English translation of the entire text, preserving the original structure, tables, numbering, notes, headings and hyperlinks.

The text is quite extensive, so I will preserve the original wording and formatting as closely as possible.

Appendices 4–11

Download

In printed format (title, authors, language of publication)In electronic publications (title, authors, language of publication)In printed format (title, authors, language of publication)In electronic publications (title, authors, language of publication)In printed format (title, authors, language of publication)In electronic publications (title, authors, language of publication)      
123456789   
No.Disciplines of educational programmes in the field of personnel trainingEducational literatureEducational and methodological literatureScientific literatureInformation on the annual updating of the educational literature collection, as well as the year of acquisition of the literature      

 

 Appendix 4 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on the availability of medical services, including the availability of a medical unit and a licence to carry out medical activities

____________________________ (name of educational institution) (as of __________)

Download

1234
Actual address of the building occupied for the educational processInformation on the licence for medical activities (number)Information on the equipment of medical unitsInformation on medical personnel
    

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 5 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on the availability of a catering facility and a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion of the authorised body in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population concerning the catering facility

____________________________ (name of educational institution) (as of __________)

Download

1234
Actual address of the building occupied for the educational processName of the catering facility (canteen, buffet, café)Availability of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion confirming the compliance of the catering facility with the requirements of regulatory legal acts in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population (date and number)Notes (if the catering facility is leased, indicate the availability of a sanitary and epidemiological conclusion confirming the compliance of the catering facility with the requirements of regulatory legal acts in the field of sanitary and epidemiological welfare of the population, as well as information about the tenants)
    

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 6 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on the usable educational area and the availability of material and technical resources

____________________________ (name of educational institution) (as of __________)

Download

12345678
Actual address of buildings (academic buildings) occupied for the educational processInformation on documents for buildings (academic buildings) owned under the right of ownership, economic management or operational management, or trust managementInformation on premises used for the educational process (classrooms, offices, premises for practical classes in specific fields, assembly halls and sports halls), floor area (square metres)Information on educational and scientific laboratories, specialised classrooms, training grounds, shooting ranges, floor area (square metres)Information on conditions for students with special educational needs and specialised inclusive education classrooms (equipped with teaching aids, educational literature and adapted software), floor area (square metres)Information on social, domestic and other premises (security checkpoints, sanitary facilities (toilets, washbasins)), floor area (square metres)Information on video surveillance in premises and/or adjacent territories, quantity and technical specificationsInformation on the provision of accommodation for students in need, floor area (square metres), details of the conclusion confirming compliance with Sanitary Rules
        

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 7 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on staffing levels of teaching personnel for educational programmes in the field of personnel training

____________________________ (name of educational institution) (as of __________)

Download

12345678910
No.Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)Year and place of birthInformation on higher education, speciality, qualification according to diploma, place of study and year of graduation (name of educational institution, period of study), internship period (specialist certificate)Main place of employment (organisation address, position, length of service)Information on practical work in the field of the disciplines taught, length of serviceInformation on the absence (presence) of a criminal recordInformation on completion of a medical examination (availability of a personal medical record book)Information on the Master's degree (speciality, year awarded, field of study)Information on an academic degree: Candidate of Sciences, Doctor of Sciences, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), or Doctor by Profile, speciality and year awarded
          

Continuation of the table

Download

111213141516
Information on the academic title of Associate Professor (Docent) or Professor, speciality and year awardedInformation on a military (special) rank not lower than Lieutenant Colonel, class rank not lower than Justice Adviser or judge, or retired judgeInformation on honorary titles and state awards of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the sports title of Honoured Coach, or the highest and first medical qualification categories, year awarded*Information on the availability of teaching skills in inclusive education (courses (at least 72 hours), internships (certificate number and date))Information on the certificate of recognition of an education document issued by a foreign educational institutionDiscipline taught
      
  • Does not apply to military and special higher educational institutions implementing personnel training in the field of "National Security and Military Affairs".

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 8 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on the material and technical support of the educational process, including the availability of computers, laboratory equipment, technical teaching aids, software and information systems

Download

123456789
Classrooms and subject-specific rooms equipped with technical teaching aidsEducational and production premises, sites and training facilities equipped with teaching aidsList of laboratory equipment indicating its type and name, including virtual laboratories, augmented reality and interactive simulatorsList of technical teaching aids, indicating their typeList of inventory and equipment of the assembly hall, sports hall and libraryComputer classrooms, computers and specialised licensed softwareEducational management information system with up-to-date databases, information on the integration of the higher and postgraduate education management system with the Unified Higher Education Platform (UHEP), third-level domain name in the edu.kz zone. Information on Internet speedInformation on the availability of equipment for online learning and information on online learning 
Actual address of the building (academic buildings), indicating the total and usable floor area (square metres)Information on equipment       

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 9 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on advanced training of teaching personnel in accordance with the profile of the disciplines taught, as well as in management for heads of educational institutions

Download

1234567
No.Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)Name of the training topicPlace and period of trainingName of the organisation where the training was completedNumber of hoursInformation on documents confirming completion of training (certificate, report)

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

 

 Appendix 10 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on the availability of a specialised scientific and technical/scientific and methodological/experimental facility*

Download

1234
Availability of a specialised scientific laboratory, research institute, scientific centre or technoparkLocation addressInformation on usage rights (owned or under an agreement)Information on the intended purpose of the specialised facility, its equipment and areas of activity
    

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

Note: Information shall be provided separately for each field of personnel training.

 

 Appendix 11 to the Assessment Criteria for Military and Special Educational Institutions Implementing Higher and/or Postgraduate Education Programmes
 Form

Information on research supervisors providing scientific guidance in the field of personnel training, indicating their length of service, scientific publications and the textbook or teaching aid prepared

Download

123456789
 In the List of Scientific Publications Recommended by the Authorised Body in the Field of Science and Higher EducationIn International Peer-Reviewed Scientific JournalsIn the Proceedings of International Conferences in the Relevant Field of Personnel Training*     
No.Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)Information on education (qualification according to diploma, year of graduation)Information on work experience (research and teaching, clinical), as well as practical work experience in the relevant field of personnel training, length of serviceInformation on the availability of an academic degree / degree of Candidate of Sciences, Doctor of Sciences, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), or Doctor by ProfileInformation on scientific publicationsTitle of the textbook or teaching aid prepared*  
         

Head of the educational institution ______________________________

(Last name, first name, patronymic (if any)) (signature)

*Note: For military and special higher educational institutions implementing personnel training in the field of "National Security and Military Affairs".

 

Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Legal Services Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defence Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Programme Charter Statute Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages