On Approval of Risk Assessment Criteria and the Inspection Checklist in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities, Branches and Representative Offices That Are Commercial Organizations
Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2019 No. 350 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 9, 2019 No. 61. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on July 9, 2019 under No. 18998.
In accordance with paragraph 5 of Article 141 and paragraph 1 of Article 143 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, WE HEREBY ORDER:
To approve:
1) the risk assessment criteria in the field of registration of legal entities, branches and representative offices that are commercial organizations, in accordance with Appendix 1 to this Joint Order;
2) the inspection checklist in the field of registration of legal entities, branches and representative offices that are commercial organizations, in accordance with Appendix 2 to this Joint Order.
2. The Department of Registration Services and Organization of Legal Services of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall, in accordance with the procedure established by law, ensure:
1) state registration of this Joint Order;
2) within ten calendar days from the date of state registration of this Joint Order, its submission in Kazakh and Russian to the Republican State Enterprise on the Right of Economic Management "Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan" of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan for official publication and inclusion in the Reference Control Bank of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
3) publication of this Joint Order on the official website of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
3. Control over the implementation of this Joint Order shall be assigned to the Deputy Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan responsible for the relevant area.
4. This Joint Order shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication.
Minister of Justiceof the Republic of Kazakhstan M. Beketayev
Minister of National Economyof the Republic of Kazakhstan R. Dalenov
"AGREED"
Committee on Legal Statisticsand Special Recordsof the General Prosecutor's Officeof the Republic of Kazakhstan
Appendix 1to the Joint Order of theMinister of Justiceof the Republic of Kazakhstandated July 5, 2019 No. 350and the Minister of National Economyof the Republic of Kazakhstandated July 9, 2019 No. 61
Risk Assessment Criteria in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities, Branches and Representative Offices That Are Commercial Organizations
Note. Appendix 1 is set out in the wording of the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 15, 2023 No. 661 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 18, 2023 No. 163 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication).
Chapter 1. General Provisions
1. These Risk Assessment Criteria in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities, Branches and Representative Offices That Are Commercial Organizations (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with paragraphs 5 and 6 of Article 141 of the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On State Registration of Legal Entities and Record Registration of Branches and Representative Offices", the Rules for the Formation by Regulatory State Bodies of a Risk Assessment and Management System, approved by Order No. 48 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 22, 2022 (registered in the State Registration Register of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 28577), and the forms of inspection checklists approved by Order No. 3 of the Acting Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 31, 2018 (registered in the State Registration Register of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 17371).
2. The following concepts are used in these Criteria:
1) score – a quantitative measure of risk calculation;
2) data normalization – a statistical procedure involving the conversion of values measured on different scales to a conditionally common scale;
3) risk – the probability of harm being caused as a result of the activities of a controlled entity to human life or health, the legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, or the property interests of the state, taking into account the severity of its consequences;
4) risk assessment and management system – a process of making managerial decisions aimed at reducing the probability of adverse factors occurring by classifying controlled entities (objects) according to risk levels for the subsequent implementation of preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects), with the aim of restricting entrepreneurial freedom to the minimum possible extent while ensuring an acceptable level of risk in the relevant fields of activity, as well as aimed at changing the risk level for a specific controlled entity (object) and/or exempting such controlled entity (object) from preventive control with visits to the controlled entity (object);
5) objective risk assessment criteria (hereinafter referred to as objective criteria) – risk assessment criteria used to select controlled entities (objects) depending on their risk level in a particular field of activity and not directly dependent on an individual controlled entity (object);
6) risk assessment criteria – a set of quantitative and qualitative indicators related to the direct activities of a controlled entity, the specific features of sectoral development and the factors influencing such development, which make it possible to classify controlled entities (objects) into different risk levels;
7) subjective risk assessment criteria (hereinafter referred to as subjective criteria) – risk assessment criteria used to select controlled entities (objects) depending on the results of the activities of a specific controlled entity (object);
8) inspection checklist – a list of requirements imposed on the activities of controlled entities (objects), non-compliance with which poses a threat to human life and health, the environment, and the legitimate interests of individuals, legal entities and the state;
9) sample population (sample) – a list of assessed entities (objects) classified as a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) in a specific area of state control, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 143 of the Code.
3. Risk assessment criteria and inspection checklists applied for conducting preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects) shall be approved by a joint act of the regulatory state bodies and the authorized body for entrepreneurship and shall be published on the websites of the regulatory state bodies in accordance with paragraph 5 of Article 141 of the Code.
Chapter 2. Procedure for Forming the Risk Assessment and Management System When Conducting Preventive Control of Controlled Entities (Objects)
4. For the purposes of risk management when conducting preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects), risk assessment criteria for conducting preventive control of controlled entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria, which shall be carried out in stages (Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis).
With respect to controlled entities (objects) classified as having a medium risk level according to objective criteria, preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects) and unscheduled inspections shall be conducted.
5. Depending on the potential risk and significance of the issue, the isolated or systematic nature of the violation, and the analysis of decisions previously made for each source of information, the requirements imposed on the activities of controlled entities (objects) shall correspond to the degree of violation – gross, significant and minor.
The degree of violation (gross, significant, minor) shall be assigned in accordance with the established definitions of gross, significant and minor violations under the subjective criteria.
6. Risk assessment criteria for conducting preventive control of controlled entities (objects) shall be formed by determining objective and subjective criteria.
Paragraph 1. Objective Criteria
7. The determination of objective criteria shall be carried out by identifying risks.
8. Under the objective criteria, branches of the Non-Profit Joint-Stock Company "State Corporation "Government for Citizens" in the field of registration of legal entities, branches and representative offices that are commercial organizations shall be classified as having a medium risk level.
Paragraph 2. Subjective Criteria
9. The determination of subjective criteria shall be carried out using the following stages:
1) formation of a database and collection of information;
2) analysis of information and risk assessment.
10. The formation of a database and collection of information are necessary to identify controlled entities (objects) that violate the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the field of registration of legal entities, branches and representative offices that are commercial organizations.
11. The following sources of information shall be used to assess the degree of risk according to subjective criteria for conducting preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects):
1) results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the controlled entity, including through the digital system "National Register of Business Identification Numbers" (hereinafter referred to as the Digital System of the National Register of BINs).
Note. Paragraph 11 is set out in the wording of the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 17, 2026 No. 796 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 137 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its official publication).
12. On the basis of the available sources of information, the authorized body in the field of registration of legal entities shall compile data on subjective criteria, which shall be subject to analysis and assessment in accordance with Appendix 1 to these Criteria.
13. Analysis and assessment of subjective criteria make it possible to focus preventive control of a controlled entity (object) on the controlled entity (object) with the highest potential risk.
During the analysis and assessment, data from subjective criteria that have previously been taken into account and used in relation to a specific controlled entity (object), as well as data for which the limitation period established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan has expired, shall not be applied.
Controlled entities that have fully remedied the violations identified following the previous preventive control with a visit shall not be included in the lists when forming the lists for the next period of state control.
14. Based on the priority of the information sources used and the significance of the subjective criteria indicators, the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 in accordance with the procedure for calculating the overall risk level indicator according to subjective criteria established in Chapter 3 of these Criteria.
The priority of the information sources used and the significance of the subjective criteria indicators shall be established in accordance with the list of subjective criteria for determining the risk level according to subjective criteria in respect of branches of the Non-Profit Joint-Stock Company "State Corporation "Government for Citizens", as set out in Appendix 1 to these Criteria.
Paragraph 3. Specific Features of Forming the Risk Assessment and Management System
15. The risk assessment and management system shall be maintained using the Digital System of the National Register of BINs and other digital systems that classify controlled entities (objects) according to specific risk levels and generate lists for conducting control measures, and shall also be based on state statistics, the results of departmental statistical monitoring, and information tools.
Note. Paragraph 15 is set out in the wording of the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 17, 2026 No. 796 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 137 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its official publication).
16. The calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria, as well as the risk level indicators in accordance with which a controlled entity is classified as having a high, medium or low risk level, shall be established in the risk assessment criteria in accordance with the list of subjective criteria for determining the risk level according to subjective criteria, pursuant to paragraph 14 of these Criteria.
Chapter 3. Procedure for Calculating the Risk Level According to Subjective Criteria
17. The following procedure for calculating the risk level indicator shall be applied for classifying a controlled entity according to its risk level in accordance with paragraph 4 of these Criteria.
The authorized body in the field of registration of legal entities, branches and representative offices that are commercial organizations
shall collect information and form a database of subjective criteria from the sources specified in paragraphs 11 or 12 of these Criteria, depending on whether preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects) is being conducted.
The calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria (R) shall be performed automatically by summing the risk level indicator for violations based on the results of previous inspections and preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects) (SP) and the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 14 of these Criteria (SC), followed by normalization of the data values to a range from 0 to 100 points.
Rпром = SP + SC, where
Rпром – intermediate risk level indicator according to subjective criteria,
SP – risk level indicator for violations,
SC – risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 15 of these Criteria.
The calculation shall be performed for each controlled entity (object) within a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) in each area of state control. In this case, the list of assessed controlled entities (objects) classified as a homogeneous group of controlled entities (objects) within one area of state control shall constitute a sample population (sample) for subsequent data normalization.
18. Based on the data obtained from the results of previous inspections and preventive control with visits to controlled entities (objects), a risk level indicator for violations shall be formed and assessed on a scale from 0 to 100 points.
19. If one gross violation is identified based on any of the sources of information specified in paragraph 12 of these Criteria, the controlled entity shall be assigned a risk level indicator of 100 points, and preventive control with a visit to the controlled entity (object) shall be conducted in respect of it.
If no gross violations are identified, the risk level indicator for violations shall be calculated as the total indicator for significant and minor violations.
When determining the indicator for significant violations, a coefficient of 0.7 shall be applied.
This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:
SPз = (SP2 × 100/SP1) × 0.7, where:
SPз – indicator of significant violations;
SP1 – required number of significant violations;
SP2 – number of significant violations identified.
When determining the indicator for minor violations, a coefficient of 0.3 shall be applied.
This indicator shall be calculated using the following formula:
SPн = (SP2 × 100/SP1) × 0.3, where:
SPн – indicator of minor violations;
SP1 – required number of minor violations;
SP2 – number of minor violations identified.
The risk level indicator for violations (SP) shall be calculated on a scale from 0 to 100 points and determined by summing the indicators of significant and minor violations using the following formula:
SP = SPз + SPн, where:
SP – risk level indicator for violations;
SPз – indicator of significant violations;
SPн – indicator of minor violations.
The resulting value of the risk level indicator for violations shall be included in the calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria.
20. The calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 14 of these Criteria shall be performed on a scale from 0 to 100 points and shall be carried out using the following formula:
[Formula not displayed in the provided original text]
xi – indicator of the subjective criterion,
wi – specific weight of the subjective criterion indicator xi,
n – number of indicators.
The resulting value of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria determined in accordance with paragraph 14 of these Criteria shall be included in the calculation of the risk level indicator according to subjective criteria.
21. The values of the R indicator calculated for controlled entities (objects) shall be normalized to a range from 0 to 100 points. Data normalization shall be performed for each sample population (sample) using the following formula:
[Formula not displayed in the provided original text]
R – final risk level indicator according to subjective criteria for an individual controlled entity (object),
Rmax – maximum possible value on the scale of the risk level according to subjective criteria for controlled entities (objects) included in one sample population (sample) (upper boundary of the scale),
Rmin – minimum possible value on the scale of the risk level according to subjective criteria for controlled entities (objects) included in one sample population (sample) (lower boundary of the scale),
Rпром – intermediate risk level indicator according to subjective criteria, calculated in accordance with paragraph 18 of these Criteria.
Chapter 4. Inspection Checklists
22. Inspection checklists shall be drawn up for homogeneous groups of controlled entities (objects) and shall include requirements in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 132 of the Code and subject to the conditions specified in paragraph 2 of Article 143 of the Code.
23. Inspection checklists shall be drawn up in the form set out in Appendix 2 to this Joint Order.
Appendix 1to the Risk Assessment Criteriain the Field of Registration ofLegal Entities That AreCommercial Organizations
Degrees of Violations of Requirements by Controlled Entities (Objects) in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities That Are Commercial Organizations
Note. Appendix 1 as amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 17, 2026 No. 796 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 137 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its official publication).
Download
Download appears as a heading in the original text.
| No. | Criteria | Degree of violation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Inaccurate completion of information in the National Register of Business Identification Numbers | Gross |
| 2 | Registration actions in the presence of judicial acts and rulings (prohibitions, arrests) issued by judicial enforcement officers and law enforcement agencies | Gross |
| 3 | Registration actions involving violations of the procedure for the establishment, re-registration and reorganization of a legal entity, as established by legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan, or non-compliance of constituent documents with the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan | Gross |
| 4 | Registration actions where a transfer deed or separation balance sheet has not been submitted, or where provisions on legal succession of the reorganized legal entity are absent from such documents | Gross |
| 5 | Registration actions where the legal entity or the sole founder (participant) of the legal entity is an inactive legal entity | Gross |
| 6 | Registration actions where an individual is the sole founder (participant, member) and/or head of inactive legal entities | Gross |
| 7 | Carrying out registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has been declared legally incapable or has limited legal capacity | Gross |
| 8 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has been declared missing, declared deceased, registered as deceased, or their status has not been determined | Gross |
| 9 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has an unexpunged or outstanding criminal record for offences under Articles 237, 238 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan | Gross |
| 10 | Registration actions where, at the time of state registration, the founder (individual and/or legal entity), its founders, the head of the legal entity, the founder and/or head of a legal entity that is a founder (participant, member) of the legal entity are debtors under an enforcement document, except for a person who is a debtor in enforcement proceedings for the recovery of periodic payments and who has no arrears in enforcement proceedings for periodic recoveries exceeding three months | Gross |
| 11 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant) and/or head of a legal entity is included in the list of organizations and persons associated with the financing of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and/or in the list of organizations and persons associated with the financing of terrorism and extremism, in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, except for shares (participatory interests in the charter capital) confiscated and/or recovered pursuant to a court decision | Gross |
| 12 | Registration actions involving registration using lost and/or invalid identity documents of heads/founders (members, participants) | Gross |
| 13 | Carrying out registration actions where the package of documents required for registration actions is incomplete | Gross |
| 14 | Unjustified refusal to carry out registration actions | Gross |
| 15 | Failure to comply with the deadlines for carrying out registration actions | Gross |
| 16 | Requesting from service recipients documents that can be obtained from digital systems | Significant |
| 17 | Unjustified interruption of the period for carrying out registration actions | Significant |
| 18 | Improper maintenance and storage of registration files | Gross |
| Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Assessing the Degree of Risk in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities that are Commercial Organizations |
|---|
List of subjective criteria for determining the degree of risk in the field of registration of legal entities that are commercial organizations, in accordance with the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
| Form |
|---|
Download
| No. | Indicator of the subjective criterion | Source of information on the indicator of the subjective criterion | Weight by significance, points (the total must not exceed 100 points), wi | Conditions / values, xi | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Condition 1 / value | Condition 2 / value | ||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| For preventive control with a visit | |||||
| 1 | Submission of information on the number of registrations of legal entities that are commercial organizations | Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the entity subject to control | 50 | Timely submission / 0% | Failure to submit a report / 100% |
| 2 | Submission of information on the number of registrations of legal entities that are commercial organizations with violations of the deadline | Results of monitoring reports and information submitted by the entity subject to control | 50 | Timely submission / 0% | Failure to submit a report / 100% |
| Appendix 2 to the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2019 No. 350 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 9, 2019 No. 61 |
|---|
Inspection Checklist in the Field of Registration of Legal Entities and Record Registration of Their Branches and Representative Offices that are Commercial Organizations, in Accordance with the Entrepreneurial Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Note. Appendix 2 – as amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 15, 2023 No. 661 and the Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 18, 2023 No. 163 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the date of its first official publication); as amended by the Joint Order of the Minister of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 17, 2026 No. 796 and the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of National Economy of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 26, 2026 No. 137 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after its official publication).
With respect to the activities of branches of the Non-Profit Joint-Stock Company “State Corporation ‘Government for Citizens’” (hereinafter referred to as the registration authorities), carrying out state registration of legal entities and record registration of branches and representative offices
Name of the homogeneous group of entities (objects) subject to control
State body that ordered the inspection/preventive control with a visit to the entity (object) subject to control
Act on the appointment of an inspection with a visit to the entity (object) subject to control
(No., date)
Name of the entity (object) subject to control
(business identification number),
Location address
Download
| No. | List of Requirements | Complies with the Requirements | Does Not Comply with the Requirements |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
| 1 | Inaccurate entry of information in the National Register of Business Identification Numbers | ||
| 2 | Registration actions in the presence of judicial acts and orders (prohibitions, arrests) issued by judicial enforcement officers and law enforcement agencies | ||
| 3 | Registration actions involving violations of the procedure for the establishment, re-registration and reorganization of a legal entity established by legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan, or non-compliance of constituent documents with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan | ||
| 4 | Registration actions in the event of failure to submit a transfer deed or separation balance sheet, or the absence therein of provisions on the legal succession of the reorganized legal entity | ||
| 5 | Registration actions where the legal entity or the sole founder (participant) of the legal entity is an inactive legal entity | ||
| 6 | Registration actions where an individual is the sole founder (participant, member) and/or head of inactive legal entities | ||
| 7 | Carrying out registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has been declared legally incompetent or has limited legal capacity | ||
| 8 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has been declared missing, declared deceased, registered as deceased, or whose status has not been determined | ||
| 9 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant, member) and/or head of a legal entity has an unexpunged or unremoved criminal record for offences under Articles 237, 238 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan | ||
| 10 | Registration actions where, at the time of state registration, the founder (individual and/or legal entity), its founders, the head of the legal entity, the founder and/or head of a legal entity that is a founder (participant, member) of the legal entity are debtors under an enforcement document, with the exception of a person who is a debtor under enforcement proceedings for the recovery of periodic payments and who has no outstanding debt under enforcement proceedings for periodic collections exceeding three months | ||
| 11 | Registration actions where an individual who is a founder (participant) and/or head of a legal entity is included in the list of organizations and persons associated with the financing of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and/or in the list of organizations and persons associated with the financing of terrorism and extremism, in accordance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with the exception of shares (participatory interests in the charter capital) confiscated and/or recovered pursuant to a court decision | ||
| 12 | Registration actions involving lost and/or invalid identity documents of heads/founders (members, participants) | ||
| 13 | Carrying out registration actions where the complete set of documents required for registration actions has not been submitted | ||
| 14 | Unjustified refusal to carry out registration actions | ||
| 15 | Failure to comply with the deadlines for carrying out registration actions | ||
| 16 | Requesting from service recipients documents that can be obtained from digital systems | ||
| 17 | Unjustified interruption of the period for carrying out registration actions | ||
| 18 | Improper maintenance and storage of registration files |
Official(s):
Position, signature
Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)
Head of the controlled entity:
Position, signature
Surname, first name, patronymic (if any)
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Decision Resolution Lawyer Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Firm Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Rules Note Regulations Charter Article Commentary Resolution Regulations Protocol Draft Programme Rules Messages