On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation
Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 528, the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 1, 2023 No. 123, the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 271, and the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 190. Registered with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan on July 1, 2023 No. 33002.
Note of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan! Enters into force on July 1, 2023.
In accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 133 of the Social Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, WE HEREBY ORDER:
1. To approve the attached Criteria for assessing the presence of ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation, in accordance with the Annex to this Joint Order.
2. To declare the following Joint Orders invalid:
1) Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 22, 2014 No. 630, the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 26, 2014 No. 399, and the Minister of Healthcare and Social Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 19, 2014 No. 240, “On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation” (registered in the State Register of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 10013);
2) Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 27, 2021 No. 812, the Acting Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 27, 2021 No. ҚР ДСМ-135, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 27, 2021 No. 501, and the Acting Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 27, 2021 No. 611, “On Amendments to the Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 22, 2014 No. 630, the Minister of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 26, 2014 No. 399, and the Minister of Healthcare and Social Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 19, 2014 No. 240 ‘On Approval of the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation’” (registered in the State Register of Regulatory Legal Acts under No. 26134).
3. The Department for Combating Organized Crime of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan shall, in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, ensure:
1) state registration of this Joint Order with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
2) publication of this Joint Order on the Internet resource of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
3) within ten working days after the state registration of this Joint Order, submission to the Legal Department of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan of information on the implementation of the measures provided for in subparagraphs 1) and 2) of this paragraph.
4. Control over the implementation of this Joint Order shall be assigned to the Deputy Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan in charge of the relevant area, the Vice-Ministers of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan, and Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
5. This Joint Order shall enter into force on July 1, 2023 and shall be subject to official publication.
| Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan | __________ A. Giniyat |
|---|---|
| Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan | __________ G. Beisembayev |
| Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan | __________ T. Duysenova |
| Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan | __________ M. Akhmetzhanov |
| Annex to the Joint Order of the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 1, 2023 No. 123, the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 190, the Deputy Prime Minister – Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 271, and the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated June 30, 2023 No. 528 |
|---|
Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation
Chapter 1. General Provisions
1. These Criteria for assessing the presence of ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and deprivation (hereinafter referred to as the Criteria) have been developed in accordance with the Social Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan and determine the grounds for classifying persons as victims of ill-treatment (hereinafter referred to as the Victim) resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation.
2. The following concepts are used in these Criteria:
1) ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation – actions committed in the form of domestic violence, human trafficking, including trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, regardless of whether criminal proceedings have been initiated in connection with the actions committed;
2) victim – an individual against whom ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation has been committed, regardless of its form;
3) social maladjustment – disruption of an individual's interaction with the social environment;
4) social deprivation – restriction and/or deprivation of a person's (family's) ability to independently satisfy basic life needs;
5) identification of a victim of human trafficking – classification of a person as a victim of ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation due to actions related to human trafficking, including trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, in accordance with these Criteria.
Chapter 2. Assessment of the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation
3. A person claiming to have been subjected to ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation shall choose the gender of the person authorized to conduct the identification and, where necessary, an interpreter.
Identification of a minor shall be carried out in the presence of legal representatives and, in their absence, close relatives and/or bodies performing guardianship or trusteeship functions.
Identification of the person who has applied shall be carried out by an entity providing special social services jointly with the local executive body of districts and cities of regional and national significance, and the capital, which determines the direction of activities in the field of social protection and employment of the population (hereinafter referred to as the authorized body).
If an offence is identified (detected) by internal affairs bodies, identification of the person shall be carried out by internal affairs bodies jointly with the entity providing special social services and the authorized body.
If a person is identified by healthcare or education organizations, the internal affairs bodies shall be notified.
Footnote. Paragraph 3 as amended by Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 24, 2024 No. 719, the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 30, 2024 No. 76, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 385, and the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 273 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
4. When assessing the presence of ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation in cases of domestic violence, the actions committed against a person shall be grouped into the following categories:
Category 1 – physical violence;
Category 2 – psychological violence;
Category 3 – economic violence;
Category 4 – sexual violence.
Identification of the person who has applied shall be carried out by an entity providing special social services jointly with the authorized body.
If an offence in the sphere of domestic violence is identified (detected) by internal affairs bodies, identification of the person shall be carried out by internal affairs bodies jointly with the entity providing special social services and the authorized body.
If a person is identified by healthcare or education organizations, the internal affairs bodies shall be notified.
5. When conducting an assessment of the presence of ill-treatment, points shall be assigned for each category of actions in accordance with Appendix 1 to these Criteria, and the total number of points shall determine whether the person is classified as a victim.
6. A person shall be recognized as a victim as a result of actions related to domestic violence if the total number of points in one of the categories is 5 or more points.
If the person who has applied is identified as a victim of domestic violence, the entity providing special social services shall, within one working day, forward the assessment sheet together with the person's application to the authorized body in order to obtain permission to provide special social services, and, in the case of identification of a minor, to the body performing guardianship or trusteeship functions.
If the person who has applied is not identified as a victim of domestic violence, the provision of special social services shall be refused.
In accordance with the Administrative Procedural and Process-Related Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the person who has applied shall have the right to appeal an administrative action (inaction) related to the adoption of an administrative act.
7. When assessing the presence of ill-treatment resulting in social maladjustment and social deprivation in cases of human trafficking, including trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, the actions committed against a person shall be grouped into the following categories:
Category 1 – the purpose of human trafficking, including trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping;
Category 2 – actions committed against the person;
Category 3 – means used against the person;
Category 4 – harm caused to the person.
Identification of the person who has applied shall be carried out by an entity providing special social services jointly with the authorized body.
If a crime related to human trafficking is identified (detected) by internal affairs bodies, identification of the person shall be carried out by internal affairs bodies jointly with the entity providing special social services, the authorized body, and a non-profit organization.
If a person is identified by healthcare or education organizations, the internal affairs bodies shall be notified.
Footnote. Paragraph 7 as amended by Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 24, 2024 No. 719, the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 30, 2024 No. 76, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 385, and the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 273 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
8. When conducting an assessment of the presence of ill-treatment, points shall be assigned for each category of actions in accordance with Appendix 2 to these Criteria, and the total number of points shall determine whether the person is classified as a victim.
9. A person shall be recognized as a victim as a result of actions related to human trafficking, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, if the total number of points in each category is 5 or more points, with an overall result of 20 or more points.
A minor shall be recognized as a victim as a result of actions related to trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, if the total number of points in each category is 5 or more points, with an overall result of 15 or more points, with the exception of Category 3 (means used against the person).
10. If a pre-trial investigation has been initiated in connection with human trafficking, including trafficking in minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping, and the person has been recognized as a victim, their identification in accordance with Appendix 2 to these Criteria shall not be required.
11. Following the assessment of the presence of ill-treatment, the entity providing special social services, jointly with the authorized body and, where necessary, the internal affairs bodies and the body performing guardianship or trusteeship functions, which conducted the identification, shall prepare a report in accordance with Appendix 3 to these Criteria.
If the person who has applied is identified as a victim of human trafficking, the entity providing special social services shall, within one working day, forward the assessment sheet together with the person's application and the report to the authorized body in order to obtain permission to provide special social services, and, in the case of identification of a minor, to the body performing guardianship or trusteeship functions.
If the person who has applied is not identified as a victim of human trafficking, the provision of special social services shall be refused.
In accordance with the Administrative Procedural and Process-Related Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the person who has applied shall have the right to appeal an administrative action (inaction) related to the adoption of an administrative act.
| Appendix 1 to the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation, approved by the Joint Order |
|---|
Assignment of Points When Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation in Cases of Domestic Violence
Footnote. Appendix 1 – in the wording of Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 26, 2024 No. 1021, the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated January 6, 2025 No. 1, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 30, 2024 No. 510, and the Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated December 31, 2024 No. 375 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
Download
| No. | List of criteria for assessing the presence of ill-treatment in cases of domestic violence | Maximum indicators for assessing the presence of ill-treatment in cases of domestic violence |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Physical violence | |
| 2. | Infliction of beatings or commission of other violent acts causing physical pain | 3 points |
| 3. | Use of obscene language, offensive harassment, humiliation, damage to household items, and other actions expressing disrespect towards citizens who are in family and domestic relations with the offender, disturbing their peace, committed within an individual residential house or apartment | 2 points |
| 4. | Infliction of physical or mental suffering through systematic beatings or other violent acts | 5 points |
| 5. | Intentional infliction of bodily harm not dangerous to human life and of moderate severity, which did not result in consequences but caused a prolonged health disorder | 5 points |
| 6. | Intentional infliction of grievous bodily harm dangerous to human life, or infliction of grievous bodily harm resulting in loss of vision, speech, hearing, or any organ, or loss of an organ's functions, or expressed in permanent disfigurement of the face, as well as infliction of other bodily harm dangerous to life or causing a health disorder, or resulting in termination of pregnancy, mental disorder, drug addiction or toxicomania | 5 points |
| 7. | Psychological violence | |
| 8. | Rudeness, mockery, insult, threat, blackmail, stalking, and other actions (inaction) causing a person's negative emotional reaction and emotional pain | 3 points |
| 9. | Driving a person to suicide or attempted suicide through threats, ill-treatment, or systematic humiliation of the victim's human dignity | 5 points |
| 10. | Threat of murder or infliction of grievous bodily harm, as well as other serious violence against a person or destruction of property by arson, explosion, or other generally dangerous means, where there are sufficient grounds to fear that the threat will be carried out | 5 points |
| 11. | Ongoing stalking, forced migration | 5 points |
| 12. | Commission of domestic violence in the presence of a minor | 3 points |
| 13. | Economic violence | |
| 14. | Deprivation of identity documents, documents establishing ownership rights, or documents required to perform actions | 3 points |
| 15. | Deprivation of funds necessary for subsistence | 2 points |
| 16. | Deprivation of housing | 5 points |
| 17. | Deprivation of food necessary for subsistence | 4 points |
| 18. | Deprivation of clothing necessary for subsistence | 3 points |
| 19. | Sexual violence | |
| 20. | Rape, that is, sexual intercourse involving the use of violence or the threat of its use against the victim or other persons, or taking advantage of the victim's helpless condition | 5 points |
| 21. | Commission of indecent acts without the use of violence against a person known to be under fourteen years of age | 5 points |
| 22. | Coercion of a person into sexual intercourse, male homosexuality, lesbianism, or other acts of a sexual nature | 5 points |
| 23. | Forcing a person to undress, touching the body, indecent or degrading treatment, as well as blows to the genital organs and воздействие on them with objects, sexual assault | 5 points |
| Appendix 2 to the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation, approved by the Joint Order |
|---|
Assignment of Points When Assessing the Presence of Ill-Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation in Cases of Human Trafficking, Including Trafficking in Minors, Other Forms of Their Exploitation, and Kidnapping
Footnote. Appendix 2 as amended by Joint Order of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 24, 2024 No. 719, the Minister of Healthcare of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 30, 2024 No. 76, the Minister of Labour and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 385, and the Acting Minister of Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated September 25, 2024 No. 273 (shall enter into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication).
Note: The supplied original text ends at the heading and footnote of Appendix 2. The translation therefore also ends at that point. The phrase in item 23 has been rendered as “application of objects to them” in the intended English meaning.
Download
| No. | List of criteria for assessing the presence of cruel treatment in human trafficking, including minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping | Threshold indicators for assessing the presence of cruel treatment in human trafficking, including minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Purpose of human trafficking, including minors, other forms of their exploitation, as well as kidnapping | |
| 2. | Human trafficking for the purpose of sexual exploitation / sexual exploitation | 5 points |
| 3. | Human trafficking for the purpose of forced labor / forced labor | 5 points |
| 4. | Trafficking in minor children for the purpose of illegal adoption | 5 points |
| 5. | Human trafficking for the purpose of forcing a person to engage in begging / coercion to engage in begging | 5 points |
| 6. | Human trafficking for the purpose of illegal removal of human organs and tissues | 5 points |
| 6-1. | Human trafficking for the purpose of coercion to engage in unlawful activities / recruitment, transportation, transfer, harboring, receipt, as well as the commission of other acts for the purpose of coercion to engage in unlawful activities | 5 points |
| 6-2. | Other actions related to the exercise by the perpetrator of some or all of the powers of an owner in respect of a person | 5 points |
| 7. | Actions committed against a person | |
| 8. | Purchase and sale, other transactions (gift, barter, exchange, lease, leaving a person as security for the performance of an obligation under a transaction, transfer of a person for the purpose of obtaining any non-property benefits) | 5 points |
| 9. | Use by the perpetrator of forced labor, that is, any work or service required of a person through the use of violence or the threat of its use, or the threat of any punishment, which the person has not voluntarily offered to perform, except in cases provided for by the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan | 5 points |
| 10. | Use by the perpetrator of another person's engagement in prostitution or other sexual services, which means coercing a person into prostitution or the provision of other sexual services for the purpose of appropriating the income received or a part thereof, as well as without the perpetrator pursuing such a purpose | 5 points |
| 11. | Coercion of a person to engage in begging, that is, to commit an antisocial act involving soliciting money and/or other property from other persons | 5 points |
| 12. | Coercion by the perpetrator to engage in unlawful activities, that is, coercion of a person to commit an offense for the purpose of generating income or obtaining property benefits | 5 points |
| 13. | Recruitment – obtaining the victim's consent to perform any work or engage in any activity, including unlawful activity, where this is connected with the purpose of exploiting that person | 5 points |
| 14. | Transportation – intentional actions undertaken for the purpose of exploiting a person by moving that person from one place to another, including within the same populated locality | 5 points |
| 15. | Transfer – the direct transfer of a victim to a person for the purpose of exploitation | 5 points |
| 16. | Harboring – concealing a victim from law enforcement authorities, relatives and other persons | 5 points |
| 17. | Receipt – the direct receipt of a person for the purpose of exploitation or subsequent transfer | 5 points |
| 18. | Kidnapping for the purpose of exploitation | 5 points |
| 19. | Unlawful deprivation of liberty for the purpose of exploitation | 5 points |
| 20. | Means used against a person | |
| 21. | Use of violence dangerous to life and health, or the threat of such violence | 5 points |
| 22. | Use of weapons or objects used as weapons | 5 points |
| 23. | Deception or abuse of trust | 5 points |
| 24. | Abuse of official position | 5 points |
| 25. | Exploitation of material or other dependency | 5 points |
| 26. | Exploitation of a mental disorder or helpless condition | 5 points |
| 27. | Seizure, concealment or destruction of identity documents | 5 points |
| 28. | Harm caused to a person | |
| 29. | Infliction of beatings or other violent acts causing physical pain but not resulting in consequences | 5 points |
| 30. | Infliction of physical or mental suffering as a result of systematic beatings or other violent acts | 5 points |
| 31. | Infliction of harm to health that is not dangerous to human life and causes a prolonged health disorder | 5 points |
| 32. | Infliction of harm to health that is dangerous to human life and results in loss of sight, speech, hearing or any organ, or loss by an organ of its functions, or is expressed in permanent disfigurement of the face, as well as infliction of other harm to health causing a health disorder or resulting in termination of pregnancy, mental disorder, drug addiction or toxicomania | 5 points |
| Appendix 3 to the Criteria for Assessing the Presence of Cruel Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation, approved by a joint order |
|---|
Report on the Assessment of the Presence of Cruel Treatment Resulting in Social Maladjustment and Social Deprivation
1. Surname __________________________________________
2. First name ________________________________________
3. Patronymic (if any) _________________________________
4. Date and time _____________________________________
5. Place of completion (name and address of the institution) __________________________________________
6. Circumstances (those existing at the time of identification (for example, the presence of employees of organizations, accompanying persons) and information relating to the incident)
7. Information about what happened to the victim based on their interview (including the methods of the alleged cruel treatment, the time when the alleged cruel treatment was applied, and any existing complaints regarding their physical or psychological condition)
8. Surname, first name, patronymic (if any), and signature of the person authorized to carry out identification ______________________________________________
9. The personal data of a person identified as a victim of human trafficking shall be protected in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Personal Data and Their Protection".
Constitution Law Code Regulatory Act Decree Order Resolution Advocate Almaty Lawyer Legal Service Legal Consultation Civil Criminal Administrative Cases and Disputes Defense Arbitration Legal Company of Kazakhstan Law Office Court Cases Declaration Decree Order Resolution Decision Report Conclusion Application Conclusion Convention Contract Memorandum Methodology Norms Note Rules Program Charter Agreement Article Commentary Resolution Regulation Protocol Draft Program Rules Messages